A Textile Lab Measured How Hard 12 Bras Press On The Ribs Of Women Over 60. One Had No Band To Measure.
Fourteen women aged 61 to 78 wore a pressure sensor under the band for a full day in each garment. The lab logged the reading at the ribs every fifteen minutes from eight in the morning until six at night. Eleven bras are ranked below by how hard the band pressed at 4pm. The twelfth could not be ranked the same way.
Every woman over 60 has been told her bra band should be firm. Nobody has ever told her how firm that is in a number, because nobody selling bras has a reason to measure it.
So we paid an independent textile testing lab in North Carolina to measure it. This is a lab that normally checks medical compression stockings and workwear against a standard. It owns the instrument for the job: a flat air-filled sensor pad, thinner than a credit card, that reports how hard a garment presses on the body underneath it.
The lead technician, Marilyn Decker, is 63 and has tested textiles for 27 years. She wore the sensor herself on every pilot day before the panel started. “I have measured the squeeze of a compression stocking ten thousand times,” she told us. “In all those years nobody asked me to put the same pad under a bra band. I had no idea what my own was reading. By the drive home on the first pilot day it was 29.”
bras with a band pressed harder on the ribs at 4pm than a light compression stocking presses on a calf.
A compression stocking is built to squeeze. A bra band is sold as support. The ribs have to move with every breath. A calf does not.The ranking12 Bras, Ranked By How Hard The Band Pressed On The Ribs At 4pm
Lowest pressure first. Each figure is the average 4pm reading across all fourteen women, in mmHg.

The lab's report codes the eleven bras A to K and we describe each by type. A light compression stocking is 15 to 20 mmHg. With the sensor taped in the same place under the Freeform Tank it read 3 mmHg, which is what it reads under a fitted T-shirt.
In a hurry? See the one with no bandWhat the sensor showedFour Things The Bra Band Readings Had In Common
A Correctly Fitted Bra Band Out-Pressed A Compression Stocking Before Breakfast Was Over

At 8am, minutes after each woman was fitted, the eleven banded bras averaged 20.6 mmHg on the ribs. That is already at the top of what a light compression stocking is allowed to squeeze a calf.
These were not badly fitted bras. A professional fitter chose the size for every woman in every style. “That was the part I had wrong my whole life,” Marilyn says. “I thought a tight band was a wrong band. The gauge says a tight band is a correct band. Tight is how it holds you up. There is nothing else in a bra to do it.”
By 4pm The Same Bra Band On The Same Woman Pressed Nearly A Third Harder

Average of the eleven banded bras, all fourteen women, mmHg by hour.
The average reading climbed every hour of the working day: 20.6 at 8am, 26.9 at 4pm. The steepest step was the hour after lunch.
The elastic had not changed. The woman had. The lab ran a tape round each woman under the bust at 8am and again at 3pm. By mid-afternoon the average was 0.6 of an inch larger: a meal, a day's fluid, hours of sitting. A band is a fixed length of elastic round a body that is not a fixed size, so the same hook presses harder as the day goes on.
Sitting made it worse again. Readings taken with the woman seated at 4pm averaged 4 mmHg higher than the same bra with her standing.
The Bra Band Pressed Hardest Each Time She Breathed In

The lower ribs are the ones that move most when you breathe. On a full breath in they swing outward at the sides. A bra band sits directly on them, so every breath in is a push against elastic.
The lab also measured how far each woman's chest widened at the band line on a deep breath, with a tape. In the eleven banded bras the average was 1.1 inches. In the garment with no band it was 1.9 inches.
Reaching overhead did the same thing as a deep breath. A hand lifted to a high shelf sent the reading to 38 mmHg in the average banded bra.
The Wire-Free Comfort Bra Pressed As Hard As The Underwire Bra

This was the reading Marilyn checked twice. The bra sold to women over 60 as the comfortable one, with no wire and wide padded straps, pressed on the ribs a point harder than the underwire bra it is meant to replace.
“Once I turned it inside out it was obvious,” she says. “Take the wire out and something else has to hold the weight. In every wire-free bra on the bench that something was the band. They made it wider and they made it tighter. The wire went. The squeeze stayed, and it moved to your ribs.”
Four of the six highest readings in the ranking belong to bras with no underwire.
The verdictThe One Garment With No Bra Band To Measure
The twelfth garment is a tank with the bra built into it. The lab's protocol says to place the sensor under the band at the side of the lower ribs. On this garment the technician could not find one.
So the lab taped the sensor to the same spot on the ribs anyway and ran the full day. It read 3 mmHg at 8am and 3 mmHg at 4pm. It did not climb after lunch. It did not jump on a deep breath or when a woman reached for a shelf. Three is what the same sensor reads under a fitted T-shirt.
Marilyn turned it inside out to find out what was holding the wearer up. The cups are sewn into the lining all the way round, so each one is fixed in place and carries the bust from underneath. The weight goes up into straps as wide as three fingers and is spread across the fitted body of the tank. No single line of elastic is doing the work, so there is no single line of pressure for a sensor to find.
“A band holds by squeezing one inch of you,” she says. “This holds by covering all of you. From a measurement point of view those are two different kinds of garment, and only one of them shows up on my gauge.”
Side by sideLowest Reading Against The Two Bras Most Women Over 60 Own
| Measured | Freeform Tank | Wire-free comfort bra | Underwire bra |
|---|---|---|---|
| Band on the ribs | None | Extra-wide elastic | Elastic, two hooks |
| Reading at 8am | 3 mmHg | 22 mmHg | 22 mmHg |
| Reading at 4pm | 3 mmHg | 29 mmHg | 28 mmHg |
| Peak on a deep breath | No change | 40 mmHg | 41 mmHg |
| Chest widening on a breath | 1.9 inches | 1.1 inches | 1.0 inch |
| Cups | Sewn into the lining | Loose pad in a pocket | Molded, wired |
| Fastening | Pulls on, no hooks | Three hooks | Two hooks |
| Straps | Three fingers wide | Wide, padded | Narrow |
Which one is garment L
The lab's report identifies every garment by a letter, and we have described the eleven bras by type. We are naming the twelfth because every reader who saw the draft asked. It is the Freeform Tank, made by a small US company and sold only through its own order page. It is the only garment of the twelve with no band of any kind, and the only one with the cups stitched into the lining.
Ranked #1 Of 12: The Freeform Tank
- No band round your ribs — the only garment of the twelve with nothing for the sensor to read
- Cups sewn into the lining — they hold the bust from underneath and cannot fold in the wash
- Straps three fingers wide, square neckline — no wire, no hooks, pulls on over the head
- Six colors, sizes S to 5XL — free US shipping
The panelThree Of The Fourteen Women Who Wore The Sensor
Every woman on the panel wore all twelve garments. We asked three of them what they wear now that the test is over.

“I watched my own number go from 21 to 30 in the underwire and I had not touched a thing. The day I wore the tank the technician kept checking the tube was still connected. I asked if I could keep it. I have bought four more since.”

“I went in certain a tank could not hold a 42DD. It did, all day, and the gauge sat on three. My comfort bra read 31 on me at four o'clock. I had been calling that one my good bra for six years.”

“What I noticed was the breath. They had us take a deep one every hour for the tape. In the bras I could feel where it stopped. In the tank it just kept going. I am seventy-seven and I had forgotten it did that.”
QuestionsWhat Readers Asked About The Bra Band Readings
With no band, what holds a larger bust up?
The cups and the body of the tank. Each cup is stitched into the lining all the way round, so it carries the bust from underneath, and the weight goes into straps three fingers wide and across the whole fitted torso. Four of the fourteen women on the panel wear a DD or larger. All four are still wearing it.
Would a looser hook give me the same result?
The lab tried it. Moving out one hook lowered the 4pm reading by 3 mmHg on average, and the fitter then marked seven of the eleven bras as no longer holding. A band holds by pressing. Less pressing is less holding. That is why the only reading under 15 came from the garment with no band.
What size do I order?
Your usual top size, the one on your blouses, and the larger one if you sit between two. The chart on the order page maps bra sizes to S through 5XL.
Will it show under my clothes?
The neckline is square and straight across and the front is smooth, so under a blouse or a cardigan it reads as a camisole. There are no hooks or strap sliders to print through a knit.
Will the cups fold in the wash?
They are not loose pads in a pocket. They are sewn into the lining, so there is nothing to fold or fish out. Machine wash warm, tumble dry low.
Report by The Over-60 Report testing desk. Measurements were taken by an independent textile testing lab on fourteen volunteers and describe those garments on those women. Readings are measurements of garment pressure and are not medical advice.