The Dowager's Hump That Wasn't: A Physical Therapist's Twelve-Week Case Report
A 59-year-old patient arrived at my clinic certain her upper-back curve was spinal and permanent. On the first exam I asked her to remove one specific garment. Twelve weeks later her kyphotic angle had reduced by 11 degrees. This is her file.
- Patient
- Carol M., 59, retired teacher. Right-hand dominant.
- Chief complaint
- "I think I'm getting a dowager's hump. I don't want to end up like my mother."
- Prior care
- Chiropractic 8 months (no change). Yoga 2 years (no change). Prescribed back brace (abandoned).
- Imaging
- Thoracic X-ray: no osteoporosis, no fracture, no congenital deformity. Spine structurally normal.
- Measured angle
- Kyphotic angle on intake: 52° (normal upper threshold: 40°).
I see Carol's chart four or five times a month. A woman between 50 and 70 arrives at the clinic afraid of her mother's spine, convinced the curve she sees in the mirror is bone collapsing. She has usually done every rehab a doctor could prescribe. None of it has worked, because none of it was aimed at what was actually pulling her forward.
In Carol's case, the first thirty seconds of the exam told me what the problem was, and twelve weeks later I can show you the follow-up photograph.
Exam: What her bra was doing to her upper back
I asked Carol to remove her outer blouse and stand against the posture grid in a running bra for a baseline measurement. I asked her to remove the running bra and put her outer blouse back on. I measured her again.
The second measurement was 8 degrees lower than the first. Her spine had not changed. Her bra had.
Finding: Three things I check before I prescribe anything
I run every new "I'm getting a hump" patient through a 60-second diagnostic. If three of three answers come back a certain way, the intervention is not spinal — it is garment.
60-Second Diagnostic
- Red indentation at the trapezius. Permanent groove where the bra strap sits.
- Rounded shoulders present when bra is on, absent when bra is off. This is the diagnostic one.
- Horizontal pink line across mid-back. Band compression on thinning rib skin.
Carol answered yes to all three. Her imaging was clean, her bone density was in range, and her curve went down 8 degrees the moment the straps came off. The diagnosis wrote itself.
Intervention: What I prescribed instead of a bra
I prescribe a garment with no straps that load the shoulder girdle and no band that compresses the ribcage. In the clinic we call it a load-neutral top. It is a camisole with shaped cups sewn into the lining of the garment — so the support comes from the whole surface area of the chest piece, not from two 2-inch strap vectors.
Carol's home protocol was simple: wear the tank from waking to 7 PM for twelve weeks. No bra underneath, over, or at any point in the day. In parallel, I gave her two mid-back-activation exercises (prone T-raises and a wall slide) she did for four minutes a morning. That is the whole prescription.
Outcome: Twelve weeks, measured against the same grid
Carol returned for follow-up on Week 12 wearing the same clothing and standing against the same grid.
Her kyphotic angle dropped from 52° to 41° — an 11-degree correction, well within the normal upper range. The red groove on her trapezius was gone. The horizontal pink line across her mid-back was gone. In the follow-up photograph her chin is in a different relationship with her collarbone, which is the clinically significant marker — the forward-head posture that always accompanies strap kyphosis had resolved on its own.
Carol has not worn a conventional bra since Week 2. She wears three of these tanks on a rotation and I have not had to see her for the hump again.
The load-neutral tank I prescribe — the Freeform Tank
- Shaped cups stitched into the lining — load distributes across the whole chest piece, not two straps.
- No band, no wire, no clasp — the three mechanical sources of strap kyphosis are all removed.
- Two-inch flat straps that don't bear the cup weight — straps anchor; the garment supports.
- S through 3XL in six colours — I write prescriptions for patients up to size 2XL regularly.
Follow-up notes from readers after this piece ran
Case notes are shared with permission. Carol approved the publication of her file in the hope that it reaches another woman in her position before she spends another year chasing an intervention aimed at the wrong tissue.D. Hashimoto, DPT, OCS · Portland, OR
See Today's Reader Offer →