My Granddaughter Asked Why I Kept Pulling At My Shoulder. I Had Not Noticed I Did It 40 Times A Day.
A long one. Several of you asked what happened after I posted about Lily and the envelope, so here is the whole thing from the Sunday it started.
It was a Sunday lunch in September, the usual one. Roast chicken, too many potatoes, my daughter Sarah, her husband, and my granddaughter Lily, who is eight and notices everything. John was carving. I was passing the gravy.
Lily put her fork down, looked straight at me across the table and said, in that voice children use when they have been wondering about something for a while:
"Grandma, why do you keep pulling at your shoulder?"
I said I didn't. She said, "You do. You just did it. You do it all the time." And Sarah, who is 44 and has clearly been watching her mother do this for years without saying a word, looked down at her plate and said, very quietly, "She's right, Mom."

I had my right hand up at my left shoulder as she said it. Two fingers hooked under the edge of my blouse, pulling a bra strap back up onto the top of my shoulder from where it had slid down towards my arm. I had done it so many times over so many years that I did not feel my hand go up any more.
So on Monday I counted
I am a counter. I counted my steps for twenty years before anybody had a watch for it. So on the Monday morning I took an envelope off the pile by the kettle, wrote the hours of the day down the left side, and every time I caught my hand at my shoulder I made a mark against the hour.
I thought it might be ten. I thought Lily was being eight.
times I pulled a bra strap back up onto my shoulder. Forty-one. And those are only the ones I caught.
Counted on the back of an electric bill envelope, one mark per tug, by hour. I have kept the envelope.The envelope, hour by hour
Here is what the envelope said, because the shape of it is the part that surprised me. Mornings were nothing much. The afternoon was where the strap gave up.
Bra strap tugs on Monday, by the hour
One mark per tug. The red bars are the two hours Lily would have seen most of at the table.
Three in the afternoon until five, five tugs an hour. One every twelve minutes. That is when I do the ironing, the dog, the garden, the phone call to my sister. Every time I lifted an arm above my shoulder the strap slid towards my arm and my hand went up to fetch it back. By seven in the evening I was sitting still in front of the television and the count dropped to one, because I had stopped moving.
What I saw in the bathroom mirror that night
I took the bra off at half past eight, which is early for me, because I wanted to look. I turned my left shoulder to the bathroom mirror and pulled the strap of my nightdress aside.

There was a groove. Not a red line. A groove, a shallow channel across the top of my shoulder about the width of my finger, pink at the edges and pale in the middle, exactly where the strap had sat all day. I pressed it and it was tender the way a bruise is tender the day before it shows. It was still there when I went to bed an hour later. It was a little less there in the morning.
Forty-one tugs. One groove. Eight years of Lily, and it took her to tell me.
The birthday photos
Then the thing that actually made me cry a little bit, in the kitchen, on my own.
Sarah sent me the photos from Lily's eighth birthday in August. Seven photos. Lily and the cake, Lily and her cousins, the grown-ups behind them. I am in all seven, standing behind the children in my blue cardigan.

In three of the seven photos my right hand is up at my left shoulder, two fingers under the cardigan, pulling a bra strap back where it belongs. At my granddaughter's birthday party.
I went back through the Christmas photos. Then the ones from our anniversary dinner. Then a photo of me at my own mother's ninetieth, nineteen years ago, with my hand at my shoulder. I had been doing this in every photograph for a very long time and nobody, not John, not Sarah, not my sister Diane, had said a word. It took an eight-year-old who had not yet learned that you do not mention things.
See what Sarah put in my hands two weeks later → check availabilityWhy a bra strap slides on a shoulder after 60
I wanted to understand it before I did anything about it, so I spent an evening reading and then I stood sideways at the mirror again with my reading glasses on. Here is what I worked out, in plain words.
Four things that changed on my shoulder that the strap did not
- The strap is about a finger wide and it is carrying half of a 38DD. All of that weight hangs from two narrow lines across the top of each shoulder. The narrower the line, the deeper it presses, and the easier it slides.
- My shoulders slope more than they did at 40. The muscle across the top of the shoulder thins with age and the shoulders round forward. A strap that sat flat on a level shoulder at 40 now sits on a slope, and a strap on a slope slides downhill towards the arm every time the arm moves.
- The pad of flesh over the top of the shoulder is thinner. So the strap is sitting closer to the bone, which is why it leaves a groove now when it left a faint pink line at 50.
- My hand fixes it without asking me. Forty-one times. The body learns that the strap is going to slide and sends the hand up before the strap has even finished moving. That is the habit Lily could see and I could not.
None of that is the bra's fault exactly. The bra had not changed. My shoulder had. But I had been buying the same narrow-strap bra for thirty years and nobody at the shop had ever said: your shoulder is not the shoulder this was designed for any more.
What I tried first, and why it did not work
I did not go straight to the thing that worked. Nobody does.
- I tightened the straps. The strap stopped sliding for about a day and the groove was twice as deep by Tuesday night. A tighter narrow line is still a narrow line.
- I bought the silicone strap cushions. The little pads you slide onto the strap. They moved. By lunchtime they had slid down the strap to the top of the cup and I was tugging at the cushion instead of the strap.
- I tried the clip that pulls the straps together at the back. That stopped the slide and moved the whole pull to the back of my neck instead. Headache by three.
- I wore my old sports bra for two days. No slide. The band round my ribs was so tight I could not take a full breath on the stairs, and the strap marks were replaced by a band mark.
What Sarah put in my hands two weeks later
Sarah came over on a Saturday with a plastic mailer bag and said, "Mom, I ordered you something. Don't argue, just try it on." Inside was a folded light-blue tank top. I said I did not need a top, I needed a bra that stayed put. She said, "It is both. Go and put it on."
A fitted tank with the bra sewn into it. No band. No wire. No hooks. The cups were stitched into the lining all the way round, not pads in a pocket. And the straps, which were the first thing I looked at, were three fingers wide. Flat, soft, wide enough to lie across the whole top of my shoulder from the neck side to the arm side.

I pulled it on over my head in the bathroom and stood sideways at the mirror. The square neckline sat straight across, well above anything. The strap lay flat on the slope of my shoulder and did not move when I lifted my arm, because a strap that wide has nowhere to slide to. There was no narrow line to press a groove. The hold was coming from the fitted body of the tank and the cups sewn into it, not from two threads over my shoulders.
I counted again a week later
The next Monday I took the same envelope off the pile and turned it over.
Two marks all day. Both of them before ten in the morning. Both of them my hand going up out of habit and finding a wide flat strap sitting exactly where I had left it, with nothing to fix. By the Wednesday I had stopped reaching. By the second Monday I did not bother with the envelope, because there was nothing to count.

Lily noticed before I told her. We were in the garden, I was in the burgundy one with a mug of tea in both hands, and she looked up from her chalk and said, "Grandma. You stopped." Then she went back to her drawing, because to an eight-year-old that was the end of the matter.
Fifty-four years of fixing a bra strap in public
I started wearing a bra at fourteen. I am sixty-eight. That is fifty-four years of pulling a strap back up onto my shoulder in church, in the choir stalls, in the queue at the grocery store, at my daughter's wedding, at my mother's ninetieth, and at my granddaughter's eighth birthday party in three photographs out of seven.
Forty times a day, give or take, for most of those years. Nobody ever said. People are kind, and people do not mention the thing you do with your hands. I would rather have known at fifty.
If a child at your table has ever asked you a question like Lily's, or if you have just felt your own hand go up to your shoulder while reading this, I would count tomorrow. I would bet on forty.
Why it fit when nothing else did
- The straps are three fingers wide. Flat and soft, they lie across the whole top of a sloping older shoulder and stay there. There is no narrow line to press a groove and nothing to slide.
- The hold comes from the body of the tank, not the straps. The fitted body and the cups sewn into the lining carry the weight. The straps are just keeping it up, not hauling it.
- No band to ride up. No wire. No hooks behind my back. It goes on over my head.
- The cups are stitched into the lining all the way round. Not pads in a pocket. They can't fold in the wash and they can't slide down the inside.
- You pick a size like a top. S to 5XL. No band numbers, no cup letters, no tape measure.
- It looks like a nice top. Square neck, six colours. I wear the light blue one under my cream cardigan to church and the burgundy one on its own in the garden.
Here is the one Sarah put in my hands.
The Freeform Tank
Straps three fingers wide · cups sewn in · no band, wire or hooksAs low as £14.99 a tank today- Straps three fingers wide that lie flat across a sloping older shoulder and do not slide.
- No band, no wire, no hooks. Pulls on over your head.
- Cups sewn into the lining all the way round — can't fold or shift in the wash.
- S to 5XL in six colours. Pick a size like a top.
With love, and thank you, Lily,
What my friends keep asking me
Will it hold a bigger bust without a band?
I'm a 38DD and it holds me. The hold comes from the fitted body of the tank and the shaped cups stitched into the lining, with the wide straps keeping it up rather than carrying all the weight. If you are a full F or G cup, order the five-pack and wear one for a full day. The 45-day guarantee has you covered either way.
Do the wide straps show under a blouse?
They sit where a wide-shouldered top would sit, so under a cardigan or a blouse they read as a top, not underwear. The square neckline sits straight across above the bust line.
What size do I pick?
Order by your usual top size using the chart on the order page, S to 5XL. If you are between two sizes, take the larger one. The tank is cut to lie flat, not squeeze.
Will the cups wash out of it?
No. They are stitched into the lining all the way round, not pads in a pocket, so they stay put and hold their shape through the wash. Mine have been through the machine every week since September.