Dear Daughters: Mom Says Her Bra Hurts But Refuses To Go For A Fitting
Dear Daughters,
My mom is 82 and still runs her own house, and her bra is hurting her. At the kitchen table I watch her hook two fingers under the strap and lift it off her shoulder. When I helped her change last month there was a red line all the way round her ribs.

Some mornings she phones me to come and do the hooks because her shoulder won't go behind her back. I can tell she hates asking.
I've suggested a proper fitting at the department store three times. She won't go. She says she is not standing in a changing room in her underwear with a stranger and a tape measure at her age. So I bought her two new bras a size bigger, thinking looser would be kinder. They're still in her drawer with the tags on.
Some days she doesn't wear one at all, and then she won't answer the door. What am I supposed to do?
Stuck in the Middle, Ohio
Dear Stuck,
Let her skip the fitting. I mean that. Your mom is right, just not for the reason she thinks.
When my mother was 80 I talked her into a fitting. She went to please me and came home with a beautifully fitted bra that hurt her exactly as much as the old one. A fitting makes the band fit better. The band is what hurts.
Your letter struck a nerve: 1,240 members wrote in this week, and most of us have stood exactly where you're standing. Here is what we've worked out between us about why a bra starts to hurt after 60, and why it gets worse in a mother's eighties.
Why Mom's bra hurts now when it didn't at 50
The bra band does nearly all the work, on thinner skin
Most of us assumed the straps hold a bra up. They don't. About 80 percent of the lift comes from the band pulled tight round the ribs, which is why a fitter makes it so snug. At 50 that left a faint mark that was gone by morning.

In her eighties the skin is thinner and there is less padding under it, so the same pressure goes straight onto the ribs, on the same strip of skin, about 14 hours a day. The red line you saw is the band.
Bra hooks sit behind her back, where her shoulders can't go anymore
Fastening a bra means reaching both hands up between the shoulder blades and working three tiny hooks by feel. Shoulders stiffen with age and fingers lose their grip, so she twists the bra round to the front and drags it back, or she waits for you.

Thin bra straps carry whatever the band doesn't
Most bra straps are about half an inch wide. They sit on two narrow lines across the top of a shoulder that has lost its padding, and that's the groove your mom lifts the strap off at the table. If she tightens them to stop them slipping, they press in deeper.

What not to buy her (members have tried all of these)

What members' mothers wear now
When we asked members what finally worked, one answer came up again and again: a tank top with the bra built in. Not a shelf cami. This one is called the Freeform Tank, and here is why it suits a mother in her seventies or eighties:
- Shaped cups sewn into the lining for good. They hold her the way a bra would, and they can't fold or shift in the wash.
- No band round her ribs. The lift comes from the cups and the fitted body of the tank, so nothing presses on one strip of skin all day.
- No hooks. It goes on over her head like any top, so she gets dressed by herself.
- Straps as wide as three fingers. They spread the weight across the whole top of the shoulder instead of pressing a groove into it.
- A square neckline and a long hem. It looks like a proper top, so she's dressed if the doorbell goes.


And the part that matters most for your mom: there is no fitting. It's ordered by her T-shirt size, S to 3XL. If she wears a medium T-shirt, she orders a medium tank. Nobody needs a tape measure, a changing room or a stranger.
Three things I'd tell you, daughter to daughter
- Order her T-shirt size, not her bra size. Look at the label in a T-shirt she wears every week. If you'd rather check her bra size too, the order page has a chart for that.
- Let her try it on alone, in her own bedroom, with the door shut. That's the only fitting she ever wanted.
- Get her three. She'll wear one every day and want one in the wash, and the nude one goes under her blouses.
The Freeform Tank
- Cups sewn in, no band, no wire, no hooks
- Ordered by T-shirt size, S to 3XL
- Six colours
More letters this week
Dear Daughters, my mother is 79 and has arthritis in both hands. She can't do her bra hooks anymore, so I drive over at seven every morning before work to do them. She apologises every single time.
Every Morning in Tampa
Dear Every Morning, there are no hooks on the tank to do. It goes on over her head and pulls down, so the only thing her hands need to manage is the hem. Several members told us the seven o'clock visit turned into a ten o'clock coffee.

Dear Daughters, Mom is 86 and a 40DD. She says nothing without an underwire will ever hold her up, and she won't hear another word about it.
Doubtful in Phoenix
Dear Doubtful, that was most of our mothers' first objection. The underwire was never what held her up: the tight band was, and that's what's been hurting her. The tank's cups are full, shaped and sewn in, the straps are three fingers wide, and it's made up to 3XL for fuller busts. Ask her to give it one day.

Dear Daughters, I do Mom's laundry, and her bras come out of the machine with the wire poking through and the band stretched. I'm replacing them every few months and she still says they hurt.
Laundry Day in Kentucky
Dear Laundry Day, there's no wire in the tank to work loose and no band to stretch out. The cups are stitched into the lining all the way round, so they come out of the wash the same shape they went in. Members wash them on gentle with everything else.
Stuck on what to get Mom this year?
Every December a few hundred members ask the same thing: what do you get a mother who says she doesn't need anything? This year a lot of you are getting her three tanks in her favourite colours. It's something she'll wear every day, it ends the bra that's been hurting her, and she never has to go near a fitting room.

Members wrote back

I fastened my mother's bra for two years and never knew how much she minded until she didn't need me to. She put the nude one on herself the first morning and came out to the kitchen grinning.
Teresa B. · Wisconsin · Mom is 84 412
I was driving over at seven every morning to do her hooks. Now I go over at ten and we have coffee. That's the whole review.
Angela M. · Florida · Mom is 79 377
Mom is a 40DD and swore she needed the wire. The red marks under her bust have gone and she's stopped tugging at her straps at the table.
Kim S. · Arizona · Mom is 86 268
The line round her ribs had been there so long I thought it was just her skin. A few weeks in the tank and it's gone. I wish someone had told me five years ago.
Rosa G. · Texas · Mom is 81 231