The Over-60 Report
HealthMoneyBuyer's GuidesHome
The Interview

A Nurse of 30 Years: I Gave Women Over 60 the Wrong Bra Advice

For three decades Ruth Callahan told every woman with sore shoulders to go and get a properly fitted underwire bra. Now 71, she says that advice was wrong for women over 60, and she has five things she would tell her old patients instead.

By Diane Mercer, Health ReporterThe Over-60 Report · Updated November 21, 2026 · 6 min read
Retired nurse Ruth Callahan at her kitchen table

Ruth Callahan, 71, at her kitchen table in Dayton, Ohio. She was a registered nurse for 30 years, most of them in a women's health clinic.

Ruth Callahan does not like to be wrong, and she says so before I have my notebook open. "I was a nurse for thirty years. When a woman came in with sore shoulders, a red line round her ribs or a rash under the bust, I said the same thing every time: you need a properly fitted underwire. Go and get measured."

She estimates she gave that advice to a few thousand women. Most of them were over 50. Many were over 60.

"And for women over 60 it was the wrong advice," she says. "I didn't understand that until I was one of them."

I owe every woman over 60 I ever sent to a bra fitting an apology. The fit was never the problem. The bra was.

Ruth Callahan, retired RN

What changed her mind was her own body. At 68 she was still wearing the underwire she had recommended to everyone else, measured and fitted. By the middle of every afternoon her shoulders ached, the band had left a groove under her shoulder blades, and some mornings she could not get her arm far enough behind her back to do up the hooks.

"I'd had the best-fitted bra money can buy and it hurt more every year," she says. "So I started paying attention to why."

What changes after 60, in Ruth's words

The skin gets thinner. A band that left a faint mark at 40 leaves a red groove at 70, because there is less padding between the elastic and the rib.

The shoulders get stiffer. Reaching behind your back to fasten hooks is one of the first movements a stiff shoulder loses.

The band never moves. It sits on exactly the same strip of skin for 14 hours a day, every day.

Where an ordinary bra presses on a woman over 60: the band, the hooks, the straps and the underwire

The four places an ordinary bra presses: the band round the ribs, the hooks in the middle of the back, the straps on the shoulders and the underwire under the bust.

I asked her what she would tell her old patients now, if she could see them again. She had the answer written down already: five things.

1
What she'd tell them now

The Bra Band Does Most of the Work, and After 60 the Skin Under It Can't Take It

A red pressure line across a woman's back where her bra band sat all day

"Every woman thinks the straps hold her up. They don't. About 80 percent of the holding in an ordinary bra comes from the band pulled tight round the ribs," Ruth says. "That's why a fitter makes the band so snug."

On younger skin, a snug band leaves a faint line that is gone by morning. After 60 the skin is thinner and there is less under it, so the same pressure presses straight onto the ribs. She saw it in the clinic for years without connecting it: red grooves under the shoulder blades, rubbed patches where the hooks sit, rashes along the line of the band, women who took their bra off the minute they got home.

What she used to say

Your band is too loose. Go down a band size so it sits firm.

What she says now

The band is the part that hurts. Get rid of the band, not the size.

2
What she'd tell them now

Thin Bra Straps Press Two Grooves Into Shoulders That Are Already Stiff

A groove on the top of a woman's shoulder from a thin bra strap

Whatever the band does not carry, the straps do, and on most bras they are about half an inch wide. "That's the whole weight of your bust on two thin lines across the top of the shoulder," Ruth says. "As the band stretches over the day, more of the weight moves onto them."

After 60 the muscles across the top of the shoulders are often already tight. A thin strap pressing on the same spot for hours is why so many women feel a knot by the side of the neck by mid-afternoon, and why the groove is still there at bedtime.

What she used to say

Tighten your straps so they stop slipping.

What she says now

A strap should be as wide as three fingers, so the weight spreads across the shoulder.

3
What she'd tell them now

Bra Hooks Behind the Back Ask a Stiff Shoulder for Its Hardest Movement Every Morning

A woman sitting on her bed struggling to fasten her bra hooks behind her back

Twisting both arms up behind you and finding three tiny hooks by feel is, Ruth says, one of the first everyday movements a stiff shoulder or arthritic fingers start to refuse. "I had patients who fastened the bra at the front and spun it round, and patients who slept in it so they wouldn't have to do it again in the morning. I told them that was fine. It wasn't."

She did it herself for two years. "Some mornings it took me five minutes and a lot of language."

What she used to say

Try a front-closure bra.

What she says now

Don't move the hooks. Wear something with no hooks at all, that goes on over your head.

4
What she'd tell them now

An Underwire Fitted for a Younger Shape Presses on the Ribs After 60

A worn underwire bra with the wire poking out of its channel

"This is the one I'm most sorry about," Ruth says. "Underwire was my answer for everything."

A wire is a fixed curve of metal. After menopause the bust usually becomes softer, wider and sits lower than the shape the wire was designed around, so instead of sitting under the breast the wire ends up pressing on the ribs at the front and digging into the soft tissue at the sides. Wires also work their way out of the fabric channel after enough washes. "I've seen the scratch marks," she says.

What she used to say

A properly fitted underwire gives the best support.

What she says now

Support should come from shaped cups that hold you, not a wire that presses on you.

5
What she'd tell them now

Stop Fitting the Woman to the Bra. Take the Bra Band Out Altogether.

Ruth reaching up to a kitchen shelf in the Freeform Tank

For a long time Ruth assumed the only alternative was going without, and she knew from the clinic what that does for a full bust by the afternoon: the weight pulls forward on the neck and upper back, and skin rubs on skin underneath.

What she wears now is a tank top with the bra built into it. Her daughter found it. "I was sceptical. I'd seen shelf-bra camisoles: a strip of elastic and two foam pads that fold in half in the wash. This isn't that."

The one she wears is the Freeform Tank. The shaped cups are sewn into the lining all the way round, so they hold and lift and cannot fold or shift in the wash. Because the lift comes from those cups and the fitted body of the tank, there is no band round the ribs, no wire and no hooks. The straps are about two inches wide, as wide as three fingers. And it goes on over the head with the arms lifted only to shoulder height.

Nothing presses on the same strip of skin all day. For the first time in years I don't have a groove anywhere when I get undressed.

Ruth Callahan, 71

What she used to say

Get measured and buy the bra that fits.

What she says now

No band, no wire, no hooks, wide straps, cups sewn in. Order your usual size and stop being measured.

Why the Tank Works Where the Fitted Bra Didn't

Ruth's point is simple. Every problem on her list comes from the parts of an ordinary bra that press on one spot: the band, the hooks, the thin straps and the wire. The Freeform takes all four away and keeps the lift, because the support is built into the tank itself.

Inside the Freeform Tank: shaped cups stitched into the lining

Turned inside out: the shaped cups are stitched into the lining all the way round. No pocket, no loose pad.

  • No band round the ribs. Nothing pressing a line into thin skin for 14 hours.
  • Straps about two inches wide, flat, so the weight spreads across the shoulder instead of grooving it.
  • No hooks. Pulls on over the head with the arms at shoulder height.
  • No underwire. Shaped cups sewn into the lining do the lifting, and keep their shape in every wash.
  • Square neckline, smooth front. Looks like a nice top on its own or under a cardigan. Six colours, S to 3XL.
Ruth in her garden in the evening wearing the Freeform Tank

Ruth in her vegetable garden at six in the evening. "I used to have my bra off before I'd put the kettle on."

Readers asked Ruth

Isn't going without a bra bad for you at our age?
"It isn't dangerous, but for a C cup and up it isn't comfortable either. With no support the weight pulls on your neck and upper back. You don't have to choose between that and a band. The cups in the tank hold you up without one."
Will it really hold a bigger bust?
"The cups are shaped and sewn in, not a strip of elastic, and the straps are wide. Several of the women in my walking group are a D or bigger and they wear it all day."
What size do I order?
"Your usual size. It comes in S to 3XL, and the order page has a chart that matches it to the bra size you wear now. No more being measured."
What about a sports bra?
"A sports bra holds you by squeezing, with an even tighter band, and you have to drag it over a stiff shoulder. Keep it for exercise if you like it."
What Ruth wears now
Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

11,482 reviews
As low as $24 a tank
1 Tank Try one
$40$80
Most popular
3 Tanks Buy 2, get 1 free · $26.66 each
$80$240
Best value
5 Tanks Buy 3, get 2 free · $24 each
$120$400
Check Availability →Early Black Friday: Buy 3 Get 2 Free · free US shipping
45-Day Guarantee. Wear it in place of your bra for six weeks. If your shoulders, ribs and back don't feel the difference, send it back for a full refund.
Ruth's tip: "Start with three. You'll wear one every day and you'll want one in the wash. The nude goes under everything."

Readers Who Took Ruth's Advice

A nurse told me to get fitted for an underwire in 2009 and I've been buying them ever since. The groove on my shoulders is gone after a month in the tank.

Donna W., 68 · Indiana · 38D

My shoulder won't go behind my back anymore. This goes over my head and I'm dressed. No hooks, no asking my husband.

Gloria M., 73 · Texas · frozen shoulder

I thought the red line round my ribs was just part of getting older. It was the band. It's gone.

Sandra J., 66 · Georgia · 40DD

I'm 75 and a 42DD. I expected it to flatten me. It lifts, and at six o'clock I've forgotten I have it on.

Helen R., 75 · Pennsylvania · 42DD
See Colours & Sizes →Early Black Friday: Buy 3 Get 2 Free while it lasts