Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsCommunity discussions · 38,600 members
Discussions›Getting Dressed›Most replied this year
Getting dressed with arthritis

Arthritis in My Hands Means I Can't Do Bra Hooks Anymore. 1,412 Women in This Group Told Me What They Wear Instead.

1,412 replies 9.8K found this helpfulUpdated November 21
Diane Whitaker
Diane WhitakerOriginal post67 · rheumatoid arthritis, both hands · Toledo, Ohio

Does anyone else dread putting on a bra in the morning?

I have rheumatoid arthritis in both hands, and this past year my fingers stopped doing the hooks. I can feel the little hook behind my back, but I can't pinch it and line it up with the eye. Some mornings it takes me ten minutes and I'm in tears before I've had my coffee.

I've tried hooking it at the front and twisting it round, but that drags the band across my skin and my wrists are on fire afterwards. I bought a front-closure bra and the clasp is even smaller. Then I tried a sports bra, got it stuck over my bad shoulder with both arms in the air, and had to call my husband in from the garage.

I'm 67. I don't want to need help getting dressed. What do you all do?

Diane trying to fasten bra hooks behind her back with arthritic hands
This is me most mornings. My granddaughter took it when I asked her to help.
EDIT: I can't reply to everyone, there are over a thousand of you. Thank you. I've ordered what Ruth said (top answer) and I'll update at the bottom when it comes.
Helpful 2.3K Me too 1,184 Reply
1,412 repliesSorted by: Most helpful
Most helpful answer
Ruth Kessler
Ruth Kessler72 · osteoarthritis, both hands and right shoulder · Asheville, NC

Diane, I could have written your post two years ago. Same hooks, same tears. I stopped wearing a bra with hooks altogether and I'm not going back.

What I wear now is a tank top with the bra built into it. There are no hooks, no clasp, no band, nothing to do up anywhere. The neckline is wide and square, so you pull it down over your head with your elbows down by your sides, and you're dressed. The cups are sewn into the lining, so there's nothing to fiddle with or stuff back in with sore fingers.

I was worried it would be a flimsy cami. It isn't. The straps are about as wide as three fingers and it holds me properly. I'm a 36D.

Here's me this morning in the light blue one. That's the whole outfit, no bra under it.

Ruth in her kitchen wearing the light blue built-in-bra tank
Helpful 4.8K Me too 902 41 replies
Diane Whitaker
Diane WhitakerOriginal post

Ruth, thank you. Does it really hold you up? I'm a 38D and I've always thought I needed the wire.

312Reply
Ruth Kessler
Ruth Kessler

It does. The holding comes from the shaped cups being stitched in and the wide straps, not from a band squeezing your ribs. I wear it to the grocery store, to church and to my grandson's ball games, and I don't think about it all day.

588Reply
Teresa Bianchi
Teresa Bianchi71 · Cleveland, Ohio

Ruth's right. I have one in nearly every colour now. It's the Freeform Tank, Diane, if that's what you're asking. It's the one most of us in here mean.

401Reply
Marlene Ostrowski
Marlene Ostrowski69 · osteoarthritis in her thumbs and wrists · Erie, PA

The hook-it-in-front-and-twist trick is what everyone tells you, and I did it for ten years. Nobody tells you what it costs. You drag a tight band all the way round your ribs, and you twist it with your wrists bent, which is exactly the movement that hurts. I had a raw red line round my middle most nights.

My drawer got so full of workarounds it was ridiculous. Extenders, a dressing stick, a front-closure bra I couldn't open. Picture below. All of it went to Goodwill after I switched to the built-in-bra tank Ruth is talking about.

A drawer of bras, extenders and a dressing stick
Helpful 1.9K Me too 655 18 replies
Connie Hale
Connie Hale64 · Boise, Idaho

My hand therapist told me to stop the twisting too. She said bending the wrist and pulling at the same time is the worst thing I can do to my thumbs.

644Reply
Marlene Ostrowski
Marlene Ostrowski

Exactly, Connie. With the tank there's nothing to twist and nothing to fasten. It just goes on.

210Reply
Joyce Whitfield
Joyce Whitfield75 · rheumatoid arthritis · Memphis, TN

Front-closure bras get sold to us as the answer. They are not. That clasp is the size of a fingernail and it takes a pinch grip, which is the first thing RA took from me. I'd get it closed at the bottom and it would pop open at the top.

I wear the black built-in-bra tank under a cardigan now, to church and everywhere else. I put it on in under a minute. Nobody can tell there's no bra. It just looks like a nice top.

Joyce in the black tank under a cardigan, ready to leave for church
Helpful 1.6K Me too 540 9 replies
Ann Pruitt
Ann Pruitt78 · Lancaster, PA

Joyce, the clasp. I thought I was the only one who couldn't work those.

233Reply
See the built-in-bra tank members keep recommending → check the early Black Friday offer
Peggy Lindqvist
Peggy Lindqvist70 · frozen shoulder + arthritis in both hands · Duluth, MN

For anyone with a bad shoulder as well as bad hands: please don't try a sports bra. I got stuck in one with both arms over my head and my left shoulder locked. My neighbour had to come in and get me out.

What makes the tank different is the neck. It's a wide square neckline with stretch, so your head goes through first, then your arms, and you never lift your elbows above your chest. My daughter took this the second morning, a minute after I'd pulled it on by myself. My elbows never went higher than my chest.

Peggy in the nude tank she pulled on by herself
Helpful 1.4K Me too 497 14 replies
Bev Thornton
Bev Thornton63 · Tulsa, OK

That photo sold me. My right shoulder doesn't go any higher than that either.

377Reply
Diane Whitaker
Diane WhitakerOriginal post

Peggy, getting it over my shoulder was the part I was most scared of. Thank you for the picture.

190Reply
Lorraine Ruiz
Lorraine Ruiz66 · psoriatic arthritis in her fingers · Tucson, AZ

One more for those of us with bad fingers: stay away from the cheap shelf-bra camis with foam pads in a pocket. The pads fold in half in the wash, and then you're sat on the bed trying to push them back into a little slit with fingers that won't work. I gave up on mine.

In the tank Ruth and the others mean, the cups are sewn right into the lining. I turned mine inside out to check before I trusted it. Stitched all the way round. Nothing comes out, nothing folds, and it comes out of the dryer the same shape it went in.

The tank turned inside out showing the cups sewn into the lining
Helpful 1.2K Me too 318 6 replies
Shirley Dunn
Shirley Dunn74 · Wichita, KS

That's why I quit those camis too. Good to know these are sewn in.

158Reply
Shirley Dunn
Shirley Dunn74 · osteoarthritis · Wichita, KS

I'll be honest, for about a year I just stopped wearing anything. My hands won. But I felt undressed every time I answered the door, and by the afternoon the weight pulling on my neck and upper back made my shoulders ache worse than the arthritis did. Going braless isn't the freedom it sounds like when you're a 40C.

My daughter bought me two of the tanks for my birthday. I'm held up, I'm dressed, and I didn't have to ask anybody for help to get there.

Helpful 980 Me too 611 7 replies
Joyce Whitfield
Joyce Whitfield

Shirley, same. I didn't realise how much going without was keeping me at home.

140Reply
Ann Pruitt
Ann Pruitt78 · rheumatoid arthritis · Lancaster, PA

My husband has done my bra hooks every morning for six years. He never once complained, but I hated it. It's such a small thing to need help with.

I've worn the tank for two months now. Last week he went fishing at five in the morning and I got dressed by myself for the first time in years. I know that sounds like nothing to some people.

Helpful 870 Me too 724 23 replies
Ruth Kessler
Ruth Kessler

It doesn't sound like nothing, Ann. It's everything.

512Reply
Marlene Ostrowski
Marlene Ostrowski

Sat at my kitchen table with tears in my eyes reading this.

266Reply
Pinned by the moderators
Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsModeratorGroup team

What 1,412 Members With Arthritis Said About Bra Hooks, in One Place

Diane's post is now the most-replied thread in this group's history, and a lot of you have messaged asking for one place with the answers. Here it is: every way of getting dressed that members said their hands and shoulders couldn't manage, and what they said works instead.

What made it hardWhat members said works
Bra hooks behind your backNo hooks or clasp anywhere
Hooking in front and twisting it roundNothing to twist, it pulls on
A tiny front clasp that needs a pinch gripNo fastening at all
A sports bra over a stiff shoulderWide stretch square neck, elbows stay low
Foam pads to stuff back inCups sewn into the lining
Thin straps on sore shouldersStraps as wide as three fingers

Almost every recommendation in this thread names the same top: the Freeform Tank, a tank top with the bra built in. Plenty of you have asked where to get it, so here's where members have been ordering.

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

11,482 reviews
Most members pick this5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free$24.00 a tank
$400.00$120.00
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free$26.66 a tank
$240.00$80.00
1 TankTry one first
$80.00$40.00
  • No hooks, no clasp, no band — nothing to fasten with sore fingers
  • Wide stretch square neckline — pulls on with your elbows low
  • Cups sewn into the lining — nothing to stuff back in, can't fold in the wash
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — six colours, S to 5XL, free US shipping
Check Availability →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Wear it for a few mornings. If it isn't right for your hands, you have 45 days to send it back for your money.
  • Sizing, from members: go by your usual bra size on the chart on the order page. Between two sizes, take the larger.
  • Colour, from members: most started with nude or black, then came back for the light blue and burgundy.
Newest reply
Update from Diane
Diane Whitaker
Diane WhitakerOriginal postthree weeks later

UPDATE, like I promised. It came on a Tuesday. I stood at my dresser, put my head through the neck the way Peggy showed, then my arms, and pulled it down with my elbows by my sides. I was dressed in under a minute. No hooks, no twisting, no calling my husband in from the garage.

I've worn it every day since. I'm a 38D and I'm held up all day, and at night there's nothing to unhook. I ordered two more, black and white. Thank you, every one of you. I mean it.

Helpful 3.1K Me too 1,027 88 replies
Ruth Kessler
Ruth Kessler

Oh Diane, this made my whole week. Welcome to the club.

702Reply
See the Tank Members Recommend →Early Black Friday: Buy 4 Get 4 Free while stock lasts