Members' coffee mugs, a pill organiser and a jar opener on a kitchen table
Arthritis Stories & Discussions

Arthritis Stories & Discussions

Community · 38.4K members
Carol Brennan
Carol Brennan AdminNovember 21 · Pinned post
Member survey results

We Asked Members With Arthritis: What's the Hardest Thing to Put On in the Morning? 1,900 Answered. The Bra Won by a Mile.

It started with Marion's post on a Tuesday morning. She'd spent twenty minutes on the edge of her bed trying to do up her bra, and she asked the rest of us one question: what's the hardest thing for you to put on?

Hundreds of you answered her by lunchtime, so we asked the whole community properly. 1,900 of you answered. It wasn't close. Here are the results, the answers you hearted most, and what members who solved it wear now.

The hardest thing to put on in the morning

1,900 members with arthritis answered. One answer each.

Won by a mile
1The bra68%
2Compression stockings11%
3A blouse with small buttons8%
4Shoes with laces6%
5A necklace clasp4%
6Pantyhose3%
Marion Keller
Marion Keller69 · rheumatoid arthritis, both hands · Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Twenty minutes this morning. Sitting on the edge of the bed with my arms twisted behind my back, trying to get one little hook into one little eye with fingers that won't bend. My husband was already out at the store. I nearly cried, over a bra. What's the hardest thing for the rest of you to put on?

Marion on the edge of her bed reaching behind her back for her bra hooks
4.8K1,214 comments

Why the bra is so hard to put on with arthritis

Members who picked the bra told us why. They could pick more than one.

The hooks behind my back74%
Twisting it round after hooking it in front52%
Getting a sports bra over a stiff shoulder41%
Some days I skip it and feel exposed38%
1
74% of members

Bra Hooks Are the Hardest Part of Dressing With Arthritis

What members described: a bra clasp is two or three tiny metal hooks you have to line up by feel, behind your own back, without seeing them. That needs fingertips that pinch and can feel a hook the size of a grain of rice, and shoulders that rotate both arms back and up at the same time. Arthritis takes the pinch out of the fingers and the turn out of the shoulders, and it's always worst first thing in the morning, which is exactly when the bra goes on.

Dot Haney 72, Kentucky

This is my hands at 7am. I can't feel the hook, I can only hope it's in. Half the time I get to the mailbox and it springs open.

Dot's arthritic fingers trying to pinch a bra hook
1.9KReply
Gail Prentiss 67, Ohio

My morning used to be pills, coffee, wait for the pills to work, THEN the bra. I plan my whole day around when my fingers will do that hook.

1.1KReply
Marion Keller 69, Pennsylvania

Gail, the waiting for the pills. Yes. I thought I was the only one sitting there in my robe watching the clock.

642Reply
2
52% of members

Hooking a Bra in Front and Twisting It Round Rubs the Skin Raw

What members described: the trick everyone gets told is to hook the bra at your waist in front, where you can see it, then drag it round to the back and pull it up. With arthritis that means gripping a tight elastic band and hauling it round your whole ribcage against your skin, then lifting both arms up into the straps. Members told us the band burns a red line on the way round, and the lift into the straps is the part their shoulders won't do.

Rita Alvarez 70, Arizona

I did the twist for six years. By the end I had a red stripe round my middle every morning from dragging that band round, and I still couldn't get my right arm up into the strap without my daughter.

1.2KReply
Helen Cho 73, Washington

Front-closure ones are no better. That little clasp in the middle needs two strong thumbs pressing together. I don't have one.

873Reply
3
41% of members

A Sports Bra Over a Stiff Shoulder Gets Stuck Halfway

What members described: a sports bra has no hooks, so it sounds like the answer. But it's a tight band that has to go over your head with both elbows up, then get rolled down past your shoulders. On a frozen or arthritic shoulder it gets stuck, rolled up round your chest, and taking it off at night is worse than putting it on.

Elaine Brooks 64, Maryland

Frozen shoulder on the left, RA in both hands. I got stuck in one of these with my arms over my head and had to call my neighbor in. This is where it ended up, next to the heat pack.

A twisted sports bra tossed on the bed beside a heat pack and a dressing stick
1.5KReply
Trudy Lindgren 68, Minnesota

Elaine, the taking it OFF. I've slept in mine because I couldn't face peeling it back over my head at 10 at night.

704Reply
4
38% of members

Skipping the Bra on Bad-Hand Days Leaves Women Feeling Exposed

What members described: on a flare day a lot of members simply don't put a bra on. Then the doorbell goes, or a neighbor waves from the drive, and they answer with their arms folded across their chest. Members told us they stopped going to the mailbox, skipped church and cancelled lunch on those days, not because of the pain, but because they didn't feel dressed.

Nancy Albers 75, Indiana

On a bad day I just put a big cardigan on and hold it shut. The UPS man must think I'm always cold.

1.3KReply
Bonnie Fields 71, Georgia

I missed my granddaughter's recital in May because my hands wouldn't do the hooks and I wasn't going to go without one. I still think about that.

1.7KReply
Carol Brennan
Carol Brennan AdminWhat members wear now

Then we asked the members who don't fight the bra every morning anymore: what do you put on instead? One answer came up more than all the others put together.

The front-closure answers came with the same complaint Helen made: the clasp still needs two strong thumbs. The sports bra answers were the ones who hadn't been stuck in one yet. And going without works until the doorbell rings.

The built-in-bra tank answers kept naming the same one: the Freeform Tank. And the reason members gave was the same every time: there is nothing to fasten. It pulls on over your head with your elbows down.

Why it goes on with stiff hands and shoulders

  • No hooks, no clasp, no band. There's nothing to line up behind your back and nothing to drag round your ribs. The support comes from shaped cups sewn into the front of a fitted tank, not from a tight band.
  • Pulls on with your elbows low. The body is soft four-way stretch, so you put your arms through and draw it down over your head the way you put on a T-shirt. No reaching back, no lifting both arms high.
  • Straps as wide as three fingers. Nothing to adjust, no slider to pinch, and they stay put on a sore shoulder.
  • Cups already in place. They're sewn into the lining, so there's no pad to tuck in or straighten with sore fingers. They come out of the wash the same shape.
  • Comes off the same way. Cross your arms, take the hem, lift. No peeling a tight band back over your head at night.
Dot Haney 72, Kentucky

My grandson took this the first morning. Arms in, over the head, pull the bottom down. That's the whole thing. I timed it for you ladies: under a minute, and I didn't have to wait for my pills to kick in.

Dot pulling the hem of the nude tank down after putting it on over her head
3.4KTop answerReply
Trudy Lindgren 68, Minnesota

But does it actually hold you, with no band? Every shelf cami I've had was a strip of elastic and a pad that ended up in my armpit.

911Reply
Rita Alvarez 70, Arizona

Trudy, I turned mine inside out for you. Real shaped cups, sewn in all the way round. Not a pad. I'm a 38D and it holds me all day.

The tank turned inside out: shaped cups sewn into the lining
1.8KReply

One more number, because a lot of you asked: of the members who switched, 9 in 10 say they now get dressed in the morning without help.

See the tank members pull on over their heads →
Marion Keller
Marion KellerUpdate · three weeks later

Well, you all talked me into it. Three of them came on Friday. Monday morning I was dressed and at the kitchen counter with my coffee by eight, before my husband was even up. No hooks, nobody to ask. The bras are in a bag for the church drive. Thank you, every one of you.

Marion in the light blue tank at her kitchen counter with a mug of coffee
6.3K902 comments
Elaine Brooks
Elaine BrooksUpdate · a bad-hand day

Flare day today, the kind where I'd normally stay in and hold my cardigan shut. Put the black one on over my head, left shoulder and all, and went to my book club. Felt dressed. That's all I wanted.

Elaine in the black tank with an open cardigan, keys in hand, by her front door
4.1K517 comments
Members' pick · nothing to fasten
Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

★★★★★ 11,482 reviews
Most chosen5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free£17.99 a tank
£299.99£89.99
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free£19.99 a tank · mix colours
£179.99£59.99
1 TankTry one first
£59.99£29.99
  • No hooks, no clasp, no band — pulls on over your head with your elbows down
  • Cups sewn into the lining — nothing to tuck or straighten with sore fingers
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — nothing to adjust
  • Order your T-shirt size, S to 3XL — no band number, no cup letter

Six colours, and you pick each one:

Nude
Black
Burgundy
Light Blue
White
Coffee
Pick My Size & Colours →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Wear it for your mornings, your bad-hand days and everything in between. If it isn't right for you, send it back within 45 days.
Carol Brennan
Carol Brennan AdminA few more from the thread
Bonnie Fields 71, Georgia

Went to my granddaughter's next recital in the burgundy one with a blouse over it. Nobody did my hooks because there weren't any.

1.2KReply
Helen Cho 73, Washington

No clasp to press with my thumbs. That's it, that's my whole review.

688Reply
Gail Prentiss 67, Ohio

I don't wait for my pills to work before I get dressed anymore. Coffee first, tank on, done.

754Reply
Nancy Albers 75, Indiana

Got the five so I'd always have a clean one on a bad day. The UPS man has seen me without the big cardigan now.

597Reply

Questions From the Thread

Can I really get it on with arthritis in my hands?

There is nothing to fasten. You put your arms through and draw it down over your head, then tug the hem down. No hooks, no clasp, no sliders on the straps.

What about a stiff or frozen shoulder?

The fabric stretches four ways, so it goes on with your elbows low by your sides instead of both arms up over your head. Most members put the stiff arm in first.

Will it hold me up without a band?

The shaped cups are sewn into the lining all the way round, and the fitted tank carries the weight from the wide straps down. Members up to a 40DD and beyond wear it every day.

How do I pick a size?

Order the size you wear in a T-shirt, S to 3XL. Between two sizes, take the larger one. The order page lists the bra sizes each tank size fits.

What if it isn't right for me?

You have 45 days. If it isn't right, send it back under the guarantee.

See the Early Black Friday Offer →Buy 3 Get 2 Free while stock lasts

Arthritis Stories & Discussions is a community of people sharing what works for them day to day. Round-ups like this one are compiled from members' answers; names and details are changed for privacy.