6 Reasons Mom Stopped Wearing the Bras You Bought Her, From 2,316 Daughters in Our Community (#6 Is What She Wears Every Day Now)
We asked members one question: what happened to the bras you bought your mother? The answers were the same from Maine to Arizona. So was the thing that finally worked.
It started with one post from Karen, a member in Ohio. Within a week it had more replies than anything we have shared this year. Here it is first, because every one of us recognised it.

I bought my mom six bras in two years. Front-closing, a sports bra, the soft ones from the catalog, one from the fitting place at the mall. She wore none of them. They are still in her drawer with the tags on.
I finally asked her why, and she said, "Karen, I just can't do them anymore." Has anyone else been through this?

We read every reply. Six reasons came up again and again, and almost none of them were about the bra being the wrong size. They were about what has changed in our mothers' bodies, and what a bra asks of a body at 80.
She Can't Reach the Bra Hooks Behind Her Back Anymore, and She's Too Proud to Say So

Fastening a bra at the back is one of the hardest movements in getting dressed. Both shoulders have to rotate inward and lift up between the shoulder blades at the same time, while the fingers line up hooks about a quarter of an inch wide without being able to see them.
That reach behind the back is one of the first movements stiff shoulders give up. Add arthritis in the knuckles and many women can't feel the hook catch at all. So Mom tries three or four times, then puts the bra back in the drawer.
And she doesn't tell you. Members said the same thing over and over: their mothers would rather go without than ask a daughter to fasten their underwear.

I only found out because I came over early one Sunday and heard her in the bedroom, muttering at the hooks. She'd been doing that every morning for a year and never said a word to me.
Lisa M., 47, Georgia · her mom is 79Bra Straps Dig Grooves Into Her Shoulders by Lunchtime

Thin bra straps carry the weight of the bust on two narrow strips across the top of the shoulders. After 75, the skin there is thinner and there is less padding underneath it, so the same strap presses deeper.
Shoulders also slope more with age, so the straps slide off. Mom tightens them to stop the sliding, and then they dig in harder. The red marks can still be there hours after she takes the bra off.

When I helped Mom change after her hip surgery, I saw two red dents on her shoulders. She said they'd been there for years. Years! She thought that was just what a bra does.
Denise K., 58, Pennsylvania · her mom is 83The Bra Band Squeezes Her Ribs Every Hour She Sits
Most of a bra's hold comes from the elastic band pulled tight around the ribcage. Our mothers sit far more than they used to: in the recliner, at the table, in the car on the way to appointments.
When she sits, the band rides up and bunches under the bust, pressing into her ribs and stomach. After a meal it gets tighter. Many members said their mother's first move on getting home was to reach under her blouse and pull the band down.

Every Sunday after church, Mom would get in my car and the first thing she did was tug the bra band down off her ribs. Every single week. I just thought it was a habit.
Teresa G., 61, Texas · her mom is 86Front-Closing Bras and Sports Bras Didn't Fix the Hooks or the Band
Almost every member had already tried the obvious fixes. These are the ones that came up most, and why the bras ended up back in the drawer.

I'm a nurse and I still bought Mom the wrong thing three times. The front-closing one was the worst. She could see the clasp, she just couldn't squeeze it shut.
Michelle P., 45, Ohio · her mom is 78Without a Bra, Mom Felt Self-Conscious at Family Dinners

When the hooks, straps and band all hurt, a lot of mothers simply stop wearing a bra. That solves the pain, but members said it brought something else. Without support, the weight pulls on Mom's neck and upper back by the afternoon, and she knows things don't sit the way they used to.
So she keeps a cardigan buttoned in July. She folds her arms in family photos. Some mothers stopped coming to the table when company came.

Mom stopped wearing one after her shoulder surgery. She kept her cardigan buttoned at every Sunday dinner, even in August, with her arms crossed. She didn't laugh the way she used to. I didn't put it together until I read Karen's post.
Angela Russo, 52, New Jersey · her mom Ruth is 81What Members' Mothers Wear Every Day Now: a Tank Top With the Bra Built In
When we read the replies about what finally worked, one answer came up more than every other answer put together: a soft tank top with the bra built into it. No hooks, no clasp, no band, no wire. Member after member named the same one, the Freeform Tank.

It answers each of the five reasons above in turn:
Why mothers keep wearing it
- No hooks to reach. It pulls on over the head with the arms at about shoulder height, and there is nothing to fasten afterwards.
- Straps as wide as three fingers. The weight spreads across a wide strap instead of a thin one, and wide straps stay put on sloping shoulders.
- No band around the ribs. Nothing rides up or bunches under the bust when she sits all afternoon.
- Real support. Shaped cups are sewn permanently into the lining, so they hold her and can't fold or fall out in the wash.
- It looks like a nice top. A square neckline and a smooth front. She wears it on its own at home, or under a cardigan to church.


So many of you told me about these tanks that I ordered Mom three. She put the first one on by herself before I'd even got my coat off. She has worn one every day since. Six bras in two years, and this is the only thing she has ever asked me to buy more of.


Mom in her black one at Sunday dinner. No cardigan, no folded arms. She told the whole table the story about Dad and the canoe. My kids hadn't heard her laugh like that in a long time.


What We're Getting Mom This Year
The question that came up most once the tank threads started: "What do I get Mom for Christmas?" A lot of members have answered it the same way. Instead of one more bra she won't wear, a set of tanks in her colours, so there is a clean one for every day of the week.

Pick her colours. There are six, and you choose the colour for each tank in the set:
Members' tips for ordering for Mom:
- Go by the size she wears now. The order page has a chart with bra size and top size side by side, S to 5XL. If you only know her shirt size, use that. Between two sizes, choose the larger one; it goes on more easily.
- Get enough for a week. Most members chose the five-tank set: one for each weekday while the others are in the wash.
- Ship it straight to her. Put her address in as the shipping address at checkout. US shipping is free.
- Order early in the season. Holiday mail gets slower every week from December on.
The Freeform Tank
- No hooks, no clasp — nothing to reach behind her back for
- Pulls on over the head — one movement, then she's dressed
- No band, no wire — nothing squeezing her ribs when she sits
- Straps as wide as three fingers — six colours, S to 5XL
More From Our Members
Replies from daughters who bought the tank for their mothers, and from a few of the mothers.

I sent Mom five for her birthday, one in every colour but white. She called to tell me which one she was wearing that day. Every day for a week.

My daughter sent me three and I was sure I wouldn't like it. I haven't put a bra on since. I don't wait for anyone to help me get dressed now.

No more muttering at the hooks. Mom says it is the first thing I've bought her in years that she actually wears.

The red dents on her shoulders were gone in about a week. She wears the light blue one around the house and the black one to church.
Questions Daughters Ask
Can Mom really put it on by herself with stiff shoulders?
It goes on over the head the way a T-shirt does, with the arms at about shoulder height, and there is nothing to fasten afterwards. If she can put on a T-shirt, she can usually put this on alone.
Will it hold her if she has a full bust?
The cups are shaped and sewn into the lining, and the whole tank carries the weight from the wide straps down. Sizes run S to 5XL, and the chart on the order page goes up to 40DDD-G and 44C-DD.
Can I ship it straight to Mom's house?
Yes. Enter her address as the shipping address at checkout. Shipping within the US is free.
What if it isn't the right size?
You have 45 days. If it isn't right for her, send it back under the guarantee.
How does it wash?
Machine wash cold and hang to dry; it dries overnight. The cups are stitched in, so they come out of the wash the same shape they went in.
Daughters Caring for Mom is a community of women looking after their mothers. Round-ups like this one are compiled from members' replies.