A Bra Fitter Ranked 9 Bras Women Over 60 Wear. The Band Decided Every Score.
Underwire, wireless, front-closure, sports bra, bralette, posture bra, shelf cami, no bra at all, and a built-in-bra tank. One fitter, six checks at 6PM, a letter grade for each. Only one got an A.
For 24 years Joan Delaney fitted bras in the lingerie department of a department store in Columbus, Ohio. She estimates she measured more than 20,000 women. The ones over 60 nearly all walked in saying the same sentence: "I think I need a different size."
"Most of them didn't," Joan told us. "They'd been a 38C for ten years and they were still a 38C. What had changed was what the band was doing to them by the end of the day. I'd ask them to come back at six o'clock instead of ten in the morning, and then I could see it."
So we asked her to do exactly that, one more time, for our readers: grade the nine things women over 60 actually wear, not in a fitting room at 10AM, but at 6PM after a full day.
How Joan graded them
- Band dig: is the band pressed into the ribs by 6PM, with a red line when it comes off?
- Band roll: does the band push the skin on the back into a roll that shows under a fitted top?
- Riding up: has the band climbed up the back since the morning?
- Strap grooves: have the straps pressed grooves into the tops of the shoulders?
- Getting it on: on at 8AM with stiff hands or a stiff shoulder, without help?
- Still supported at 6PM: is the bust still held, or has she given up on it?
Notice that four of the six checks are about one part of the bra. "When a woman over 60 tells me her bra hurts," Joan said, "nine times out of ten she's describing the band."
The ranking









The full report card
| Option | Band dig | Band roll | Riding up | Strap grooves | Getting it on | Support at 6PM | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bra tank | A | A | A | A | A | A | A |
| Bralette | B | C | B | C | B | F | C |
| No bra | A | A | A | A | A | F | C |
| Shelf cami | C | D | C | D | A | F | D |
| Front-closure | D | D | C | D | C | C | D |
| Wireless | D | D | D | D | F | C | D |
| Sports bra | D | C | B | C | F | B | D |
| Posture bra | F | F | C | D | D | B | F |
| Underwire | F | D | D | F | F | B | F |
Grades are Joan's, from 162 test days (18 women, 9 options each) checked at 6PM.
From last place to first
Underwire bra
F
The most common bra in the group and the worst at 6PM. An underwire holds the bust up from below, which means the band has to be pulled tight around the ribs and the wire pressed against the body all day. At 6PM, 16 of the 18 women had a red line under the bust where the wire sat and a deeper one around the back where the band did.
"The wire doesn't move with you," Joan said. "You sit down, you lean over the sink, and it presses into the same spot every time. After 60 the skin there is thinner, so the mark is still there when you go to bed."
Posture bra
F
Bought to fix a rounded back, graded on what it does to the back by evening. The band is wider and tighter than an ordinary bra's, and the crossed straps pull the shoulders back all day. By 6PM the band had pushed a roll above and below it on every woman in the group, and four had taken it off before lunch.
"More band is not the answer to a band problem," Joan said.
Pull-on sports bra
D
Many of Joan's clients switched to a sports bra to get away from hooks. It doesn't ride up, but the compression band is built to hold still through an hour of exercise, not to be sat in for ten. And getting one on over a stiff shoulder failed outright: 11 of the 18 needed to sit on the bed and work it down in stages, and two needed help getting it off at night.
Wireless T-shirt bra
D
The bra most women over 60 switch to when the wire gets too much, and the one that surprised them most. "They take the wire out and keep everything that was hurting," Joan said. Without a wire, all the lifting falls on the band, so it is cut just as tight. Same red line, same roll under a knit top, same hooks behind the back.
Front-closure bra
D
Moving the clasp to the front helps stiff hands in the morning, and that is the one check it improved. The band behind is the same band. Every time the women reached up to a cupboard it climbed their backs, and by 6PM it was sitting an inch higher than at breakfast. The front clasp itself is small and stiff; three women with arthritis couldn't close it.
Shelf-bra cami
D
It pulls on over the head, so it passed the morning check easily. Inside, though, it is a thin strip of elastic under the bust and nothing above it. By 6PM the elastic had rolled over on itself on 14 of the 18 women, and the spaghetti straps had grooved the shoulders of everyone above a C cup. "It's a band without the bra," Joan said.
No bra at all
C
Joan included it because seven of the eighteen had quietly stopped wearing a bra at home. No band, so five perfect grades. But it failed support outright: by 6PM most of the women described an ache across the upper back and neck from carrying the bust all day, and every one of them said she felt exposed when the doorbell rang.
"That told me everything," Joan said. "The relief they feel with no bra is the relief of no band. They just need the support without it."
Bralette
C
Softer band, so better on the band checks. But a soft band and thin straps have nothing to lift with. On anyone above a B cup it was comfortable and did nothing, and its loose foam pads had shifted out of place by lunch on most of the group.
Built-in-bra tank
A
The only A on the card, and the only option that passed all six checks. Joan's explanation was simple: it doesn't have a band.
The support comes from the shaped cups sewn into the lining and from the fitted body of the tank itself, which holds from the shoulders down to the hips. With no strip of elastic pulled tight around the ribs, there was nothing to dig in, nothing to roll the skin on the back, and nothing to climb up. At 6PM not one of the eighteen women had a band line.

The straps are as wide as three fingers, so the weight spreads across the whole top of the shoulder instead of pressing a groove into one narrow strip of it. It pulls on over the head like a T-shirt: no hooks, no clasp, nothing to reach behind for. And it looks like a top, so most of the women wore it with just a cardigan over it to the store.


Why the band decided every score
- 1A bra's band does most of the lifting. To hold the bust up, it has to be pulled tight around the ribs, and it presses on the same strip of skin for every hour you wear it.
- 2After 60, that strip of skin changes. It is thinner and slower to recover, so the same band that was fine at 40 leaves a red line at 60 that is still there at bedtime.
- 3A tight band pushes the skin into a roll above and below it, which is the line you see through a knit top. A looser band doesn't fix it; it rides up instead.
- 4Narrow straps take the rest of the weight and press grooves into the shoulders. Bigger cups on the same thin straps make the grooves deeper.
- 5The hooks are on the band. Behind the back for most bras, which is the hardest place to reach with stiff hands or a stiff shoulder.
It was never your size. It was the band.
Joan Delaney, 66 · bra fitter for 24 yearsThe tank that got the A is the Freeform Tank. It comes in six colours, and you order it from your usual bra size; the order page has the size chart. Joan's advice: "Order the size you'd buy in a bra. Don't size down to make it tighter. Tight is what we're getting away from."
The Freeform Tank
- No band: nothing to dig in, roll the skin or ride up by 6PM
- Straps as wide as three fingers: no shoulder grooves
- No hooks: pulls on over the head in seconds
- Cups sewn into the lining: still supported at 6PM, same shape after every wash