Group members around a porch table
Comfortable After 60

Comfortable After 60: Stories & Discussions

Community · 51.6K members
Carol Brennan
Carol Brennan AdminNovember 21 · Pinned post
Holiday survey results

We Asked Our Members What They Wear Instead of a Bra on Long Holiday Days. 2,100 Women Answered.

Last November, Deborah posted from the passenger seat somewhere in Pennsylvania, five hours into a nine-hour drive, with her bra band digging into her ribs. More of you answered her than any post we had all year.

So this year we asked properly, before the travel starts. 2,100 of you answered. I've grouped the most-hearted answers by the four parts of a holiday day where you said the bra was worst: the travel, the kitchen, the photos and the evening. Then what most of you wear instead.

Where the bra hurt most on a holiday day

2,100 members answered. Members could pick more than one.

The long drive or the flight68%
The evening, when it finally came off61%
On my feet in the kitchen all day54%
The family photos47%
Deborah Kowalski
Deborah Kowalski66 · Toledo, Ohio · the post that started it

Nine hours to my daughter's in Raleigh for Thanksgiving. We're not even out of Pennsylvania and this bra band is cutting into my ribs so bad I can't sit back in the seat. The seatbelt sits right on top of it. Four more hours. Ladies, what do you wear on the travel days?

Deborah in the passenger seat pressing on her ribs where her bra band digs in
4.6K1,312 comments
68% of members · Part 1

The Long Drive and the Flight: Hours in a Seat With a Bra Band on Your Ribs

What members described: sitting for hours, the bra band rides up and settles on the lower ribs, and the underwire pushes up into the soft tissue under the bust every time you slump back in the seat. In the car the seatbelt presses on top of the band. On a plane you can't get up to fix it.

Marlene Ostrowski 67, Michigan

Six hours up to my son's in Traverse City every Christmas. I used to unhook my bra under my coat at the first rest stop and sit there with it loose the rest of the way. My husband thought I was carsick.

1.2KReply
Janice Pruitt 71, Arizona

Phoenix to Boston, five hours in a middle seat. My strap slid off my shoulder the whole flight and I had to keep reaching inside my shirt to push it back up with a stranger sitting right there. You can't exactly fix a bra in an airplane bathroom.

Janice on a plane pushing her bra strap back up under her shirt
968Reply
Brenda Haskins 70, Indiana

Janice, the strap thing! My shoulders slope more than they used to and the straps just won't stay. Tightening them only makes them dig in.

411Reply
54% of members · Part 2

All Day in the Kitchen: an Underwire Bra Digs In Every Time You Bend to the Oven

What members described: eight, ten hours on your feet. Every time you lean over the oven door or lift the roasting pan, the wire presses up into your ribs and the straps take the weight. The kitchen gets hot, and the band is where the sweat sits all afternoon.

Rita Caruso 73, New Jersey

I cook for nineteen on Thanksgiving. By the time the turkey comes out I'm basting with one hand and holding my underwire off my ribs with the other. My granddaughter took this one and I said delete it. She didn't.

Rita basting the turkey with one hand pressed under her bust where the underwire digs
1.4KReply
Sue Medina 62, New Mexico

Tamales on Christmas Eve, all day standing at the counter. The heat off the stove and that band. By four o'clock there's a red raw line under my bust that's still there the next morning.

733Reply
Joyce Whitfield 72, Georgia

Church dinner, then family dinner. I'm in the church hall kitchen from seven in the morning. I used to keep a spare soft bra in my purse to change into at lunch.

502Reply
47% of members · Part 3

The Family Photos: a Bra Band Roll Shows Under a Holiday Sweater

What members described: the band pushes up a roll across the back and under the arms that shows through a fitted sweater, and the straps show at the neckline. So you button the cardigan to the top and fold your arms in every picture with the grandkids.

Helen Moore 69, North Carolina

Every Christmas picture for ten years, same thing. Cardigan buttoned to my chin and my arms folded so nobody sees the bra lines. My daughter finally asked me why I always look cold.

Helen in a family Christmas photo with her cardigan buttoned and arms folded
1.1KReply
Peggy Lindstrom 68, Minnesota

I bought a nice red sweater for the family photo last year. Took one look at the back of it in the hall mirror, the bra band making two rolls, and went back to the baggy one.

644Reply
61% of members · Part 4

The Evening: Red Marks From the Bra Band and Straps That Last Into the Next Day

What members described: fourteen hours in the same bra, then the guest room. The band leaves a red line across the back, the straps leave grooves in the shoulders, and after 60 the skin there is thinner, so the marks take longer to fade. And the family is still up, so you can't take it off until bedtime.

Gail Park 65, Washington

This was me in my daughter's guest room at eleven at night. Took the bra off and looked over my shoulder in the mirror. I counted three red lines. They were still there at breakfast.

Red marks across a woman's back and shoulders from a bra band and straps
1.3KReply
Nora Callahan 74, Massachusetts

And you can't just go without, not at your son's house with your daughter-in-law's parents there. At a 40DD, without one, everything pulls on my neck and back by the afternoon.

897Reply
Carol Brennan
Carol Brennan AdminWhat members wear instead

Then we asked the part everyone wanted to know: what do you wear instead of a bra on a long holiday day? One answer came up more than all the others put together.

A tank top with the bra built in52%
A sports bra17%
Nothing at all14%
A soft bralette11%
Still a regular bra6%

The sports bra crowd said the same thing over and over: it's a fight to get on over stiff shoulders, and the band is just as tight. The bralette crowd said it doesn't hold a full bust through a long day. Going without works at home, not at the in-laws'.

The built-in-bra tank answers had one name in them again and again: the Freeform Tank. Here's why members said it works on the long days.

Why it lasts a whole holiday day

  • No band round the ribs. Nothing rides up and sits on your ribs in the car seat, and nothing for the seatbelt to press into.
  • No underwire. Bending to the oven door all day, there's no wire pushing up under the bust.
  • Straps as wide as three fingers. The weight spreads across a wide flat strap instead of a thin one, so they stay put on a sloping shoulder and don't press grooves in.
  • Shaped cups sewn into the lining. They hold you up from the front all day and come out of the wash the same shape they went in.
  • Smooth front and back. A square neckline and no band means no roll under a fitted sweater in the photos.
Nora Callahan 74, Massachusetts

I asked the question everybody asks: does it actually HOLD a 40DD? A friend from here turned hers inside out for me. Real shaped cups stitched in all the way round. Not a strip of elastic, not a loose pad. It holds me up all day and I've been through the wash with it twenty times.

The tank turned inside out: shaped cups sewn into the lining
1.9KTop answerReply
See the tank members wear on holiday days →
Deborah Kowalski
Deborah KowalskiUpdate · the drive back from Raleigh

OK ladies. I ordered three after everyone told me to. Nine hours home in the nude one with a cardigan over it. I sat back in the seat the whole way. Nothing on my ribs, nothing for the seatbelt to dig into. I didn't think about what I had on once. My husband asked why I wasn't fidgeting.

Deborah laughing in the passenger seat wearing the nude tank with an open cardigan
6.3K708 comments
Rita Caruso
Rita CarusoUpdate · Thanksgiving

Nineteen people, a twenty-two pound bird, and I wore the black one from six in the morning till the dishes were done. Lifted that roasting pan a dozen times. No wire. Nothing digging. And the gravy doesn't show on black.

Rita laughing at the stove stirring gravy, wearing the black tank
3.8K412 comments
Helen Moore
Helen MooreUpdate · Christmas afternoon

First Christmas picture in ten years where my arms aren't folded. The burgundy one, no cardigan. Smooth all the way round, no lines, no straps showing. My daughter printed this one for the fridge.

Helen laughing on the sofa with her grandchildren in the burgundy tank
5.1K536 comments
Janice Pruitt
Janice PruittUpdate · gate B22, on the way home

Five hours back to Phoenix in the light blue one. Not once did I reach inside my shirt for a strap. They're wide and they stay right where they are.

Janice at the airport gate in the light blue tank
2.7K298 comments
Members' packing list

What to Pack Instead of a Bra for the Holidays

The tip that came up most: don't take one, take three. They roll up flat in the suitcase and you'll want a fresh one every day you're away.

A suitcase on a bed with three folded tanks packed in it
  1. One for the travel day. Nude or light blue under a cardigan. Nothing on your ribs for the drive or the flight.
  2. One for the big day. Black for the kitchen, burgundy for the photos.
  3. One for the trip home. Wash the others in the sink at your daughter's; they hang dry overnight and the cups keep their shape.

Six colours, and you pick each one:

Nudetravel days
Blackthe kitchen
Burgundyholiday photos
Light Bluethe flight
Whiteunder light blouses
Coffeeunder cardigans

Holiday mail slows down every week from December on, so members who travel order early.

Members' pick for the holidays
Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

★★★★★ 11,482 reviews
Most chosen5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free£17.99 a tank
£299.99£89.99
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free£19.99 a tank · the packing-list three
£179.99£59.99
1 TankTry one first
£59.99£29.99
  • No band, no wire, no hooks — nothing on your ribs in the car seat
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — they stay put through the whole day
  • Cups sewn into the lining — hold their shape wash after wash
  • Six colours, S to 5XL — mix colours in one order
Check Availability →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Wear it through the holidays. If it isn't right for you, send it back within 45 days.
Carol Brennan
Carol Brennan AdminA few more from the thread
Marlene Ostrowski 67, Michigan

Drove to Traverse City in mine. No rest-stop unhooking this year. My husband said it was the first Christmas drive I didn't complain about, which I did not appreciate.

842Reply
Sue Medina 62, New Mexico

Tamale day in the black one. No band means nothing under my bust for the sweat to sit in. No red line the next morning.

519Reply
Peggy Lindstrom 68, Minnesota

Wore the red sweater over the nude one. Checked the back in the hall mirror. Smooth. I'm in the middle of the photo this year.

677Reply
Brenda Haskins 70, Indiana

Pulls on over my head, so no fighting hooks with stiff hands in a hotel bathroom at 5am before the flight. That alone.

455Reply

Questions From the Thread

Will it really hold a full bust all day?

The cups are shaped and sewn into the lining, and the whole fitted tank carries the weight from the wide straps down. Sizes run S to 5XL, and the chart on the order page goes up to 40DDD-G and 44C-DD.

Can I wear it on its own or does it need a top over it?

Both. It has a square neckline and a smooth front, so it looks like an ordinary tank on its own, and it sits flat under a sweater or cardigan.

Can I wash it in a sink while I'm travelling?

Yes. Rinse it, roll it in a towel and hang it; it's dry by morning. At home, machine wash cold. The cups are stitched in, so they keep their shape.

Is it hard to get on with stiff shoulders?

It pulls on over the head the way a T-shirt does, and there is nothing to fasten afterwards.

What if the size isn't right?

You have 45 days. If it isn't right, send it back under the guarantee.

See the Early Black Friday Offer →Buy 4 Get 4 Free while stock lasts

Comfortable After 60: Stories & Discussions is a community of women sharing what works for them. Round-ups like this one are compiled from members' answers; names and details are changed for privacy.