5 Reasons Women Over 60 Who Gave Up Their Bra Keep Getting Asked If They've Lost Weight
They haven't lost a pound. What's gone is the tight band round their ribs, and with it the roll under their tops, the bust that sat too low and the shoulders that curled forward. We asked five readers what people said to them, and what was really going on.
It is one of the most common things readers over 60 tell us after they stop wearing a bra with a band. Somebody, usually somebody who sees them every day, looks them up and down and asks "Have you lost weight?"
When we asked readers to write in about it, more than 300 did. Almost none of them had changed what they ate. Most of them were exactly the same weight. What had changed was what was round their ribs. Here are five of their stories, and the plain reason behind each one.
A Tight Bra Band Pushes Up a Roll on Your Back That Shows Through Every Knit Top
Have you lost weight? Your back looks different in that sweater.Her husband, to Patricia R., 64, Indiana


Same sweater, same hallway, the same week. Patricia weighed the same on both days.
Patricia had stopped wearing her fitted sweaters years ago. "I thought the ridge across my back was just my age," she told us. "So I bought everything a size bigger and looser, which made me look bigger still."
Her daughter took the two pictures above in the same sweater, a few days apart. On the left she is wearing her usual bra. On the right she is wearing a tank with the bra built in. The ridge and the two rolls either side of it are gone.
A Bra Band That Rides Up Lets Your Bust Drop, and Your Waist Looks Thicker
Mom, did you lose weight? You look like you've got a waist again.Her daughter, to Diane K., 67, Georgia
Diane's daughter dropped by with groceries and stopped in the doorway. "She thought I'd been on a diet," Diane said. "I'd been eating the same as always. I'd just started wearing the tank she'd laughed at."
What her daughter was seeing was her bust sitting where it used to sit. When your bust sits higher, there is a gap again between your bust and your waist, and the eye reads that gap as a smaller middle.
Thin Bra Straps Pull Your Shoulders Forward All Day, and a Rounded Back Looks Heavier
Joyce, you're standing so straight. Have you lost weight?A friend at church, to Joyce M., 71, Pennsylvania
Joyce is a 38D. For years her straps left grooves in her shoulders by lunchtime, and without thinking about it she had started to curl her shoulders forward to take the pull off them. "I didn't know I was doing it until I stopped," she said.
Two weeks after she switched, a friend at church took her by the arm after the service and asked if she'd lost weight. She hadn't. She was standing up straight.
Tugging at a Bra All Day Keeps Your Arms Folded Over Your Middle
You're the same weight as last year. What did you change? You look so much more comfortable.Her doctor, to Sandra L., 62, Arizona
Sandra's doctor is the only person in this story who checked. At her yearly checkup the nurse weighed her: the same as last year to the pound. Her doctor looked up from the chart and asked what she'd changed, because she looked different.
Sandra worked it out on the drive home. "I used to spend the whole day fixing my bra. Pulling the band down at the back, hitching a strap, pressing the wire away from under my arm. When I wasn't fixing it, I had my arms folded over my stomach to hide the bulge." Nothing to fix meant her arms were down by her sides, and she sat back in the chair instead of hunched over.
A Built-In-Bra Tank Has No Band to Roll, Ride Up or Dig In
What have you done? You look ten pounds lighter.Her sister, to Gloria T., 69, Texas
Every reader in this piece had switched to the same kind of top: a tank with the bra built into it. Gloria's sister didn't believe her until Gloria went inside and brought one out, turned inside out.
This is the part that surprises people. The old shelf-bra camisoles had a strip of elastic and two loose foam pads that folded in the wash. In this tank the cups are shaped and sewn into the lining, so they hold you and keep their shape. There is no band, no wire and no hooks. The straps are as wide as three fingers, the neckline is cut straight across, and the front is smooth and plain, so it passes for an ordinary nice top.
That is the whole reason for every "have you lost weight?" in this article. Nothing round your ribs means nothing pushing up a roll, nothing riding up, nothing digging into your shoulders and nothing to fix all day.
What People Said, What Actually Changed, and the Weight They Lost
| Reader | What she heard | What really changed | Lbs lost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patricia, 64 | "Your back looks different" | No band pushing up a back roll | 0 |
| Diane, 67 | "You've got a waist again" | Bust no longer dropping by afternoon | 0 |
| Joyce, 71 | "You're standing so straight" | No thin straps to hunch away from | 0 |
| Sandra, 62 | "You look more comfortable" | Nothing to tug at all day | 0 |
| Gloria, 69 | "Ten pounds lighter" | All of the above | 0 |
None of these women lost weight. The tank doesn't make you lighter. It takes away the band that was making you look heavier.
The Tank These Readers Are Wearing Instead of a Bra
- No band round your ribs, so there is no roll on your back and nothing riding up
- Cups sewn into the lining, so your bust stays at the same height all day and the cups can't fold in the wash
- Straps as wide as three fingers, flat, so they don't dig into your shoulders or slide off
- A smooth plain front and a square neckline, so it looks like a nice top on its own or under a cardigan
- No hooks and no wire; it pulls on over your head
It's called the Freeform Tank. It comes in light blue, white, nude, black, burgundy and coffee, and you order it in your usual top size.
The Freeform Tank
- No band, no back roll — nothing squeezing your ribs
- Holds you all day — shaped cups sewn in for good
- Wide flat straps — no digging, no slipping
- Six colours — mix them in one order, free US shipping
Readers on Giving Up the Bra Band
From the letters we received for this piece.