Comfortable After 60Member Survey · November 2026
Members' Round-Up · The Grandchild Hug

We Asked Our Members Whether Their Bra Had Ever Hurt During A Grandchild's Hug. 1,100 Wrote Back The Same Day.

One question in the group on a Tuesday morning. 1,100 members over 60 wrote back inside twenty-four hours. 7 in 10 said yes, it had hurt. This is what they told us, and the one swap most of them made afterwards.

Comfortable After 60 admin byline
Compiled by the CA60 adminsRound-up of our members' thread · 1,100 responses in 24 hours · November 21, 2026
A grandmother hugging her grandchild on the front porch
Mary (68, Ohio) and her youngest granddaughter on the front step the morning after our members' thread hit a thousand replies.

On a Tuesday morning we posted one question in the group: "Has your bra ever hurt during a hug from a grandchild?" By bedtime we had 1,100 replies. 7 in 10 said yes, it had. Several members said they had never put the sentence together before, but once it was in front of them they knew exactly which hug they meant.

The one that comes up most is the running hug. A grandchild sprints across a lawn or a kitchen floor, hits a grandmother at full speed, and lands with both arms wrapped tight around her ribcage. The band of the bra sits on exactly the line of ribs that gets squeezed. For a long second it stings. Most of our members have been bracing for that second for years and never told anyone.

A note from the admins. This is a community round-up, not medical or fitting advice. Member names and ages are posted exactly as they wrote them in the thread. The percentages below are tallied from the 1,100 responses we received in a single day; this is our community's own count, not a formal study.
Our members' survey · n = 1,100 in 24 hours
7 in 10

of our members over 60 said their bra had hurt during a hug from a grandchild. Most said the running hug was the one that stung the most.

Self-reported, members of the Comfortable After 60 private group. Our community's own tally over one day. Not a controlled study.

Who wrote in · yes, the hug has hurt (by age bracket)

1,100 members over 60 answered inside twenty-four hours. We split the replies by the age bracket members ticked on their profile.

60-64
58%
65-69
69%
70-74
76%
75-79
78%
80+
81%

Members' survey tally, 1,100 responses in a single day. Yes-share rises with age. Members over 75 told us the ribs feel thinner than they did at 60 and the hug lands harder.

Part one · What members told us about the hugThree stories members wrote in the first hour of the thread.

1

The Running Hug That Stung Mid-Afternoon

Member 1 · the one that started the thread
A grandchild running across a kitchen to a grandmother

Mary, 68, from Ohio, wrote the post that started the thread. Her youngest granddaughter, four, had sprinted across the kitchen floor and launched into a running hug the Saturday before, both arms tight around Mary's ribcage. Mary said she had flinched for a long second before she hugged back, and had spent the rest of the afternoon wondering why.

"She hit me at full speed and the band dug straight into the exact line of ribs it has been digging into since the eighties. I kept smiling. Nobody saw. Then I asked the group whether anyone else had done the same."Mary, 68, Ohio
Why it stingsThe running hug lands two small arms right across the band of the bra. The band is already pressed into the ribs; a tight squeeze pushes it in another half-inch and holds it there for the duration of the hug.
2

The Storybook Hug That Lasted A Chapter

Member 2 · the one that lasted
A grandmother reading a book with a grandchild curled against her side

Elaine, 72, from Florida, wrote in about reading The Velveteen Rabbit on the couch with her six-year-old grandson. He had curled against her side with his cheek on her ribcage and did not move for a full chapter. Elaine said that by page eight the band had drawn a thinner line into her skin than she had seen in a year, because he was not squeezing hard — just leaning, for twenty minutes, with the full weight of a small shoulder pressed on the elastic.

"It did not sting. It just slowly got worse. Twenty minutes of a six-year-old's shoulder on one strip of elastic is a lot. I did not shift him because he was happy. I unhooked the bra in the bathroom the moment he went for a snack."Elaine, 72, Florida
Why it marksWeight is the problem more than speed. A sustained lean puts the mass of a small child onto one line of elastic and keeps it there for the whole chapter. The band does what a band does: it marks.
3

The Goodbye Hug At The Front Door

Member 3 · the one at the door
A grandchild hugging a grandmother at a front door

Jo, 65, from Idaho, wrote about the hug that happens on the way out. Her three grandchildren came for Sunday lunch most weekends. The hug at the door at the end was always the tightest; the youngest especially, five years old, who held on with both arms around Jo's middle for a full count of ten before his mother called him to the car. Jo said she had learned to turn her ribcage slightly to the side so the band did not catch straight on.

"I was turning my body away from a five-year-old's hug for two years before I understood I was doing it. When I read Mary's post I cried a little. I thought it was my ribs. It was never my ribs. It was the band."Jo, 65, Idaho
Why it adds upA tight hug a few times a week for forty-five weeks a year is more than a hundred and fifty hugs. The band crosses the same strip of rib each time. Members said the strip of skin under the band is where the colour and the groove sit by Sunday evening.

Part two · What is actually happeningWhy a tight band on the ribs plus a tight hug equals a sting.

4

The Band Sits On A Rib That Is Already Compressed

The mechanism, in plain language
Anatomy illustration of a bra band compressing the ribs during a hug

The bra band is a strip of elastic a little over an inch wide that runs around the ribcage, usually just under the bust. It is tight by design — the hold of the bra depends on it. When a small child wraps both arms around a grandmother's middle, the arms land across that strip of elastic, press it another half-inch into the skin, and hold it there until the hug ends. The rib, the skin, the elastic and the small arms are all pressing on the same line.

What members feltA long second of sting on the running hug. A slow red line on the storybook hug. A groove in the skin that is still there by bedtime on a long day. Most members said they had never named it until the thread.

None of this is dramatic. There is no injury here. There is a persistent small pain in the exact place a grandmother wants a hug to feel good, and after forty-five years of ignoring it most of our members have decided they no longer have to.

See the tank most members switched to → check the early Black Friday offer

Part three · What members didThe swap most members made, in one sentence.

5

A Tank With The Bra Built Into It, No Band Across The Ribs

The one answer most of the thread circled back to
A woman over 60 in a built-in-bra tank in her kitchen

The answer that came up more often than any other in the hug thread was a soft tank with the cups stitched into the lining and the holding spread across the whole garment instead of pinned on one tight line across the ribs. No band. No hooks. No wire. Members told us the first time a grandchild hugged them in the tank the hug just felt like a hug.

"The first hug after I switched, I kept waiting for the sting. It did not come. My granddaughter hugged me the exact same way she always does and I noticed the difference inside the first second."Mary, 68, Ohio
Why it holds without a bandThe hold is spread up and down the torso by shaped cups stitched into the lining all the way round and straps three fingers wide. Nothing concentrated on one strip under the bust. Members ordered by their T-shirt size.

Three members wrote back after a week of grandchild hugs in the tank

We asked a few of the members who had switched to the built-in-bra tank to tell the thread what the first week of grandchild hugs felt like. Three replied the same evening.

Mary, 68, Ohio
Mary, 68, Ohio CA60 member since 2020

"First Saturday in the tank. My granddaughter did the running hug and I did not flinch. She noticed before I did. She said grandma you did not do your face. I did not know I had a face."

Elaine, 72, Florida
Elaine, 72, Florida CA60 member since 2019

"Three bedtime stories on the couch with my grandson and no red line under my bust at all. I checked in the bathroom mirror because I did not believe it the first time."

Jo, 65, Idaho
Jo, 65, Idaho CA60 member since 2021

"The goodbye hug at the door is a goodbye hug now, not a brace. My youngest grandson hugged me for a count of ten on Sunday and I did not turn my body away."

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

11,482 reviews
As low as $20 a tank today
  • No band across the ribs — the whole tank holds you, so a hug lands on fabric, not elastic
  • No wire, no hooks, no hidden elastic — nothing hard on the lower ribs when a grandchild squeezes
  • Cups sewn into the lining all the way round — they can't fold or shift in the wash
  • Straps three fingers wide — six colours, sizes S to 5XL
Check Availability →Free US shipping · 45-day fit guarantee
Wear it through one weekend of grandchild hugs. If the band problem shows up again, send it back within 45 days for your money back.

What members asked in the thread

Does this treat or fix any medical issue?

No. The tank is a soft everyday garment, not a treatment, cure or preventive. It removes the elastic band from the ribs so a tight hug lands on fabric, not on a strip of elastic. If you have persistent swelling, chest pain or any sudden change, see a clinician — a tank is not a substitute for that.

Will it hold a larger bust during a hug?

The hold comes from shaped cups stitched into the lining and three-finger-wide straps, not a tight elastic band. Members in the C and D cup range reported good hug-day results in the thread. For an F or G cup, we suggest the five-pack and a full-day test; the 45-day guarantee covers the trial.

How do I pick a size?

Order by your T-shirt size using the chart on the order page, S to 5XL. If you are between sizes, go up one. The tank is cut to lie flat, not squeeze.

Will the cups wash out of it?

No. They are sewn into the lining all the way round, not slipped into a pocket, so they hold their shape through the wash. Warm wash, tumble low, and they come out of the dryer looking like they went in.

See the Early Black Friday Offer →Buy 3 Get 2 Free while stock lasts

Compiled by the Comfortable After 60 admins from members' own replies to our hug thread. Member names and ages are as members wrote them. The round-up is a community document and is not medical, fitting or financial advice; individual experiences vary.