Barbara Hayes
Barbara HayesNotes from my kitchen table
Twelve of us · four months

Twelve Women Over 60 Spent Four Months Finding Everything Wrong With a Built-In-Bra Tank. I'm a 40DD and I Was One of Them. Here's What We Made Them Change.

The cups folded in the wash. The straps dug grooves in our shoulders. The band rolled up our backs. One of us couldn't even get it over her head. We sent it back four times, until all twelve of us could wear it from breakfast to bedtime.

Barbara Hayes
Barbara Hayes, 66Retired school secretary, Ohio · November 21, 2026 · 6 min read
Barbara with some of the twelve women on the church porch
The twelve of us on the back porch of our church, the night we handed in our first forms. I'm the one in pink.

I wore an underwire bra for forty years. I'm a 40DD, and if you're anywhere near my size you already know the rest: the straps leave two red ditches in your shoulders by supper, the band pinches every time you sit down, and the first thing you do when you walk in the door is reach behind your back and unhook it.

So when a notice went into our church bulletin last spring asking for women over 60 to wear-test a tank top with a bra built into it, and tell the makers honestly what was wrong with it, I signed up mostly to complain. So did eleven other women from church and my street. Joanne, who sits behind me, signed up because a frozen shoulder means she can't reach a bra hook at all anymore.

The deal was simple. They mailed us a version. We wore it every day we could, through ordinary days: church, groceries, gardening, grandkids, a long car ride. Every Sunday we filled in a one-page form. Then they changed it and mailed the next one.

Barbara filling in a feedback form at her patio table
Sunday afternoon form, out on my patio. I did not hold back.

The Twelve of Us

Ages 61 to 77, bra sizes 34B to 44DD. No models, no fitters. Just women who were tired of their bras.

Barbara, 66Barbara, 6640DD, me
Joanne, 71Joanne, 7136C
Linda, 63Linda, 6338DDD
Carol, 69Carol, 6934B
Dottie, 74Dottie, 7442DD
Pat, 61Pat, 6136D
Gloria, 68Gloria, 6840D
Marge, 77Marge, 7738C
Sue, 64Sue, 6444DD
Rosa, 67Rosa, 6736DD
Nancy, 70Nancy, 7034C
Helen, 72Helen, 7238D

Version 1 to the Final Tank: What Was Wrong With Each One, and What They Changed

On each form, the question that mattered was the last one: could you wear it a full day, 7am to 9pm, without wanting to take it off? Here is how many of us said yes each time.

Version 1 · June

The Loose Bra Pads Folded in Half in the First Wash

Loose foam pads folded after the wash
What was wrong: the cups were two foam pads tucked into a pocket, like every shelf-bra cami in the store. I'm a 40DD. That version failed me in a week. The pads came out of the washer folded like tacos, and on me they slid sideways by lunch.
What they changed: the cups are now shaped and sewn permanently into the lining, stitched all the way round. No pocket, nothing to take out, nothing to fold.
3 of 12 wore it a full day
Version 2 · July

Thin Bra Straps Dug Grooves Into Our Shoulders by Mid-Afternoon

Red groove left in a shoulder by a thin strap
What was wrong: the straps were barely wider than a shoelace. With the cups sewn in, the tank was holding us properly now, which meant all that weight hung on two thin lines. Linda, a 38DDD, had the same red grooves she gets from her bra by 3pm.
What they changed: the straps were widened to about two inches, as wide as three of my fingers laid side by side, and flat. The weight spreads across the top of the shoulder instead of cutting into one line.
5 of 12 wore it a full day
Version 3 · August

The Elastic Bra Band Rolled Up Our Backs Every Time We Sat Down

An elastic band rolled up across a woman's back
What was wrong: version 3 had an elastic band sewn under the bust, because that is how bras are built. On us it rolled into a rope at the back, dug into our ribs in the car, and pushed up the same roll under a T-shirt we were all trying to get away from. Dottie wrote "this is just a bra again" across her whole form.
What they changed: they took the band out completely. The sewn-in cups and the wide straps do the holding, and the body of the tank is fitted, the way a good T-shirt is, so there is nothing tight round your ribs to roll.
8 of 12 wore it a full day
See the final tank all twelve of us wear now → check the early Black Friday offer
Version 4 · September

A Narrow Neck Was Impossible to Get Over a Stiff Shoulder

Joanne stuck pulling a narrow-necked top over her head
What was wrong: this one was nearly there, but the neck was a small scoop. Joanne got one arm in, then her frozen shoulder stopped at chest height and she was stuck inside it in her bedroom until her husband came. If the whole point is no hooks behind your back, it has to go on with arms that don't lift.
What they changed: a wide stretch square neckline. It opens enough to step into or pull down over your head with your elbows barely raised, and it sits straight across, so it doesn't gape when you lean over the sink.
10 of 12 wore it a full day
The final tank · October

All Twelve of Us Wore It a Full Day, With No Bra Underneath

The final tank turned inside out, cups sewn into the lining

The last box came the first week of October. We wore it to church that Sunday, to the potluck after, and on through supper. Twelve forms came back with the same answer: yes, a full day. Joanne put hers on by herself. Dottie wrote "do not change anything" and underlined it twice.

12 of 12 wore it a full day

The Four Bra Problems We Sent Back, on One Page

We told themSo nowFull day
Pads folded in the washCups sewn into the lining3/12
Thin straps dug groovesStraps three fingers wide5/12
Band rolled up the backNo band at all8/12
Stuck on a stiff shoulderWide stretch square neck10/12
The final tankNothing left to send back12/12

What It's Like on a 40DD Now

Barbara wearing the light blue tank on her patio
Me on the patio in the light blue one. No bra under it. That's the whole outfit.

I pull it on over my head in the morning and I don't think about it again. I'm held up, I'm smooth under a blouse, and at night there's nothing to unhook and no red marks on my shoulders or round my ribs. I have not worn an underwire since September.

Three fingers laid across the wide strap
The strap I show anyone at church who asks. As wide as three of my fingers, and flat.
  • Cups sewn into the lining, so they come out of the wash the same shape they went in
  • Straps as wide as three fingers, so nothing cuts into your shoulders
  • No band, no wire, no hooks, so nothing rolls, pinches or needs reaching behind you
  • A wide square neckline that goes on over your head with stiff shoulders, and looks like a nice top

They call it the Freeform Tank now, and it comes in the six colours we picked off a card at the last meeting: light blue, white, nude, black, burgundy and coffee, small to 5XL. I wear the 2XL.

Testers in the church kitchen wearing the tanks
After the October potluck in the church kitchen. That's me in the middle in the burgundy one, under a cardigan.

What the Others Wrote on Their Last Form

Copied off the final forms, with their say-so.

Joanne P., 71
Joanne P., 71 36C, frozen shoulder

"I dressed myself this morning without calling anyone. I haven't been able to say that about a bra in three years."

Linda K., 63
Linda K., 63 38DDD

"I took it off at bedtime and there were no grooves in my shoulders. I actually went and got my husband to look."

Dottie M., 74
Dottie M., 74 42DD

"I was the one who kept writing that it was just a bra again. This last one isn't. Do not change anything."

Gloria J., 68
Gloria J., 68 40D

"Wore the black one to my granddaughter's recital under a blouse. Smooth all the way round the back, which I could never say before."

Sue E., 64
Sue E., 64 44DD

"I was sure nothing without wire would hold me. I gardened in it for four hours on a Saturday and didn't think about it once."

Rosa A., 67
Rosa A., 67 36DD

"Four washes, the cups came out the same shape every time. The pads in version 1 didn't make it through one."

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

11,482 reviews
Most of us got this5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free$24.00 a tank
$400.00$120.00
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free$26.66 a tank
$240.00$80.00
1 TankTry one first
$80.00$40.00
  • Cups sewn into the lining — they can't fold or shift in the wash
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — no shoulder grooves
  • No band, no wire, no hooks — pulls on over your head
  • Six colours, S to 5XL — free US shipping
Check Availability →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Do what we did: wear it a full day. If it isn't right for you, you have 45 days to send it back for your money.

What People at Church Ask Me Most

Will it really hold a 40DD?

It holds me, and I'm a 40DD. Linda is a 38DDD and Sue is a 44DD, and both wore the final one a full day. The cups are sewn in and shaped, and the wide straps take the weight, so you are held up without a band squeezing your ribs.

What size do I order?

Go by your usual bra size on the chart on the order page, S to 5XL. I'm a 40DD and wear the 2XL. If you're between two sizes, take the larger.

Can I get it on with a bad shoulder?

That's exactly what version 4 was about. The square neckline stretches wide enough to pull down over your head with your elbows barely raised. Joanne, with her frozen shoulder, dresses herself in it every morning.

Does it look like underwear?

No. It looks like a plain, nice tank top. I wear it on its own around the house and in the garden, and under a cardigan to church.

See the Early Black Friday Offer →Buy 4 Get 4 Free while stock lasts

Barbara HayesTake it from twelve women who sent it back four times,
Barbara