Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsCommunity discussions · 38,600 members
Discussions›Getting Dressed›Member survey
Member survey: 1,900 replies

We Asked 1,900 Members With Arthritic Hands Whether They Could Take Their Bra Off Without Help. 7 Out Of 10 Said No. Here Is What They Switched To.

1,900 replies 11.4K found this helpfulPosted November 21
Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsModeratorGroup admin team · 38,600 members

A few weeks ago we posted one question in the group: can you take your bra off at the end of the day, by yourself, with your hands the way they are now?

We got 1,900 answers. 7 in 10 of you said no.

The number surprised even us. We thought it would be high, but we didn't think it would be that high. So we did a longer round-up: we asked a smaller follow-up of 341 of you to write back and tell us what you'd tried, what hurt, and what you're wearing now. This post is what came back.

Older woman's arthritic hands reaching up behind her back trying to unhook a bra
Harriet, 67, sent us this one. "My granddaughter took it. I'd been at the hooks for eleven minutes."
The survey · 1,900 members with arthritic hands
Can't take their bra off alone most days71%
Need someone else to do the hooks at night41%
Sleep in it on bad-hand days37%
Tried a front-closure bra and gave up63%
Switched to something with no closure at all46%
Helpful 2.9K Me too 1,418 Reply
1,900 member repliesSorted by: Most helpful
Most helpful answer · 341 wrote back
Maureen Pulaski
Maureen Pulaski74 · osteoarthritis in both hands and right thumb · retired OT, Buffalo NY

I was an occupational therapist for 36 years before I retired, and I've been on both sides of this. First the clipboard, now the hooks.

What arthritis takes from your hands in the back-hook test is the pinch grip: the thumb-and-fingertip squeeze you need to pick up a bra hook, line it up with the eye, and hold it there while you turn your other hand to catch it. The pinch is the first thing to go, and it goes decade by decade. I used to measure it in my clinic. In your 50s, most women's pinch is strong enough. In your 60s it's about half. In your 70s a lot of us can't pinch a small key, let alone a hook behind our own back.

So when a group this big tells us 7 in 10 can't do it, I'm not surprised. The surprise is how many of us have been quietly struggling.

Simple chart showing pinch grip strength declining decade by decade from 50s to 80s
Why the hooks are the first thing to goPinch grip is the first strength to drop with age and the first to drop with arthritis. A bra hook needs more pinch than most women over 65 still have, and the hook sits where you can't see it. It's a test designed for younger hands.
Helpful 5.2K Me too 1,114 58 replies
Harriet Donnelly
Harriet DonnellyPosted the photo

Maureen, this put words to it for me. I always thought I was just getting lazy. Thank you for the chart.

406Reply
Maureen Pulaski
Maureen Pulaski

You are not lazy, Harriet. Your pinch is doing what pinch does at 67. Keep reading, I'll say what I wear now near the bottom.

611Reply
Georgia Alsobrook
Georgia Alsobrook71 · rheumatoid arthritis in her thumbs · Columbia, SC

I want to say the thing nobody said to me, which is the front-closure bra is not the answer we all hoped for. 63% of the survey said they tried one. I was one of them. I bought three.

That clasp in the middle is the size of my thumbnail. It takes a pinch grip to open and a two-handed pinch to close. My thumbs can't do a pinch grip anymore. I got it closed at the bottom and it popped open at the top in the kitchen. I asked for help twice before lunch.

A beige front-closure bra laid flat with the tiny plastic clasp highlighted
Why the fix our members hoped for didn't workMoving the clasp to the front doesn't take away the pinch grip. It just moves it where you can see it. The clasp is often smaller than a bra hook, and arthritis in the thumb kills the two-finger press you need to close it.
Helpful 2.1K Me too 798 24 replies
Eleanor Prasad
Eleanor Prasad68 · Fresno, CA

Georgia, same. I have four of them in my drawer. I thought it was me.

322Reply
Nita Thomason
Nita Thomason69 · nodal osteoarthritis in both hands · Fort Wayne, IN

Can we talk about the knuckles for a minute. A lot of us in here have Heberden's and Bouchard's nodes, those bony lumps on the finger joints that come with osteoarthritis. The joint doesn't bend as far, and the knuckle is wider than it used to be.

What that does to a bra hook is simple: the fingertip can't tuck in close enough to the hook anymore. The swollen knuckle gets in the way of its own pinch. I used to be able to feel the hook with my thumbnail. Now my thumbnail doesn't reach it, because my thumb won't bend that far.

Close-up of an older woman's hand with visibly swollen knuckles on the index and middle finger
Helpful 1.8K Me too 905 19 replies
Maureen Pulaski
Maureen Pulaski

Nita, yes. In clinic we called this "the geometry problem". The joint shape changes, so the grip has to change with it. A bra hook doesn't let you.

441Reply
See the no-closure tank 46% of our members switched to → check the early Black Friday offer
Harriet Donnelly
Harriet DonnellyPosted the photo67 · RA in both hands · Erie, PA

The morning that photo at the top was taken, I'd dropped my coffee mug. Not knocked it over, dropped it. I'd gone to pick it up off the counter and my fingers couldn't close round the handle.

I went upstairs anyway because I had the hairdresser at ten, and I stood at my mirror with my arms behind me trying to do my hooks. Eleven minutes. I know because the clock radio was on. My granddaughter came in to see if I was alright and I asked her to take the photo so I could post it in here. I was crying.

A member in this group messaged me that afternoon and told me what she wears, and I ordered it that night.

A ceramic coffee mug lying on a kitchen tile floor with coffee splashed around it
Helpful 1.7K Me too 1,026 32 replies
Georgia Alsobrook
Georgia Alsobrook

Harriet, I've been there. Dropped mug, bra hooks, tears before breakfast. You are not alone in this group.

583Reply
Dorothy Beauchene
Dorothy Beauchene76 · osteoarthritis + bursitis in her right shoulder · Billings, MT

I'm one of the 37% who was sleeping in it. I'd like to say I did it twice, but the truth is I did it most nights for about a year. I couldn't face unhooking a bra at ten at night with my right shoulder on fire, so I'd keep the bra on under my nightgown and worry about it in the morning.

I knew it wasn't good for me. My skin got sore under the band. I slept worse. But the alternative was waking my husband to unhook me, and I wasn't going to do that.

Why the band is the thing nobody mentionsIf taking a bra off at night hurts enough that you'd rather sleep in it, the problem isn't your hands alone. It's that there's a tight elastic band and a fastener in the equation at all. Take both away and there's nothing to unfasten at bedtime.
Helpful 1.5K Me too 940 21 replies
Nita Thomason
Nita Thomason

Dorothy, I slept in mine too. You are not the only one.

304Reply
What 46% switched to
Maureen Pulaski
Maureen Pulaski74 · retired OT, Buffalo NY

Here is what I wear now, and what nearly half of the 341 who wrote back about the follow-up are wearing.

It is a tank top with the bra built into it. There is no closure of any kind. No back hook, no front clasp, no little plastic latch. The cups are shaped and stitched into the lining, so there is nothing to arrange or stuff back in. The straps are about as wide as three fingers. It pulls on over your head with your elbows down by your sides, and you take it off at night the same way, hem up and over, with crossed arms. No pinch grip required anywhere.

Here is me yesterday morning in the light blue one. I was dressed and at my coffee in under a minute.

Maureen in her kitchen wearing the light blue built-in-bra tank, holding a coffee mug
Helpful 3.4K Me too 1,180 47 replies
Harriet Donnelly
Harriet DonnellyPosted the photo

Maureen, this is the one I ordered. Will post an update at the bottom when it arrives.

288Reply
Dorothy Beauchene
Dorothy Beauchene

I have one in nearly every colour now. It's the Freeform Tank. Just so the newer members know what we mean.

522Reply
Pinned by the moderators
Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsModeratorGroup team

What 341 Members Wrote Back About Taking Their Bra Off, In One Place

The survey had 1,900 answers. The follow-up had 341 members who wrote back with what they'd actually tried. Here is every workaround members told us didn't fix the problem, and what they said does.

What members told us didn't workWhat members said works
Back hooks you can't see or pinchNo hooks or clasp anywhere
Hooking in front and twisting it roundNothing to twist, it pulls on
A front-closure bra with a tiny plastic claspNo closure at all
A sports bra stuck over a stiff shoulderWide neck opening, elbows stay low
Foam pads to arrange and stuff back inCups sewn into the lining all the way round
Sleeping in it to avoid unhooking at nightComes off with crossed arms, hem up

Almost every reply in the thread named the same top: the Freeform Tank. 46% of the follow-up members switched to it. Several of you have asked where to get it, so here's where members have been ordering.

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

11,482 reviews
Most members pick this5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free£17.99 a tank
£299.99£89.99
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free£19.99 a tank
£179.99£59.99
1 TankTry one first
£59.99£29.99
  • No hooks, no clasp, no band — nothing to fasten or unfasten anywhere
  • Wide stretch square neckline — pulls on with your elbows low by your sides
  • Cups sewn into the lining — nothing to stuff back in with sore fingers
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — six colours, S to 5XL, free US shipping
Check Availability →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Wear it for a few mornings. If your hands can't manage it, you have 45 days to send it back for your money.
  • Sizing, from members: go by your usual bra size on the chart on the order page. Between two sizes, take the larger.
  • Colour, from members: most started with nude or black, then came back for the light blue and burgundy.
Newest reply
Update from Harriet
Harriet Donnelly
Harriet DonnellyPosted the phototwo weeks later

Update, like I said I would. It came on a Thursday. I stood at the dresser with my elbows by my sides, pulled it on over my head, and I was dressed. No hooks, no twisting, no crying before coffee. I took it off that night by crossing my arms and lifting the hem. That was the first evening in a long time I didn't have to ask anyone to unhook me.

Yesterday I made it to the hairdresser without dropping a mug or losing my temper. I ordered three more, two black and one burgundy. Thank you to everyone who wrote back. I mean it.

Helpful 3.6K Me too 1,422 94 replies
Maureen Pulaski
Maureen Pulaski

Oh Harriet. This made my whole week.

719Reply
See The Tank Members Switched To →Early Black Friday: Buy 3 Get 2 Free while stock lasts