I Was Sure Built-In-Bra Tanks Were a Gimmick for a 38DD Like Me. I Wrote Down 6 Objections and Wore One for a Month to Check Every One.
It won't hold me. The cups will fold in the wash. It'll be hot. It'll show my back roll. The sizing is a lottery. I had a list, and I wanted to be right. Here is what thirty days of wearing it actually showed, one objection at a time.
I'll be straight with you, because that's what people who follow this page know me for. When my daughter Karen sent me a tank top with a bra built into it this summer, I didn't open the bag for six weeks.
I'm 68 and a 38DD. I have worn an underwire bra nearly every day since I was fifteen. I've tried the wireless ones, the "comfort" ones off the TV, and the shelf-bra camisoles from the department store. Every one of them let me down somewhere. So I knew exactly what this was: a camisole with foam in it, sold to women my age with a picture of a smiling lady on the front.
Karen didn't argue with me. She said, "Fine. Write down everything you think is wrong with it. Then wear it for a month and check." So on the first of September, at the kitchen table, I wrote my objections on the back of an envelope. Here's the list exactly as I wrote it.
- It's a camisole with foam in itWrong
- It won't hold a 38DDWrong
- The cups will fold in the washWrong
- It'll be hotWrong
- It'll show my back rollWrong
- The sizing is a lotteryWrong
You can see how it ended. Every one is crossed out. But I don't expect you to take a crossed-out list on trust, because I wouldn't. So here is what I actually did to check each one, and what I found.
A Built-In-Bra Tank Is Not a Camisole With Loose Foam Pads in It

The shelf-bra camisoles I've bought have a strip of elastic under the bust and two thin round pads tucked into a pocket. The pads slide, they fold, and in a 38DD they hold nothing. That's what I expected to find.
So before I'd even try it on, I turned it inside out. The cups are shaped and sewn into the lining, stitched all the way round each one. There's no pocket and no pad to take out. They are part of the top itself.
A Built-In-Bra Tank Held My 38DD From 7am to Bedtime, Stairs and Laundry Included

This was the big one. Anything without a wire, I'd always found, either flattens me into one shape or lets everything drop by lunchtime. So I didn't baby it. I wore it on a full ordinary day: laundry up and down the stairs, the grocery store, an hour weeding, my grandson on my lap at supper.
At nine that night I stood in front of the hall mirror. I was sitting at the same height I was at seven in the morning. I checked again the next night, and the next.
Twenty Washes in a Month, and the Cups Never Folded Once

Every shelf-bra cami I've owned came out of its first wash with the pads folded in half and creased, and I'd spend five minutes in the morning poking them flat. So I was hard on this one on purpose. I washed it nearly every evening in the machine with my towels and hung it over the bath overnight. Twenty washes by the end of September.
The cups came out the same shape every single time. There's nothing loose in there to fold, because they are stitched in place all the way round.
A Built-In-Bra Tank Was Cooler Than My Bra in an 88-Degree Garden

I assumed a top with cups built in would be a bra with extra fabric round it, which is the last thing I want in summer. Then we got that hot spell in the second week of September and I spent two hours in the garden in it.
When I came in, there was no wet line under my bust and nothing to peel off. With my bra, by that point I'd be unhooking it in the kitchen before I'd even washed my hands.
The Roll on My Back Was My Bra Band, Not My Weight


Same grey T-shirt, same hallway, same week. I didn't lose a pound.
I've stopped wearing knit tops because of the ridge across my back. I'd always put it down to my age and my weight, and I assumed anything snug would only make it worse.
Karen took the two pictures above in the hallway, three days apart, in the same thin T-shirt. On the left is my bra. On the right is the tank. The roll is gone.
Bra Sizing Was a Lottery for Forty Years. This Tank Fit the First Time.

I've been measured four times in ten years and walked out with four different bra sizes. Ordering anything that holds you up online always meant guessing, for me.
This tank comes in ordinary sizes, small to 5XL, and the order page has a chart that goes by the bra size you already wear. A 38DD put me in the 2XL, and the 2XL fit the first time. Karen's tip, which I'll pass on: if you're between two sizes, take the larger.
My Scorecard on Built-In-Bra Tanks After 30 Days
| My objection | What a month showed | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| A camisole with foam in it | Cups sewn into the lining | Wrong |
| Won't hold a 38DD | Same height at 9pm as 7am | Wrong |
| Cups will fold in the wash | 20 washes, never folded | Wrong |
| It'll be hot | Cooler than my bra at 88° | Wrong |
| It'll show my back roll | The roll was the band | Wrong |
| Sizing is a lottery | Fit first time off the chart | Wrong |
I Haven't Worn a Bra Since September
I wanted to be right about this. I'm not often wrong about what works for a woman my age, and I don't enjoy saying so in public. But at the end of the month I ordered two more, a burgundy and a black, and my underwire bras are in a bag for the church clothing drive.
If you're as suspicious as I was, here's what it actually is, in plain words:
- Cups sewn into the lining, so they come out of the wash the same shape they went in
- Straps as wide as three fingers, flat, so they don't dig in or slide off a sloping shoulder
- No band, no wire, no hooks, so nothing rolls, pinches or needs reaching behind you
- A square neckline that pulls on over your head and looks like a nice plain top
It's called the Freeform Tank. It comes in light blue, white, nude, black, burgundy and coffee, small to 5XL.
The Freeform Tank
- Cups sewn into the lining — they can't fold or shift in the wash
- Holds a full bust — the whole fitted top carries the weight
- No band, no wire, no hooks — no back roll, pulls on over your head
- Six colours, S to 5XL — free US shipping
Your Questions About Built-In-Bra Tanks, and My Answers
From the comments on my post about the list. I've answered the ones that came up most.
From the biggest skeptic I know,Margaret