Group members around a porch table
Comfortable After 60

Comfortable After 60: Stories & Discussions

Community · 51.6K members
Joan Albright
Joan Albright AdminNovember 21 · Pinned post
Member survey results

We Asked 2,400 Members Why They Stopped Buying Bras Online. Here's What They Wear Now.

It started with Patricia's post about her top drawer: fourteen bras, every one of them right in the store or on the website, and not one she could wear past lunch. Hundreds of you answered her with your own drawers.

So we asked the whole community properly: why did you stop buying bras online, and what do you wear now? 2,400 of you answered. I've grouped the most-hearted answers by the four reasons you gave most, then what most of you switched to.

Why members stopped buying bras online

2,400 members answered. Members could pick more than one.

I don't know my bra size anymore71%
Every brand sizes bras differently64%
I was sick of sending bras back58%
It fit in the fitting room, then dug in all day49%
Patricia Doyle
Patricia Doyle68 · Dayton, Ohio · the post that started it

Counted the bras in my top drawer this morning. Fourteen. Every one of them fit in the store or looked right on the website. I wear two, and I don't like either of them. I'm 68 and I honestly could not tell you my bra size today. Do the rest of you even know yours?

Patricia holding up a bra beside her dresser drawer full of bras, some with tags still on
5.2K1,486 comments
1
71% of members

After 60, Your Bra Size Changes Every Few Years

What members described: the number you learned at 40 stopped being true somewhere in your fifties. Weight goes up or down a few pounds, the breast tissue gets softer and sits lower after menopause, and the ribcage measures differently. A band number and a cup letter that were right three years ago describe a body you don't have anymore. Then the bra you buy in your old size gapes at the top or cuts in at the bottom.

Bev Sandoval 66, New Mexico

I was a 36C my whole adult life. Since 60 I've been a 38B, a 38C and now apparently a 40B. Same woman. I don't even know what to type into the box anymore.

1.3KReply
Darlene Fisk 71, Wisconsin

I sew, so I own a good tape measure. Measured myself three times on Sunday following one of those online bra charts. Got three different numbers. My granddaughter took this while I was standing there squinting at it.

Darlene measuring under her bust with a tape measure, bras laid out on the bed
982Reply
Edith Yamamoto 69, California

Darlene, same. And the bra charts all say "measure snugly." How snug? Snug enough to breathe?

504Reply
2
64% of members

Every Brand Sizes a Bra Differently

What members described: even when you do know your size, it doesn't travel. A 38C in one brand fits the same as a 36D in the next. Each website has its own chart, its own "sister sizes" and its own advice to size up or down. A bra has two numbers that both have to be right, the band within about an inch and the cup within one letter, so there are a dozen ways to get it wrong and one way to get it right.

Carla Novak 62, Pennsylvania

I have a 38C in my drawer that's really a 36. I have a 38C that's really a 40. Same size on the tag, from two different brands, and I paid full price for both.

871Reply
Ruth Kessler 75, Iowa

The website told me to "try a sister size." I'm 75 years old. I don't want a sister size, I want a bra that fits the first time.

1.1KReply
3
58% of members

Ordering Bras Online Means Ordering Three Sizes and Sending Two Back

What members described: because the size is a guess, the advice is to order two or three and return the rest. That means the reprinted labels, the trip to the post office, waiting weeks for the refund, and the ones you missed the return window on and kept. Members said this is how the drawer fills up.

Gwen Hartley 64, Tennessee

This was my kitchen counter last spring. Three bras, three sizes, two going back. Then the third one I kept dug in by Thursday anyway. I stood in line at the post office twice for that.

Gwen packing a bra back into a mailing bag with two more return parcels on the counter
1.4KReply
Maureen Gallagher 73, Massachusetts

And by the time the refund comes you've forgotten which one you sent back and which one is in the drawer.

466Reply
4
49% of members

A Bra That Fits in the Fitting Room Digs In by Lunch

What members described: going to a store didn't solve it either. In a fitting room you stand still for three minutes. At home you sit, bend, reach and drive. The band rides up and settles on the ribs, the underwire presses in when you sit down, and the straps start to dig once they're carrying the weight all day. So the bra that was right at 10am is the one you're unhooking under your shirt at 2pm.

Loretta Banks 70, Georgia

I'm a 40DD. I let a lady at the department store fit me properly, tape measure and all. Bought two at full price. By the time I got home from church that Sunday the band had left a red line round my back. She fit me standing up. I don't live standing up.

1.6KReply
Patricia Doyle 68, Ohio

Loretta, that's my drawer in one sentence. Every one of the fourteen fit in the fitting room.

733Reply
Joan Albright
Joan Albright AdminWhat members wear now

Then the part everyone wanted to know: what do you wear now, if you stopped buying bras? One answer came up more than all the others put together.

The sports bra answers came with the same complaint: they're sized by band and cup too, they're a fight to get on over stiff shoulders, and the band is just as tight. Bralettes don't hold a full bust all day. Going without works at home and nowhere else.

The built-in-bra tank answers had one name in them again and again: the Freeform Tank. And the reason members gave most wasn't comfort first. It was this: there's no bra size to guess. You order your T-shirt size.

Your T-shirt size is your tank sizeThe size chart members shared most
Your T-shirtYour tankTop size
Small=S4–6
Medium=M8–10
Large=L12–14
XL=XL16–18
2XL=2XL20–22
3XL=3XL24–26
Between two sizes? Take the larger one. If you still know your bra size, the order page lists the bra sizes each tank size fits.

Why there's no bra size to guess

  • No band to measure. On a bra, the band is the number that has to be right to the inch. This has no band round the ribs at all, so there's nothing to measure snugly and nothing to ride up when you sit.
  • No cup letter. Shaped cups are sewn into the lining in each size, and the fabric stretches four ways, so the cup settles to the shape you have now, not the one on a chart.
  • Cut like a top. The body is fitted and straight, sized S to 3XL the way your T-shirts are. If you know what you wear in a T-shirt, you know your size.
  • Straps as wide as three fingers. Nothing to adjust, and the weight spreads across the whole strap, so they stay put on a sloping shoulder.
  • 45 days to decide. If the size isn't right, the guarantee covers it.
Loretta Banks 70, Georgia

I asked what every 40DD asks: no cup size, so does it actually HOLD me? A friend from here turned hers inside out for me. Real shaped cups, sewn in all the way round. Not a strip of elastic, not a loose pad. I ordered an XL because that's my T-shirt size, and it holds me better than the two the store fitted me in.

The tank turned inside out: shaped cups sewn into the lining
2.2KTop answerReply

One more number from the survey, because a lot of you asked: of the members who switched, 86% kept the first size they ordered.

See the tank members order in their T-shirt size →
Patricia Doyle
Patricia DoyleUpdate · three weeks later

OK ladies, you talked me into it. I wear a Medium in every T-shirt I own, so I ordered three Mediums. They fit the day they came. The fourteen bras went to the church clothing drive and the top drawer is tanks now. First time in ten years I haven't had to guess a number.

Patricia in the light blue tank beside her dresser, folded tanks in the drawer
6.1K812 comments
Gwen Hartley
Gwen HartleyUpdate · the mailbox

One parcel. One size. Nothing going back. I'm a Large in tops, ordered Large, and I opened it at the counter and wore the black one straight to my grandson's ball game. My husband asked where the return bags were. There aren't any.

Gwen laughing in her kitchen in the black tank, holding the opened parcel
3.9K441 comments
Loretta Banks
Loretta BanksUpdate · Sunday afternoon

Church, lunch, and two hours on the porch swing in the burgundy one. No red line round my back when I changed tonight. No fitting room, no tape measure, no lady telling me I'm a size I've never heard of.

Loretta laughing on her porch swing in the burgundy tank
4.4K503 comments
Members' pick · order your T-shirt size
Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

★★★★★ 11,482 reviews
Most chosen5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free$24.00 a tank
$400.00$120.00
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free$26.66 a tank · mix colours
$240.00$80.00
1 TankTry one first
$80.00$40.00
  • Order your T-shirt size, S to 3XL — no band number, no cup letter
  • No band, no wire, no hooks — nothing to ride up or dig in by lunch
  • Cups sewn into the lining — hold their shape wash after wash
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — nothing to adjust

Six colours, and you pick each one:

Nude
Black
Burgundy
Light Blue
White
Coffee
Pick My Size & Colours →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Order your T-shirt size and wear it for a while. If it isn't right for you, send it back within 45 days.
Joan Albright
Joan Albright AdminA few more from the thread
Bev Sandoval 66, New Mexico

36C, 38B, 38C, 40B. Doesn't matter anymore. I'm an L in tops and I've been an L for fifteen years. Ordered L.

892Reply
Darlene Fisk 71, Wisconsin

The tape measure is back in the sewing box where it belongs. Ordered my T-shirt size, which is XL, and it fits.

614Reply
Ruth Kessler 75, Iowa

No sister sizes. Pulls on over my head and there's nothing to fasten. At 75 that's all I wanted.

577Reply
Carla Novak 62, Pennsylvania

Went for the five so I could mix colours. White and nude for under blouses, black and coffee for everything else, and the light blue because I liked it.

431Reply

Sizing Questions From the Thread

How do I know which size to order?

Order the size you wear in a T-shirt: S, M, L, XL, 2XL or 3XL. If you're between two sizes, take the larger one. The order page also lists the bra sizes each tank size fits, up to 40DDD-G and 44C-DD.

My bra size has changed a lot. Does that matter?

No. There's no band number and no cup letter to match. The cups are shaped and sewn into the lining in every size, and the fabric stretches four ways, so the tank fits the shape you have now.

Will it hold a full bust without a cup size?

The shaped cups are sewn in all the way round, and the whole fitted tank carries the weight from the wide straps down. Members up to a 40DD and beyond wear it every day.

What if the size isn't right?

You have 45 days. If it isn't right, send it back under the guarantee.

Is it hard to get on with stiff shoulders?

It pulls on over the head the way a T-shirt does, and there is nothing to fasten afterwards.

See the Early Black Friday Offer →Buy 3 Get 2 Free while stock lasts

Comfortable After 60: Stories & Discussions is a community of women sharing what works for them. Round-ups like this one are compiled from members' answers; names and details are changed for privacy.