A Reader Wrote To Our Fitter's Desk About Crying In A Changing Room At 64. Here Is The Letter She Got Back.
Carolyn wrote in last autumn after she sat down on the bench in a department-store changing room with four bras in her lap and could not stop crying. We handed the letter to Jo Alder, who spent 29 years fitting women for bras in Boston and now writes our Fitter's Desk column. This is the reply she sent back, with five things she asked Carolyn to try tonight.
Every week the Fitter's Desk gets a handful of letters from women who used to feel fine in the bra section and no longer do. Jo answers each one by hand. This is the one she asked us to print.
Carolyn is 64, lives in a small town in Minnesota, and taught third grade for 33 years before she retired. She wrote in October, two days after the trip to the department store.
I am 64 years old and this afternoon I sat down on the little bench in a Macy's dressing room with four bras in my lap and I cried.
I have been wearing a bra since I was 13. For fifty-one years I have hooked one on in the morning and taken it off at night and never once thought about it. Today I tried four different sizes. One cut a red line under my arm that was still there in the parking lot. One rolled up the back the second I lifted my arms to look at the price tag. One had straps so thin I could feel them digging in through my shirt. One had wire that pressed on my ribs so hard I had to lean forward in the chair.
I was not crying because of the bras. I was crying because I used to walk into that shop and leave with the right one and today I did not know what the right one was anymore. My daughter is coming to visit in three weeks and I don't want to flinch when she hugs me.
I don't know what you can say to someone like me. Please tell me what you tell your own friends.
Dear Carolyn,
I want to start by saying that the thing that happened to you in that dressing room has happened to almost every woman who has written to me since I started this column, and to almost every woman who sat on the little bench on my side of the curtain for 29 years. You did not do anything wrong. The ribcage changes a little, the shoulders change a little, the tissue changes a lot, and the bras in that section were made for a woman you stopped being around 55.
The red line under your arm is a bra band pulled too tight across a chest wall that no longer has the padding to take it. The rolling up the back is a band so stiff and so narrow it had nowhere to sit. The thin straps are a design that assumes the shoulders carry the weight the same way they did at 32. The wire on the ribs is a wire that was never going to sit flat on your ribcage, no matter which size you picked.
Four bras, four problems, all four of them the hardware. None of them you.
Below is what I want you to try tonight, before you go anywhere near that store again. Five small things, in order. Each one names what was going wrong today.
The Band. Take It Off Tonight And Look At The Line.

Tonight, when you unhook, stand in front of the mirror and look at the line the band left on your ribs. If it is still pink an hour later, that bra was too tight. The band is doing almost all of the work in a modern bra, and the band is the first thing to go wrong on an older ribcage. The one in that store today had been pulled across the strip of tissue your arm swings against for twelve straight hours, and the strip is thinner than it used to be. That is the first bit of hardware I want you to retire.
The Straps. If They Groove The Shoulder, Stop Buying That Width.

I want you to find the thinnest strap in your drawer, hold it up against three of your fingers, and see how much of it is skinnier than that. That is the strap your shoulder has been carrying all day. On a 64-year-old shoulder the fat pad under the skin is thinner, so the strap meets bone sooner. A strap three fingers wide carries the same load with none of the groove. Any strap narrower than that, on anyone over 60, I ask them to retire.
The Hooks. Count How Many You Can No Longer Reach Behind You.

Carolyn, this one is almost never admitted out loud. Behind-the-back hooks are a joint test, not a bra test. Shoulder rotation, finger pinch, a bit of wrist. Most of my customers in their sixties quietly stopped using the back row of hooks years ago and were on the loosest setting the day they walked in. A bra you hook facing forward and twist around is a workaround, not a fix. A piece without any hook at all is what I started handing to the women who told me they had started dreading mornings.
The Loose Pad. If It Slid In The Wash, It Was Never Yours.

I know a lot of women your age quietly switched to a shelf-bra camisole and thought they had solved it. Jo's rule: turn it inside out at the sink. If there is a strip of elastic sewn under the bust, it is a bra wearing a sweetheart neckline. If the cup is a loose foam pad in a pocket, that pocket is there because the pad slides, which means it is not shaped to you. The whole garment is a looser bra. The thing you ran from is still inside the lining.
The Wire. If It Pressed On Your Ribs Today, Do Not Buy Another One.

The wire in a modern bra is a horseshoe of steel designed to sit flat under the breast fold on a 32-year-old ribcage, which lies on a slightly different plane than yours now does. On three in five of the women I fitted in their sixties, the wire sat on the ribs instead of under the breast. It hurt because it was never shaped to the ribs it was pressed against. If any wire you tried today pressed into your side when you sat down in the chair, that is the wire telling you it is on the wrong ribcage. The whole plane has changed. The hardware has not.
Stop Walking Into The Store Alone.
Carolyn, the four bras in your lap today were four pieces of hardware that were never going to fit the body you have now, in any size that store carried. The thing I want you to stop doing is going back there to try again. Not because you cannot find a bra — you can — but because the thing you are trying to solve is not a sizing problem, and the shop assistant is going to hand you another band pulled tight to make up for another cup that doesn't fit.
What I now ask every woman who writes in like this to try first, before any new bra at all, is the one soft tank piece I have been quietly handing out for the last two years. No band pulled tight. No thin strap. No hooks behind the back. No loose pad. No wire. Nothing to retire, because nothing in it is the thing that was going wrong.
Below — the three readers who wrote back after a week in it.What Three Readers Wrote Back After A Week
We asked three of the women Jo had sent the same reply to, earlier in the year, to send us a note after seven days in the piece she hands out.

"Jo's letter was the first time anyone told me the problem was the hardware, not me. Seven days in the tank and I have not thought about the band or the hooks once. I threw out four bras last Sunday."

"I read Carolyn's letter and cried in my own kitchen. I ordered the tank that night. One week in and I am not reaching for ibuprofen before dinner, and the shoulder grooves are gone."

"I had done the Macy's run twice this year. I did the five things Jo asked. The hard line is gone and I don't flinch when I take the tank off."
The Freeform Tank
- No band pulled tight across the ribs — the whole piece holds you
- No wire, no hooks, no thin strap — nothing hard, nothing fiddly
- Cups sewn into the lining all the way round — nothing slides in the wash
- Straps three fingers wide — six colours, sizes S to 5XL
What Readers Ask Jo First
Does this treat or cure anything?
No. The tank removes a tight elastic band, a thin strap, a row of hooks and an underwire from the hardware around your ribcage. It does not treat, cure or prevent any medical condition. If you have persistent swelling, tenderness or lumps, see a clinician — the tank is not a substitute for that visit.
Can it really hold up a larger bust?
The hold comes from shaped cups stitched into the lining and three-finger-wide straps, not from a tight elastic band. Jo says her readers in the C and D cup range do very well in it. For an F or G cup, order the five-pack and test for a full day; if the straps drag at all, the 45-day guarantee has you covered.
What size do I pick?
Order by your usual bra size using the chart on the order page, S to 5XL. If you are between two sizes, take the larger one. The piece is cut to lie flat, not squeeze.
Will the cups wash out of it?
No. They are sewn into the lining all the way round, not slipped into a pocket, so they stay put and hold their shape through the wash. Warm wash, tumble low.
Letters column by Jo Alder for the Women's Health Insider Fitter's Desk. Carolyn's name has been changed at her request; the letter is published with her written permission. This is an opinion column informed by one fitter's thirty years of observations and is not medical advice; individual experiences vary.