I Wore My Department Store Bra And A Built-In-Bra Tank On Alternate Days For 30 Days At 66. I Scored Every Day.
I am a 40DD. Odd days were the underwire bra I was fitted for at the department store. Even days were a tank top with the bra built into it. I gave each one a score out of ten at 8am, 1pm and 6pm and wrote it on the kitchen calendar. The bra and the tank were close at breakfast. They were not close at supper.
I have worn an underwire bra since I was fifteen. That is fifty-one years, and for most of them I have said the same thing every woman my size says: a 40DD needs a real bra, with a band and a wire, and anything else is for smaller women.
My friend Joanne has been wearing a tank with the bra built in since the spring and will not stop talking about it. I told her it would never hold me. She said, “Barbara, you were a school secretary for thirty-one years. Stop telling me and keep a record.”
So I did. One month, two garments, the same body, and a pen.
- Odd days, the bra. My department store underwire, a 40DD, fitted in the store by their fitter this year. It is the best bra I own.
- Even days, the tank. A built-in-bra tank, worn on its own with no bra under it.
- Three scores a day: 8am, 1pm and 6pm, by the kitchen clock.
- One question each time: how much do I want this off me right now? A ten means I had forgotten I was wearing it. A one means it is coming off in the next minute.
- Ordinary days only. Church, groceries, the garden, the grandkids, the long drive to my sister's. No sitting still to help either one.
The two garmentsOne Bra With A Band, A Wire And Three Hooks. One Bra Tank With None Of Them.
| The bra | The bra tank | |
|---|---|---|
| Band | Elastic, an inch and a quarter wide, round the ribs | None |
| Wire | Underwire in both cups | None |
| Fastening | Three rows of hooks behind my back | None. Pulls on over the head |
| Straps | Half an inch, with metal sliders | Two inches, as wide as three of my fingers, flat |
| Cups | Molded, held up by the wire | Shaped and sewn into the lining |
| Washing | By hand, says the label | In the machine with the towels |
I expected the tank to lose on the one thing that matters at my size, which is holding me up. I will come to that. First, the three times of day, because the clock is where this got decided.
At 8am My Bra Scored A 7.4. There Was Not Much In It.
I want to be fair to the bra. A properly fitted underwire at eight in the morning is a decent thing. I am standing up, I have not eaten, I have not sat in a car. I gave it sevens and eights and I meant them.
The tank got eights on its first three mornings and nines after that. The eights were me, not it. I spent those three mornings waiting for something to slip, and nothing did.
By 1pm The Bra Band Had Dropped To A 5.0
The one o'clock score is taken after lunch, and usually after a drive. On bra days that is when I first notice the band. Not pain. Just that I know exactly where it is, all the way round, and I did not know that at eight.
On tank days there is nothing round my ribs to get tighter. The one o'clock score was an eight on the first tank day, a ten on the last, and a nine on every day in between.
At 6pm My Bra Scored 2.6 Out Of 10. The Tank Scored 9.2.
This is where they split. On fourteen of the fifteen bra days, the six o'clock score was a three or lower. Seven of them were twos. A two on my scale means I am writing the number down with one hand and reaching behind my back with the other.
I had always called that being tired. It is not tiredness. I know that now because on the days in between, at the same six o'clock, after the same kind of day, I was writing down nines and tens and then getting on with supper.
The tank's six o'clock average came out higher than its eight o'clock average. I checked my adding twice. By the evening I had simply stopped noticing I had it on, and a thing you have stopped noticing gets a ten.
The proofAll 90 Bra And Tank Scores, Exactly As I Wrote Them On The Calendar
My handwriting is a secretary's but the fridge is not a good photographer, so here is the whole month typed out. Each box is one day: the 8am score, the 1pm score, the 6pm score.
Bra days: 8am 7.4 · 1pm 5.0 · 6pm 2.6. Tank days: 8am 8.8 · 1pm 9.0 · 6pm 9.2. Added up twice, once by me and once by my husband, who taught math.
Read down any bra day and the numbers fall: eight, five, three. Read down any tank day and they do not move. That was the whole finding, and I had it by the end of the first week. I kept going to thirty because I said I would.
The question I get asked firstDoes A Bra Tank Really Hold Up A 40DD With No Band And No Wire? I Tested That Too.
This was the reason I expected the tank to lose, so I was hard on it. On tank days I did the things I would never do without a proper bra on. I took the stairs at a trot. I went down the church steps in front of everybody. I leaned right over the sink. I carried a laundry basket on my hip.
I stayed put. Here is what is doing it, as far as a retired secretary with a tape measure can tell you:
That stitching is also why it went through the machine fifteen times in a month, with the towels, and came out every time with the cups where they started. The bra went through my hands in the bathroom sink fifteen times, because the label says so, and I did not score that but I could have.
Day 30On Day 30 I Added Up Both Columns. Then My Department Store Bra Went In The Donation Bag.
Day thirty was a tank day. At six o'clock I wrote a ten, sat down at the table with the calendar and added the columns. 225 for the bra. 405 for the tank. Out of the same 450.
I am not a woman who throws things out. But I could not think of one reason to put the bra on for day thirty-one, and I looked for one. It went in the bag by the door with the sweaters. Then I got my reading glasses and ordered the tank in three more colors.
Joanne has been told she was right. She has asked for it in writing, so here it is.
The one I scoredThe Built-In-Bra Tank I Wore On The Even Days
Enough of you have asked that I will just say it. It is the Freeform Tank. It comes from a small company that sells it from its own order page and not in the stores, which is why I had never seen one on a hanger. It is the one Joanne wears, and the only one I have found with the cups sewn into the lining and no band of any kind.
The Freeform Tank
- No band round your ribs — nothing to get tighter between breakfast and supper
- Cups sewn into the lining — no wire, no pads to fold, straight in the machine
- Straps as wide as three fingers — flat on the shoulder, square neckline
- Pulls on over the head — no hooks; six colors, sizes S to 5XL
Three Friends Who Scored Their Own Bra Against The Tank
I showed the calendar round at church. Three of them went home and kept their own, for a week each.

“I am the Joanne. I kept my own calendar for a week so Barbara could not say I had made it up. My bra got a four at six o'clock on its best day. The tank never got under a nine. I have a frozen shoulder and could not reach the hooks anyway, so mine was not a fair fight.”

“I told Barbara a tank would not hold a 42DD and I would prove it with her own pen. Seven days later I had proved the opposite. What got me was the one o'clock number. I had never noticed that the band gets tighter after lunch until I had to write it down.”

“I scored mine in the car, because six o'clock is when I am driving home and that is when I always unhooked at the lights. On the tank days there was nothing to unhook. I wrote a ten and kept both hands on the wheel.”
What I Get Asked About The Bra Tank
I am bigger than a 40DD. Will it hold me?
I can only score my own chest, and it held a 40DD down a flight of stairs for fifteen days. The sizes run from S to 5XL and the chart on the order page goes by your bra size, so you look yourself up. You have 45 days to run your own test.
What size did you order?
I looked up 40DD on the chart on the order page and ordered what it said. It fitted the first time. It is meant to lie flat and hold, not squeeze, so do not size down the way you would with a band.
Does it show under a blouse?
Less than the bra did. The neckline is square and straight across and there are no hooks or sliders to show through a knit. Under a blouse it looks like a camisole. On its own it looks like a top, which is how I wear it in the yard.
Do the cups fold in the wash?
No. They are sewn into the lining, not tucked in a pocket, so there is nothing loose to fold. Mine went in with the towels fifteen times in the month.
Did you ever put the bra back on?
No. I looked for a reason on day thirty-one and did not find one.
Barbara Hayes is a retired school secretary in Ohio. This is one woman's own record of her own month, scored by her at her own kitchen table. It is not medical advice.