Margaret Ellis
Margaret Ellis68 · Columbus, Ohio · November 21

I Am 68 And I Sit Most Of The Day. I Wore 8 Bras In My Chair And Scored Each One By Evening. The Band Rode Up On Seven.

My sister Patty asked me a simple question and I could not answer it. So I spent eight days in my recliner with a notepad, a pencil and my sewing tape, and Frank did the measuring.

Patty retired in the summer. In September she rang me and said, “Marg, I sit all day now, and by three o'clock my bra is up round my shoulder blades. Which one do you wear in that chair of yours?”

I opened my mouth to tell her and found I did not know. I have a drawer full of bras, and I could not have told you which one was any good sitting down. I only knew which ones looked right in a fitting-room mirror.

So I told her I would find out properly and write it down.

Margaret in her recliner with a notepad, a tape measure round her neck and several bras laid over the arm of the chair
Day one. Frank thinks I have lost my mind.

First, How Much A Woman Of 68 Really Sits

I would have told you I am on my feet all day. Then I kept a note of one ordinary Wednesday, by the kitchen clock.

One ordinary Wednesday, sitting down

Kitchen table: breakfast, the paper, the telephone, lunch2½ hrs
My recliner: the crossword, my knitting, the afternoon programs4 hrs
The car: the pharmacy, the grocery store and back1 hr
The sofa with Frank after supper1½ hrs
Sitting down, in one day9 hrs

Nine hours. On a Sunday you can add an hour and a quarter in a church pew. I am not ashamed of it. I am 68, I have earned my chair. But it does mean something I had never once thought about.

My bra spends nine hours of every day on a woman who is sitting down. Every bra I own was fitted on a woman who was standing up.

Every Bra Is Fitted Standing Up. Nobody Checks It Sitting Down.

Think about the last time you were fitted. You stood in front of a mirror with your arms by your sides. The tape went round you while you were standing. You looked at yourself standing, said it felt fine, and bought it. Nobody has ever asked me to sit down in a fitting room, and there is rarely anything to sit on but a little bench with your handbag on it.

Then you take that bra home and sit in it for nine hours.

How I Scored The Eight

I took seven bras out of my drawer, one of every kind I own. For the eighth I added a built-in-bra tank my daughter Karen had mailed me a few weeks earlier with a note that said, “Mom, try this before you buy another bra.” I had not made my mind up about it, so in it went.

Seven bras and one folded tank laid in a row on a bedspread with a tape measure
The eight, in the order I wore them.

One garment a day, for eight days, living exactly the way I always do. And I am a 38DD, so this was a fair test of whether anything holds. The rules were simple.

  • In the morning, standing up, Frank measured with my sewing tape from the little bone at the base of my neck down to the top edge of the band at the back, and I wrote it on the pad.
  • At six in the evening, before I got out of the recliner, he measured the same spot again. The difference is how far the band had ridden up my back.
  • I wrote down where the wire and the front of the band had ended up, and I was not allowed to straighten anything first.
  • Then I gave the day a score out of ten, for how it had felt to sit in.
A spiral notepad ruled into a scorecard on the arm of a recliner, with a tape measure, a pencil and reading glasses
The pad lived on the arm of my chair all week.

My Scorecard: The Bra Band Rode Up On Seven Out Of Eight

Here it is, typed up from the pad exactly as I wrote it. The red number is how far the band had climbed up my back by six o'clock.

Eight days in my chair

Rode up = inches the band climbed at the back between morning and 6pm. Score = how the day felt, out of 10.

Day 1 · SundayMy everyday underwireWire ends pressing into my side by the second hymn.
2″rode up
3
Day 2Wire-free “comfort” braFront of the band rolled into a cord under my bust.
1½″rode up
4
Day 3 · car tripMinimizer, underwiredWire tipped forward off my ribs in the car.
2½″rode up
2
Day 4Front-closure braThe clasp pressed on my breastbone when I leaned to the table.
1″rode up
4
Day 5Pull-on sports braBottom band rolled up on itself at the front.
1″rode up
4
Day 6Longline bra, wide bandThe wide band folded in half where I bend.
1½″rode up
3
Day 7Soft lounge braletteBand up my back, and nothing much held at the front.
2″rode up
5
Day 8Built-in-bra tankNo band. The tape read the same at 6pm as it did at breakfast.
0″no band
10

Seven bands rode up. The eighth had no band to ride up.

How far each bra band rode up by 6pm

Minimizer2½ in
Underwire2 in
Lounge bralette2 in
Wire-free1½ in
Longline1½ in
Front-closure1 in
Sports bra1 in
Bra tank0 in

Not one of the seven bras stayed where Frank measured it in the morning. The best of them moved an inch. And on day one, without telling me, Frank kept a tally on the corner of his crossword of every time I reached round and pulled my band back down. Twenty-three times in one day. I would have guessed four.

In a hurry? Skip to the one that scored ten

Why A Bra Band Rides Up When You Sit Down

By day four I had stopped blaming the bras one at a time, because they were all doing the same thing. So I stood sideways at the hall mirror, and then I sat down sideways at it on a kitchen chair, and watched.

Diagram: standing, the bra band is level; sitting, the band is pushed up at the front and rides up at the back while the wire tips into the ribs
StandingThe band sits level. The wire lies flat on the ribs.SittingThe band tilts and climbs the back. The wire tips into the ribs.

When I stand, my ribs are lifted and my middle is long and flat. That is the shape the band was fitted to.

When I sit, my ribs settle down toward my lap and my middle shortens and comes forward. The front of the band is now resting on top of my stomach, and my stomach pushes it up from underneath. Every time I lean back in the recliner, or reach for my tea, or shift my weight, the chair drags the back of the band up a little further, and elastic does not climb back down on its own.

The wire is worse. A wire is a stiff curve, and it was shaped for the standing me. It cannot bend when I do. So when I sit, the bottom of it tips forward off my ribs and the two ends press in, one toward my breastbone and one into my side under my arm.

That is all it is. Nothing is wrong with my figure and nothing is wrong with yours. A band and a wire are fitted to a woman standing still, and they are then worn by a woman sitting down.

The Four Seats, And What Each One Did To My Bra

  • The recliner. Leaning back slid the back of the band up, a little at a time, all afternoon. This is where most of the inches came from.
  • The kitchen table. Leaning forward to the newspaper pressed the centre of the wire, or the clasp on the front-closure one, against my breastbone.
  • The church pew. A hard straight back with the hooks of my bra between it and my spine for an hour and a quarter. Helen leaned over during the sermon and whispered, “Margaret, you have been wriggling since the first hymn.”
  • The car. The worst of the four, and it gets its own section.

Two Hours In The Car: My Bra Band Rode Up Two And A Half Inches

Day three was the day we drove to Patty's, two hours each way. I was in the minimizer, which is the bra I would have told you was my best.

Margaret in the passenger seat of the car, seat belt on, reaching behind her shoulder
Somewhere past the first hour. Frank took it at a stop light.

A car seat tips you back and pushes your shoulders forward at the same time, and then the seat belt lies straight across the wire and holds it there. By the time we were on the highway the wire had tipped forward off my ribs, and it stayed tipped for the whole two hours.

Frank measured me in Patty's driveway before I had straightened a thing. The band was two and a half inches higher up my back than it had been at breakfast. Patty watched him do it and said, “Well. That is my answer on that one.”

The Eighth One Had No Band To Ride Up

Day eight was a Sunday again, so the tank Karen had sent got the church pew as well as the kitchen table, the recliner and the sofa.

At six o'clock Frank held the tape to the back of my neck, looked, and said, “There is nothing to measure, Marg. It is where it was.” He had no tally on his crossword either. I had not reached behind me once all day, and I had not noticed that I hadn't.

I turned it inside out over the arm of the chair to see why.

The tank turned inside out over the arm of the recliner, showing the cups stitched into the soft lining
Inside out. The cups are stitched into a soft lining.
  • There is no band round the ribs. So there is nothing for my stomach to push up at the front, and nothing for the chair to drag up my back. The fitted body of the tank runs all the way down to my hips and holds me across the whole of it.
  • There is no wire. Nothing stiff that was shaped for standing. The cups are soft and shaped, and they bend when I bend.
  • The cups are sewn into the lining, all the way round. They are not pads in a pocket, so they stay exactly where they are whether I am upright, leaning back or reaching for the remote. They cannot fold or slide in the wash either.
  • There are no hooks. Nothing between my spine and the back of a pew or a car seat. It pulls on over my head.
  • The straps are as wide as three of my fingers. They lie flat and stay on my shoulders when I lean back.
  • You choose a size the way you would for a top, S to 5XL. No band number to be fitted for, standing or sitting.

Seven bras were built to fit me standing in front of a mirror. The tank is the only one of the eight that fit me in my chair.

Margaret sitting in her recliner in a light blue built-in-bra tank with the crossword in her lap
Day eight, six o'clock. Nothing to pull down.

What I Told Patty

I rang her that evening and read her the whole pad, top to bottom. Then I told her what I am telling you. If you sit most of the day, and at our age a good many of us do, stop asking which bra is the most comfortable. Ask which one was made for a woman who is sitting down. Out of my eight there was one.

I have worn the tank every day since. The seven bras went back in the drawer and I have not opened it. This is the one Karen sent me.

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

Cups sewn in · no band, wire or hooks · six colors, S to 5XL
  • No band round your ribs — nothing to ride up your back when you sit
  • No wire — nothing stiff to tip or press when you lean back
  • Cups sewn into the lining all the way round — they stay put in the chair and in the wash
  • No hooks, wide flat straps — pulls on over your head, sized like a top
See The One That Scored Ten →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Do what I did. Wear it for a whole day in your own chair. If it is not for you, send it back within 45 days for your money back.
P.S. Patty ordered three the night I rang her, so there is always one in the drawer while one is in the wash. She tells me she watched a whole ball game last week without once reaching behind her. I am a 38DD and it holds me from breakfast to bedtime.

With love, from my chair,

Margaret

What My Friends Keep Asking Me

Does a tank with no band really hold a bigger bust sitting down?

I am a 38DD and it has held me all day, every day, since day eight. The hold comes from the shaped cups sewn into the lining and the fitted body of the tank, with the wide straps sharing the work. The sizes go up to 5XL. Wear it for a day in your own chair and judge for yourself; the 45 days are there for exactly that.

Does the tank itself ride up when you sit?

Mine does not. It is a fitted body that runs down to the hips, and I tuck it into my waistband the way I would any top. There is no elastic strip for anything to push against, which is the whole point.

What size do I order?

Your usual top size, from the chart on the order page, S to 5XL. If you are between two sizes, take the larger. It is cut to lie flat against you.

Do the cups come out or fold in the wash?

No. They are stitched into the lining all the way round, so there is no pocket for them to fold up in. Mine go in the machine with everything else.

Can you wear it on its own?

I do, in my chair and round the house. To go out I put a cardigan or a blouse over it. It looks like a plain fitted top with a square neckline.

See If It's In Stock →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee

Comments

Patty
Patty Ellis-ByrdFor the record I only asked which bra. I did not ask for a science project. But she was right, and I have not pulled a band down my back since mine arrived.
Helen
Helen MarshI can confirm the wriggling in church has stopped. I sat down sideways at my own mirror after reading this and watched my band go up. I never knew.
Karen
Karen EllisMom, you scored my present out of ten with a tape measure. Glad it passed. Tell Dad his tally made me laugh.
Individual experiences vary. This page is general information, not medical advice.