Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsCommunity discussions · 38,600 members
Discussions›Getting Dressed›Member timed test
Member timed test: 40 members, stopwatch in hand

We Timed 40 Members With Arthritis Getting Dressed. The Bra Took Longer Than Everything Else Combined.

612 replies 8.7K found this helpfulPosted November 21
Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsModeratorGroup admin team · 38,600 members

A member (Judith, you will meet her below) suggested this one and we ran it over two weeks in October. 40 members with arthritis in their hands or shoulders each got dressed the way they normally do, while a family member stood in the doorway with the stopwatch on their phone. Five tasks, timed one at a time: pants, a blouse with buttons, socks, shoes, and the bra.

We expected the bra to come out slowest. We did not expect this. The median time to get a bra on and fastened was 6 minutes 40 seconds. Pants, blouse, socks and shoes together came to 6 minutes 05 seconds. One garment, with two little hooks, took longer than the whole rest of getting dressed.

Below is the stopwatch chart, then what members wrote when we posted the numbers. Several of you asked what the 22 members who re-timed themselves in a built-in-bra tank got. That is in Judith's second reply, with her photo.

An older woman in a house robe at her bedroom dresser, hands behind her back at the bra hooks, while her daughter holds a stopwatch in the doorway
Lorraine, 68, Dayton. Her daughter Kim held the stopwatch. "Eleven minutes and twenty seconds. Kim stopped the clock and did the hooks herself. I let her."
What follows is not medical advice. It is a round-up of a timed test our own members ran at home, with names and figures as members gave them to us. Arthritis is a medical condition. Please talk to your doctor or hand therapist about your own hands. Nothing on this page treats or cures anything; the only thing it does is take the hooks out of the morning.
The stopwatch · median of 40 members

Time to put on each item and fasten it, by the family member's phone.

Bra6:40 Blouse (7 buttons)2:05 Pants1:52 Socks1:10 Shoes0:58
Everything except the bra, added together6:05
The bra on its own6:40
Fastest bra time in the group: 2:10. Slowest: 19:12, a member in Tucson who finished it with her husband's help. Times are the middle value of the 40, not the average.
What else the 40 told us
Fastened the bra in front, then twisted it round to the back31 of 40
Gave up on the hooks and asked someone else to do them9 of 40
Skipped going out at least one morning last month because of the bra6 of 40
Could do all 7 blouse buttons without help38 of 40
Re-timed themselves in a built-in-bra tank (results below)22 of 40
Helpful 2.6K Me too 1,204 Reply
612 member repliesSorted by: Most helpful
Most helpful answer · ran the tally
Judith Hamel
Judith Hamel71 · rheumatoid arthritis, both hands · retired school secretary, Scranton PA

I suggested the test because I was tired of guessing. I kept the spreadsheet, so let me tell you the thing that jumped out of it before anyone else does.

The blouse had seven buttons and took two minutes. The bra had two hooks and took almost seven. Seven fasteners beat two. That is not what you would expect until you think about where the fasteners are.

A button is in front of you. You can see it. It is about the size of a dime, and you push it through with the pad of your thumb, which still works on most of us. A bra hook is behind you, where you cannot see it, and it is about a quarter of an inch across. You have to pinch it between a thumbnail and a fingertip, line it up with an eye you also cannot see, and hold both hands there up your own back while you do it. Every one of those four things is something arthritis takes away.

38 of us could do every button. 9 of us could not finish the hooks at all.

Why seven buttons beat two hooksA button faces you and takes a thumb-pad push. A bra hook faces away from you, is a quarter inch wide, and needs a fingertip pinch held behind your back for as long as it takes to find the eye. The size of the fastener and where it sits decide the time, not how many there are.
Helpful 4.9K Me too 1,092 61 replies
Lorraine Pettibone
Lorraine PettibonePosted the photo

Judith, this is it exactly. I can do my cardigan buttons in under a minute. Kim timed those too, 50 seconds. Then eleven minutes on two hooks. I thought it was me.

418Reply
Judith Hamel
Judith Hamel

It is not you, Lorraine. It is a quarter-inch hook behind your back. Keep reading, I put what I wear now further down with the re-timing numbers.

633Reply
Carol Ann Dusek
Carol Ann Dusek66 · osteoarthritis with knuckle nodes, both hands · Omaha NE

My hand therapist drew this for me on the back of an appointment card last year and it finally made sense of the hooks, so I asked her if I could share it.

The bony lumps a lot of us have on our finger joints mean the end joint of the finger and the thumb no longer bend as far, and the knuckle is wider than it used to be. To pinch a bra hook you need the thumbnail and the fingertip to meet with about a quarter inch of hook between them, and the end joints have to curl in to do it. When the joint will not curl and the knuckle is wide, the two fingertips cannot get close enough together around something that small. You end up pushing the hook with the flat of your finger, which is why it slides off the eye.

She measured my pinch on a little gauge. It was less than a third of what she said she would expect in a woman of 40. I was timed at 8 minutes 05 seconds in the test.

Illustration of a thumb and index finger with swollen knuckles trying to pinch a small bra hook and eye, drawn next to the hook at true scale
Why the hook slides off the eyePinching a quarter-inch hook needs the end joints of thumb and finger to curl in until the nails nearly touch. Knuckle nodes stop the joint curling and widen the knuckle, so the fingertips stop short of each other. The hook gets pushed by a flat finger pad instead of held by a pinch, and a pushed hook does not stay on its eye.
Helpful 2.3K Me too 884 27 replies
Beverly Tolliver
Beverly Tolliver69 · Memphis, TN

Carol Ann, the flat-finger push is exactly what I do. I never had words for it. Thank you for asking her.

352Reply
Phyllis Grandbois
Phyllis Grandbois73 · osteoarthritis in the hands, worn rotator cuff on the right · Grand Rapids MI

31 of the 40 of us did the same thing, so I will describe it for anyone who has not been shown it. You fasten the hooks in front, where you can see them, then you twist the whole bra round your ribs to the back and pull the straps up. I have done it for about nine years. My time in the test was 5 minutes 50 seconds, and almost all of that was the hooks even with them in front.

What nobody tells you is what the twist does to your shoulders. For the band to stay fastened while you spin it, it has to be pulled tight, so you are dragging a tight elastic band a half turn round your ribcage with both arms. Then you have to get both arms up through the straps and hitch them onto the shoulders. On the right side, where my rotator cuff is worn, that hitch is the single worst moment of my day. Some mornings I sit down afterwards.

Close-up of an older woman's hands with mildly swollen knuckles fastening a beige bra band held in front of her in her lap
Why the twist trick loads the shouldersThe band has to be tight to stay hooked while it turns, so both arms drag a tight band a half turn round the ribs, elbows driven back. Then both arms lift to hitch the straps. The hooks move to where you can see them; the shoulder work does not go anywhere, it doubles.
Helpful 2.0K Me too 1,011 33 replies
Carol Ann Dusek
Carol Ann Dusek

Phyllis, nine years here too. I had never once thought about what the spin was doing to my shoulders. Only the hooks.

297Reply
See the no-hook tank 22 members re-timed themselves in → check the early Black Friday offer
Lorraine Pettibone
Lorraine PettibonePosted the photo68 · osteoarthritis, both hands · Dayton, OH

The morning that photo at the top was taken, I had my daughter Kim over because she was driving me to my sister's for lunch. She was the one with the stopwatch. I did the pants, the blouse, the socks and the shoes, and she read the times out and I was quite pleased with myself.

Then the bra. I did it my usual way, in front and twist. I got one hook on and the other would not go. I started over. Kim said nothing for a long time, and then she said, "Mom, that's eleven minutes," and she came and did the two hooks in about four seconds. We were twenty minutes late to my sister's and I sat in the car and did not talk.

I am one of the 9 who asked for help, and one of the 6 who has stayed home over it. There was a church breakfast in September I did not go to because it was a bad-hand morning and I could not face the hooks and I was not going to ring anyone to come and do them.

Helpful 1.8K Me too 1,147 39 replies
Phyllis Grandbois
Phyllis Grandbois

Lorraine, I was late to my own sister's lunch last spring for the same two hooks. You are not the only one in this group who has sat in the car.

561Reply
Beverly Tolliver
Beverly Tolliver69 · rheumatoid arthritis, both hands · Memphis, TN

"I have a six-minute bra and a ninety-second everything else. Nobody at my doctor's office has ever asked me about the six minutes."

Beverly, 69 · timed at 6:38

That is what I wrote on my timing sheet and I stand by it. My pants, blouse, socks and shoes together were about a minute and a half, because I buy pants with an elastic waist and I have done for years. The bra was 6 minutes 38 seconds. On a normal morning.

On a flare morning it is not a number, because I do not finish. With rheumatoid arthritis my hands are a size bigger from waking until about ten, stiff and warm, and the thumbnail will not meet the fingertip at all. On those mornings I either wait until ten to get dressed, or I go without, or I wake my husband. I am 69 years old and I wake my husband to do my bra.

Helpful 1.7K Me too 1,236 28 replies
Judith Hamel
Judith Hamel

Beverly, I re-timed myself on a flare morning on purpose, with the tank. 31 seconds. It is in my next reply.

509Reply
The re-timing · 22 members in the tank
Judith Hamel
Judith Hamel71 · Scranton PA · keeper of the spreadsheet

Here is the second half of the test, which 22 of the 40 agreed to do. We each got the same thing, a tank top with the bra built into it, and had the same family member time us putting it on from the drawer to dressed.

The median was 24 seconds. The slowest of the 22 was 41 seconds. Mine on an ordinary morning was 19 seconds and, because Beverly asked, I did it again on a flare morning with both hands stiff and it was 31 seconds.

There is nothing to fasten. No back hooks, no front clasp, nothing to twist round. The cups are shaped and stitched into the lining so there is no pad to find and push back into place. The straps are about as wide as three fingers. You grab the hem with your whole hand, not your fingertips, and pull it over your head with your elbows down low by your sides. It comes off the same way at night, hem up, arms crossed. There is no pinch anywhere in it and nothing behind your back.

Here is me at the breakfast table at a quarter past seven in the light blue one. At a quarter past seven I used to still be standing at the dresser.

Judith at her kitchen table at breakfast wearing the light blue built-in-bra tank, coffee and cereal in front of her
Why the time drops from minutes to secondsEvery one of the 6 minutes 40 seconds was spent on the hooks: finding them, pinching them, holding both hands up the back, or twisting a tight band round the ribs. Take the hooks and the band out and what is left is pulling a top over your head, which the 40 members were already doing with their blouses in about two minutes with buttons, and in seconds without them.
Helpful 3.3K Me too 1,158 52 replies
Lorraine Pettibone
Lorraine PettibonePosted the photo

Judith, I was not one of the 22 because mine had not arrived. Kim is coming Saturday with the stopwatch. I will post the number at the bottom.

274Reply
Carol Ann Dusek
Carol Ann Dusek

Mine was 27 seconds. It's the Freeform Tank, for the newer members asking what we mean. I have the white and the light blue.

496Reply
Pinned by the moderators
Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsModeratorGroup team

The Timed Test In One Place: 6:40 For The Bra, 0:24 For The Tank

40 members timed, five tasks each. The bra took 6 minutes 40 seconds at the median and beat everything else combined. 22 members then re-timed themselves in a built-in-bra tank and the median fell to 24 seconds. Here is every workaround members told us they had tried against the hooks, and what they said the tank did instead.

What members tried against the hooksWhat the tank does instead
Hooking in front and twisting the band round (31 of 40)Nothing to hook, nothing to twist, pulls straight on
Asking a husband or daughter to do the hooks (9 of 40)Dressed alone, 24 seconds at the median
Waiting until the hands loosen up at tenWhole-hand grip on the hem, no pinch, any hour
A front-closure bra with a plastic claspNo clasp of any kind, front or back
Foam pads to find and push back inCups sewn into the lining all the way round
Sleeping in it to avoid the hooks at nightOff at night with the hem, arms crossed
Phyllis buttoning an open cardigan over the black built-in-bra tank in her hallway
Phyllis, 73, doing the cardigan buttons over the black one. "Buttons I can see. That is the whole difference."

The top the 22 re-timed themselves in is the Freeform Tank. Several of you have asked where members have been ordering, so here it is.

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

11,482 reviews
Most members pick this5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free£17.99 a tank
£299.99£89.99
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free£19.99 a tank
£179.99£59.99
1 TankTry one first
£59.99£29.99
  • No hooks, no clasp, no band — nothing to pinch and nothing behind your back
  • Wide stretch square neckline — grab the hem with your whole hand, elbows low, over the head
  • Cups sewn into the lining — no pad to find or push back with stiff fingers
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — six colours, S to 5XL, free US shipping
Check Availability →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Time yourself for a few mornings. If your hands can't manage it, you have 45 days to send it back for your money.
  • Sizing, from members: go by your usual bra size on the chart on the order page. Between two sizes, take the larger; the neck opening is roomier and the hem is easier to grab.
  • Colour, from members: most started with black or nude, then came back for the light blue once they knew the fit.

Questions members asked in the thread

Does this do anything for the arthritis itself?

No, and nobody in the thread said it did. The tank takes the two hooks and the behind-the-back reach out of getting dressed. That is the whole of what it does. Please keep seeing your doctor or hand therapist about your hands; this group is not a substitute for that.

What about a flare morning, when my hands are swollen and stiff?

Judith re-timed herself on a flare morning on purpose: 31 seconds. The reason it still works on a stiff-hand day is that there is nothing to pinch. You take the hem in your whole hand, fingers wrapped round it, elbows low, and pull. Members with rheumatoid arthritis said it was the first top they could get on before ten in the morning without waiting for the hands to loosen.

Can I get it over my head if my shoulders are bad too?

Phyllis, 73, has a worn rotator cuff on the right and was one of the 22. The square neckline stretches wide, so you pull it on with your elbows low by your sides, not reaching up or behind. It comes off the same way, arms crossed, hem up. She said it was the first morning in nine years without the strap hitch on her right shoulder.

Is it supportive enough to wear out of the house?

Members in the test wore it to church, to lunch and to the grocery store, mostly under an open cardigan or a blouse worn unbuttoned. The cups are shaped and sewn into the lining and the straps are three fingers wide, so the hold is spread across the shoulders rather than hanging off a hook. Carol Ann, who gardens, wears hers under a work shirt. Her photo is below.

Carol Ann kneeling at a raised garden bed in the white built-in-bra tank, wearing garden gloves
Carol Ann, 66, Omaha. "Dressed at seven, in the garden by half past. I used to be at the dresser until eight."
Newest reply
Update from Lorraine · Saturday's number
Lorraine Pettibone
Lorraine PettibonePosted the photonine days later

Kim came Saturday with the stopwatch like I said. Same dresser, same mirror, same daughter in the doorway. 22 seconds. I pulled it over my head with my elbows down and I was dressed, and Kim said, "Mom, that's it?" and I said yes, that's it.

I took it off that night with my arms crossed and the hem up and I did not have to ask anyone anything. We went to my sister's on Sunday and we were early. I have ordered two more, a black and a burgundy, and the bras with the hooks are in the bottom drawer where I do not have to look at them on a bad-hand morning. Thank you to everyone in this thread, and to Judith for the spreadsheet.

Lorraine at her bedroom dresser mirror settling the straps of the burgundy built-in-bra tank, just pulled on over her head
Helpful 3.1K Me too 1,302 77 replies
Judith Hamel
Judith Hamel

22 seconds, Lorraine. That is 11 minutes and 20 seconds down to 22 seconds. I have added you to the spreadsheet. This made my whole week.

688Reply
See The Tank 22 Members Re-Timed In →Early Black Friday: Buy 3 Get 2 Free while stock lasts