We Asked 1,200 Women Over 60 What Changed After They Stopped Wearing an Underwire. These 7 Answers Came Up Most.
Aching shoulders by dinnertime, red lines under the band, a roll across the back of every top. We asked readers who gave up their underwire bras what was different afterwards. Their answers were remarkably alike.

One of the 1,200 readers who answered, filling in her survey at the kitchen table.
Every few months we put one question to our readers. This time it came from a letter: a reader in Ohio wrote that she had finally stopped wearing an underwire bra at 66, and that "four or five things changed that I didn't expect." She wanted to know if it was just her.
It was not. We asked every reader over 60 who had stopped wearing an underwire in the past two years one open question: what changed? No tick boxes, no suggestions. Then we read every answer and counted how often the same things came up.
How we ran it
1,200 women aged 60 to 84 answered, from 46 states. Bra sizes ran from 34B to 46G, and more than half wore a D cup or larger. Readers could name as many changes as they liked, so the figures below add up to more than 100%.
What changed after the underwire went
Share of the 1,200 readers who named each changeShoulders Stopped Aching By Evening Once the Thin Underwire Bra Straps Were Gone

This was the most common answer by a distance, and almost every reader put it the same way: the ache across the tops of the shoulders that used to arrive around four in the afternoon simply stopped arriving.
Here is why it happens. An underwire bra holds the bust up with a band and two straps. As the band stretches, or rides up the back during the day, more of the weight moves onto the straps, and most bra straps are less than an inch wide. That is the full weight of the bust hanging on two thin strips of elastic from breakfast to bedtime. Readers with a D cup or larger felt it most.
The readers who stopped hurting had mostly moved to a top with straps about two inches wide and a fitted body that takes part of the weight from the sides, so no single narrow line carries it.

By six o'clock I used to sit with a heating pad across my shoulders. I haven't plugged it in since August.
Joyce H., 67 · Ohio · wore underwire 44 years
The grooves in my shoulders were so deep my granddaughter asked what they were. They've filled back in.
Beverly O., 71 · Maryland · 40DDThe Red Marks Under the Bra Band Stopped Showing Up at Bedtime

Many readers said they had stopped noticing the red lines years ago, because they were always there: one straight across the back, a curve under each arm where the wire sat, two grooves on the shoulders.
An underwire bra stays in place by pressing in. The band grips the ribs and the wire presses against the chest wall. After 60, skin is thinner, there is less padding underneath it, and it takes longer to recover from pressure, so a mark that faded in ten minutes at 40 can still be there hours later. Some readers had bruising on one side where the wire rubbed.
With no band and no wire there is nothing pressing in a line, and readers said the marks were gone within a few weeks.

Twenty years of a red line under my bust every night, and a sore spot on the left side where the wire dug in. Both gone in about three weeks.
Patricia L., 64 · Minnesota · 36DBacks Looked Smoother Under Tops Without a Bra Band Pushing Up a Roll

The bulge across the back that shows through a knit top is one of the things readers said they had blamed on their weight. Most of them were wrong about the cause.
A bra band is a tight strip of elastic around the ribcage. After 60, the skin and soft tissue on the back are looser, and the band pushes that tissue up above it and down below it. That is the roll. Take the band away and the same tissue lies flat, which is why so many readers said the roll disappeared the first day, not after a diet.

I wore a cardigan over everything because of the bulge the band made. Last Sunday I wore a fitted knit to church with nothing over it.
Carmen R., 66 · Texas · 38DD
My daughter took a photo of me from behind at the lake and I didn't ask her to delete it. That's a first.
Sandra K., 62 · Pennsylvania · 36CGetting Dressed Got Faster With No Bra Hooks to Fasten Behind the Back

Readers with arthritis in their hands or a stiff shoulder wrote some of the longest answers. Fastening a bra means twisting both arms behind your back and pinching a hook you cannot see. Those are the two movements stiff joints lose first: the shoulder turning inward, and the fingertips gripping something small.
Several readers said they had started hooking the bra at the front and twisting it round, or asking a husband to do it. What they wear now goes on over the head with the arms barely raised, and there is nothing to fasten.

With my hands, those hooks took five minutes some mornings, and some mornings my husband had to do them. Now it goes over my head and I'm dressed.
Margie T., 73 · Georgia · rheumatoid arthritisSleeping Got Easier With No Underwire Pressing Into the Ribs at Night

This surprised us. Fuller-busted readers said that lying on their side with no support at all pulls and aches, and that sleeping in an underwire was out of the question because the wire presses into the ribs the moment you lie down.
Many of them now wear the same soft top to bed that they wear all day: shaped support with no wire and no band, so there is nothing hard to press into them when they turn over.

I'm a 40DD and lying on my side without anything hurt. I never could sleep in a bra. I sleep in the black one now and I don't think about it.
Helen B., 69 · Wisconsin · 40DDReaders Stopped Buying Bras That Don't Fit the Body They Have Now

A lot of readers described the same drawer: a dozen bras, most barely worn, several with the tags still on. After menopause the ribcage often gets smaller while the bust gets fuller and sits lower, so the band size and the cup size both move, and they keep moving. Readers said they had been measured three and four times and come home with a different size each time.
What they wear now is sized like a top, S to 5XL, picked from the bra size they already know. And because the cups are sewn into the lining instead of sitting loose in a pocket, they come out of the wash the same shape they went in, so it is not another thing to replace in six months.

I added it up. I'd spent over four hundred dollars on bras in two years and I wore two of them.
Rita F., 65 · New Jersey · 38D
Every bra I owned went to the church clothing drive. Five tanks in the drawer, and that's the whole drawer now.
Gwen H., 70 · Oregon · 42DFriends Asked If They'd Lost Weight. What They'd Lost Was the Bra Band.

One in three readers said somebody asked whether they had lost weight. None of them had. Two things change how a torso looks under a top: the roll the band pushes up across the back and under the arms, and a bust that sits lower once a tired band has stretched. Remove the band and lift the bust with shaped cups, and the line from shoulder to waist is one smooth line again.

At my nephew's wedding three people asked if I'd lost weight. Same weight. No band making a roll under my dress.
Donna P., 68 · Florida · 38DDWhat They Wear Instead of an Underwire Bra
We did not ask what readers switched to. They told us anyway. Seven in ten of the readers who described what they wear now named a tank top with the bra built into it, and most of those named the same one: the Freeform Tank.
We looked at why that one kept coming up. Shelf-bra camisoles from the department store have a strip of elastic and a loose foam pad in a pocket, and readers said the pads folded in the wash and gave no lift. The Freeform is built differently.

- Shaped cups sewn into the lining all the way round, so they hold you up and keep their shape in the wash.
- No band, no wire, no hooks. Nothing pressing a line into your ribs or your back.
- Straps two inches wide, flat, so the weight spreads across the shoulder instead of cutting into it.
- Square neckline and a smooth front, so it passes as a plain top on its own or under a cardigan.
- Pulls on over the head. Six colours, sizes S to 5XL, chosen from your usual bra size.
The Freeform Tank
Readers Who Made the Switch

I'm a 42DDD and I didn't believe a tank could hold me. It does, and by the end of the day it holds me better than the underwire did.
Ellen W., 72 · Arizona · 42DDD
I bought five so I could mix the colours. The nude one is under everything I own, and nobody can tell there's a bra in it.
Nora B., 63 · Virginia · 38C
It took me two weeks to stop reaching behind my back for hooks that weren't there. My shoulders noticed before I did.
Faye L., 75 · Michigan · 36DD