Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsCommunity discussions · 38,600 members
Discussions›Frozen Shoulder›Member survey
Member survey: 1,400 replies

Members With Frozen Shoulder Said The Bra Hook Was The Last Thing They Could Still Fasten. Then One Morning It Wasn't.

1,400 replies 9.4K found this helpfulPosted November 21
Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsModeratorGroup admin team · 38,600 members

Three weeks ago we posted one question in the group for anyone who has had adhesive capsulitis -- frozen shoulder -- in either arm: what was the LAST dressing task you could still do alone before the shoulder shut down completely?

We got 1,400 answers. 7 in 10 of you named the same one: the back bra hook. It stayed workable right up until the morning it didn't.

The pattern surprised the moderators. The back hook is usually the first task to go in any shoulder problem. In frozen shoulder it was the LAST. So we asked 341 of you to write back and tell us about the morning it stopped working, what you'd tried, and what you're wearing now. This is what came back.

Older woman with frozen shoulder reaching behind her back, arm stopped halfway up at the bra line
Pam, 69, sent us this one. "I was halfway up to the hooks and the arm wouldn't come any higher. I'd been getting dressed on my own for twenty-eight years of mornings. That one I couldn't."
What follows is not medical advice. It is a round-up of what members in this group have written about their own experience of frozen shoulder (adhesive capsulitis), with placeholder names and figures. Frozen shoulder is a medical condition -- please talk to your doctor or physical therapist about your own case.
The survey · 1,400 members with frozen-shoulder history
Said the back bra hook was the LAST task to go7 in 10
Named a specific morning the arm stopped reaching82%
Had tried PT already before the hook went61%
Had tried a front-closure bra and given up58%
Switched to something with no closure at all48%
Helpful 2.4K Me too 1,118 Reply
From the follow-up · 341 members

How dressing tasks disappear across 6-18 months of frozen shoulder, in order.

Month 0All tasks workable · the ache has started, mostly at night Month 3Overhead reach starts to go · top shelves, hair wash Month 6Can't pull a jumper off clean · cardigans only Month 9Washing own back goes · long-handled brush comes out Month 12Zips at the back go · dresses live at the back of the closet Month 15Back bra hook is the LAST thing still working Month 15+The morning the hook also goes. No warning.
Still workable Workaround needed Gone
1,400 member repliesSorted by: Most helpful
Most helpful answer · 341 wrote back
Marcie Hollerbach
Marcie Hollerbach72 · adhesive capsulitis, right shoulder, year 2 · retired PT, Topeka KS

I was a physical therapist for 34 years and I treated frozen shoulder in women over 60 almost every week of that career. Then at 70 I got it myself. I have been on both sides of this door.

Here is why the back hook is the last thing to go, and not the first. Frozen shoulder doesn't take your fingers -- that stays as good as it ever was. It takes the SHOULDER's internal rotation: the angle that lets you reach up the middle of your back. The back-hook position needs less of that than most people think, because the hands meet quite low, between the shoulder blades. For months you can still get there if you do it slowly.

Then internal rotation drops below about 30 degrees. Below that threshold the arm will not come up behind the back at all. There is no warning. One morning you reach and the arm stops at the small of your back. That is the morning 7 in 10 of us wrote the group about.

Illustration showing internal rotation of the shoulder with a shaded cone showing how low the arm can reach behind the back as frozen shoulder progresses
Why the morning it goes is not predictableInternal rotation isn't lost smoothly. It drops in steps as the capsule tightens, and the step that drops you below the hook-line can happen overnight. By the time you can't hook the bra, you also can't reach forward to tie an apron. The hook test is actually the only everyday test that catches it.
Helpful 4.6K Me too 1,018 51 replies
Pam Odegaard
Pam OdegaardPosted the photo

Marcie, this is exactly what the morning felt like. One day the hooks, the next day I could not reach them at all. There was no warning Tuesday that Wednesday would be the one.

372Reply
Marcie Hollerbach
Marcie Hollerbach

Pam, it is the capsule, not you. You did not do anything wrong on Wednesday morning. Keep reading to the bottom and I will say what I ended up wearing.

594Reply
Shirley Boutwell
Shirley Boutwell66 · frozen shoulder, left, 11 months in · Montgomery, AL

I want to say what nobody said to me in the group when I first joined, which is the front-closure bra is not the fix we hoped for. 58% of our survey said they tried one. I bought two.

The clasp sits in the middle of my chest and I thought at least I could see it. What I did not know is that closing a front clasp needs you to bring both ELBOWS forward and then press them together across your front. My left elbow doesn't come forward anymore. It swings about halfway and stops where the capsule has gone tight. I ended up pinching one side closed with my right hand only, and the whole thing lifted off my ribs at the bottom. I asked my husband twice before breakfast.

A beige front-closure bra laid flat with the small plastic clasp highlighted in the centre
Why moving the clasp doesn't help with frozen shoulderA back hook needs internal rotation. A front clasp needs elbow adduction -- the opposite movement. Frozen shoulder shuts both of them down. There is no closure position on a torso that frozen shoulder leaves fully workable, which is the thing nobody tells you at diagnosis.
Helpful 1.9K Me too 712 22 replies
Eileen Costa
Eileen Costa64 · Pawtucket, RI

Shirley, same here. Three in the drawer, all unused. I thought my shoulder was being dramatic.

274Reply
Pam Odegaard
Pam OdegaardPosted the photo69 · frozen shoulder, right, year one · Cleveland, OH

The morning that photo at the top was taken, I had my dress for a wake laid out on the bed. The hook was the only thing left on the dressing routine that I was still doing myself. I had been managing it slowly for a few months.

I lifted my arms, right one started well, got to about shoulder-blade height, and then just stopped. Not pain exactly. Just a wall. I pushed and it would not go. I started again, slowly. Nothing. I sat down on the end of the bed in a half-done dress and I cried, because I knew what it meant. The last thing I was still doing by myself at the beginning of a morning was now not something I could do.

A member in this group messaged me that afternoon and told me what she wears now. I had it in my cart by evening.

A woman sitting on the edge of a bed in a half-dressed state, head in hands, soft morning light through curtains
Helpful 1.7K Me too 1,064 36 replies
Shirley Boutwell
Shirley Boutwell

Pam, I sat on the end of the bed the same way. There is no language in medicine for that morning.

468Reply
See the no-closure tank 48% of our members switched to → check the early Black Friday offer
Eileen Costa
Eileen Costa64 · frozen shoulder, right, 14 months in · Pawtucket, RI

I slept in my bra for about four months. I was not going to type that out but I need to say it, because the comments on the moderator's post told me a lot of us did.

Taking a bra off at bedtime with a frozen shoulder is worse than putting it on in the morning. In the morning the capsule is cold and tight but you have some adrenaline. At night the ache is already there, your arm doesn't want to lift at all, and the thought of twisting and digging for a hook behind you with a shoulder that is burning is more than I had in me. So I kept it on. I knew my skin wasn't thanking me. I slept worse. I didn't want to wake my husband every night.

Why the fastener is the whole problem at bedtimeIf taking a bra off at night with a frozen shoulder is painful enough that you'd rather sleep in it, the problem isn't you. It's that there's a band and a hook at a position your arm can no longer reach. Take both out of the equation and there is nothing left to unfasten before bed.
Helpful 1.4K Me too 882 24 replies
Marcie Hollerbach
Marcie Hollerbach

Eileen, I slept in mine for six weeks before I admitted it to anyone. You are not alone and your skin can recover.

322Reply
Doris Linville
Doris Linville70 · bilateral frozen shoulder (one then the other) · Louisville, KY

I am the member Marcie's post is going to interest the most, because I have had it on both sides. Left shoulder from 66 to 68. Right shoulder started last winter.

I will tell you what I wish I had been told at the start. The back hook holds up longer than any other dressing task, and then it leaves overnight. You will think it is one of your better days and you'll go to fasten and nothing above the small of your back will cooperate. Please do not keep trying for an hour. The capsule does not care how patient you are. Buy the thing that does not have hooks, and keep it on your side of the drawer so you do not even open the one with hooks on a bad morning.

Helpful 1.6K Me too 925 19 replies
What 48% switched to
Marcie Hollerbach
Marcie Hollerbach72 · retired PT, Topeka KS

Here is what I wear now, and what nearly half of the 341 who wrote back are wearing.

It is a tank top with the bra built into it. There is no closure of any kind. No back hook, no front clasp, no little plastic latch. The cups are shaped and stitched into the lining so there is nothing loose to arrange. The straps are about as wide as three fingers. It pulls on over your head with your elbows LOW by your sides -- which is the whole point for a frozen shoulder, because the elbows never have to leave the side of the ribs. You take it off at night the same way: cross your arms, lift the hem up and over.

No reach behind the back. No elbows forward. No pinch grip at a position your shoulder can't find. Here is me yesterday morning in the light blue one.

Marcie in her kitchen wearing the light blue built-in-bra tank, holding a coffee mug
Helpful 3.1K Me too 1,124 44 replies
Pam Odegaard
Pam OdegaardPosted the photo

Marcie, this is the one I ordered. Will post an update at the bottom when it arrives.

262Reply
Doris Linville
Doris Linville

I have one in nearly every colour by now. It's the Freeform Tank. Just so the newer members know what we mean.

488Reply
Pinned by the moderators
Arthritis Stories & Discussions
Arthritis Stories & DiscussionsModeratorGroup team

What 341 Members Wrote Back About The Morning The Hook Stopped Working, In One Place

The survey had 1,400 answers. The follow-up had 341 members who wrote back with the morning it happened, the fixes they tried, and what they wear now. Here is every workaround members told us didn't fix the problem, and what they said does.

What members told us didn't workWhat members said works
Back hooks you can't reach once the capsule tightensNo hooks or clasp anywhere
Hooking in front and twisting it round the ribsNothing to twist, it pulls straight on
A front-closure bra that needs the elbows forwardElbows stay LOW by the sides the whole time
A sports bra pulled over the head one arm at a timeWide square neck opening, both elbows stay low
Foam pads to arrange with a stiff shoulderCups sewn into the lining all the way round
Sleeping in it to avoid unhooking at nightComes off with crossed arms, hem up

Almost every reply in the thread named the same top: the Freeform Tank. 48% of the follow-up members switched to it. Several of you have asked where to get it, so here's where members have been ordering.

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

11,482 reviews
Most members pick this5 Tanks · Buy 3 Get 2 Free$24.00 a tank
$400.00$120.00
3 Tanks · Buy 2 Get 1 Free$26.66 a tank
$240.00$80.00
1 TankTry one first
$80.00$40.00
  • No hooks, no clasp, no band — nothing to reach for behind your back on a frozen-shoulder morning
  • Wide stretch square neckline — pulls on with both elbows LOW by your sides
  • Cups sewn into the lining — nothing to stuff back in while your arm won't lift
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — six colours, S to 5XL, free US shipping
Check Availability →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Wear it for a few mornings. If your shoulder can't manage it, you have 45 days to send it back for your money.
  • Sizing, from members: go by your usual bra size on the chart on the order page. Between two sizes, take the larger -- it gives the elbows more room.
  • Colour, from members: most started with nude or black, then came back for the light blue and burgundy once they knew the fit.

Questions members asked in the thread

What exactly is frozen shoulder, and why does the back hook go overnight?

Frozen shoulder (adhesive capsulitis) is when the capsule around the shoulder joint quietly tightens over 6-18 months. The movement that goes first is internal rotation -- the angle that lets your arm travel up your own back. Below about 30 degrees of internal rotation the arm will not reach behind the shoulder blades at all, and the drop under that threshold often happens in one step. That is the morning members write us about.

I'm in month four. Should I just wait it out?

Please speak to your doctor or physical therapist about the medical side -- this group is not a substitute for that. 61% of our members had already started PT by the time the hook went, and most are glad they did. What we can say is that having a top you can actually get on and off without reaching behind yourself takes one daily argument off the table while the shoulder is where it is.

Will it work on both frozen shoulders at once?

Doris, 70, Louisville, has had it on both sides. She wore the Freeform Tank through the second shoulder from month three onward. The movement to get it on and off is elbows LOW to the sides -- which both shoulders can still do when neither can rotate internally.

What if my shoulder is still thawing and I can lift a little again?

The members who are in the "thawing" phase of frozen shoulder told us they kept wearing the tank even after some overhead range came back, because they didn't want to go back to a morning that depended on finding a hook they couldn't see. The guarantee is 45 days -- enough time to see how it fits your morning.

Newest reply
Update from Pam
Pam Odegaard
Pam OdegaardPosted the phototwo weeks later

Update, like I said I would. It arrived on a Monday. I stood in front of my dresser with both elbows by my sides, pulled it on straight over my head, and I was dressed. No hands behind my back, no stopping halfway, no wall. I took it off that night by crossing my arms and lifting the hem. That was the first evening in a long time I didn't have to decide between asking my husband and sleeping in it.

I made it to a wake last week in a dark cardigan over it. I ordered three more -- two black and one burgundy. The right shoulder is still frozen. The morning routine has one fewer thing in it that can go wrong. Thank you to everyone in this thread.

Helpful 3.2K Me too 1,318 86 replies
Marcie Hollerbach
Marcie Hollerbach

Pam. This made my whole week. Keep us posted on the right side.

702Reply
See The Tank Members Switched To →Early Black Friday: Buy 3 Get 2 Free while stock lasts