We Read 2,140 Five-Star Reviews Women Over 60 Left On One Bra Tank. The Same 6 Things Came Up.
Fourteen of us split the pile, read every one with a highlighter and kept a pencil tally of what women our age actually wrote about a tank with the bra built in. Here are the six things, in order of how often they were said.
Every week somebody in this group asks the same question: is a tank with the bra built in actually any good for a woman our age, or is it one more thing that looks fine on a thirty-year-old in a photograph?
We got tired of answering with opinions. So in September we did something a bit mad. We took the one bra tank members mention most, pulled every five-star review left on it by a woman who gave her age as 60 or over, printed the lot and read them. All of them. There were 2,140.
We were not looking for whether women liked it. Five stars already tells you that. We wanted to know what they said when nobody had asked them a question, because the thing a woman bothers to type out at 70 is the thing that mattered.
2,140 of 2,318 gave it five stars.
The tallySix things women over 60 said about a bra tank, counted
Times mentioned in 2,140 five-star reviews
A review can count toward more than one row.None of us guessed the first one. We all assumed the top answer would be comfort, or the band, or simply that it was soft. It was the washing machine.
The Bra Cups Stay Put In The Wash

More than six in every ten reviews said some version of the same sentence: the cups came out of the wash where they went in. Women wrote it with real feeling, and after reading a few hundred we understood why. Every one of them had spent years fishing a folded foam pad out of a wire-free bra or a shelf cami, flattening it on the counter and poking it back through a slit.

“Forty-one washes, I have been counting. In with the towels, tumble low. I have not put my hand inside it once to straighten a cup. There is nothing in there to straighten.”
There Is No Bra Band Round The Ribs

The second thing was not what the tank has. It was what is missing. Over a thousand women wrote that there is no band: nothing round the ribs, nothing under the bust, nothing to ride up or roll. A lot of them only noticed at bedtime, when there was nothing to take off with relief.

“I kept waiting for the part where it squeezes. There is no part where it squeezes. I wore it to my granddaughter's recital, four hours in a folding chair, and never once thought about my ribs.”
The Straps Stay On The Shoulder

Four in ten mentioned the straps, and nearly always with a number. “As wide as three fingers” turned up so often that we started a separate column for it. Women with sloping shoulders wrote the longest reviews of anybody.

“My shoulders slope, they always have. I have pushed a strap back up under my blouse every ten minutes for forty years. These are wide and flat and they have not moved. I did not know that was allowed.”
There Are No Bra Hooks To Fasten

One in three reviews mentioned that the tank pulls on over the head. No hooks, no clasp, nothing behind the back. The oldest reviewers said it most. For a good number of them it was the whole review.

“I am eighty. I had started hooking my bra at the front and turning it round, and some mornings I asked my daughter. Now I pull this over my head the way I would an undershirt and I am dressed before the coffee is made.”
The Bra Tank Passes As A Proper Top

This was the one that made us smile. Hundreds of women wrote that they wear it as the top itself: under an open cardigan to church, on its own in the garden, under a blouse in place of a camisole. The neckline is square and straight across, so it looks finished, not like underwear showing.

“I bought it as underwear and it turned into half my wardrobe. Burgundy one with the cream cardigan for church, white one under my linen shirt. One layer where I used to wear a bra, a camisole and a top.”
The Bra Tank Holds A Fuller Bust

The sixth thing came only from larger-busted women, and it was the one they said they had least expected to be writing. 489 reviewers gave a cup size of DD or above, and said it holds. Several began their review with the word “honestly”.

“Honestly I ordered it to prove my sister wrong. I am a 40DD and every soft thing I have ever tried left me at my waist by noon. This holds me where I am supposed to be, all day, and I can still breathe.”
What else the pile told usThree more counts we did not plan to make
reviews used the words “forgot I was wearing it”, or near enough.
It was the single most repeated phrase in the whole pile. Marlene started circling it in red in week one because it kept turning up in reviews that otherwise had nothing in common.
reviewers named what they had tried before the bra tank.
Wire-free “comfort” bras came first by a distance, then sports bras, then shelf camis, then bralettes. The complaint about each was nearly word for word: a pad that folded, a band that rolled, or both. Nearly half the women who wrote a five-star review had already paid for a soft bra that let them down.
said, in the review itself, that they had already ordered the bra tank a second time.
That is 724 women out of 2,140. We had not set out to count it. Sandra noticed in the first week that reviews kept ending the same way and added a column. The usual reason was more colors. The second most common was a sister.
“At 71 I gave away every bra I owned after one bra tank. Fourteen of them, in a grocery bag, to the church sale. Then I ordered five more tanks and two for my sister in Dayton.”
Dorothy H., 71, Ohio · the review all fourteen of us read aloud
The one we read aboutWhich bra tank it was
So many of you asked while we were counting that we will say it once. Every one of the 2,140 reviews was for the Freeform Tank. It is made by a small company and sold only through its own order page, not in stores, which is why you will not have seen it on a rack.
We are a discussion group, not a shop. Nobody here is telling you what to wear. We read what 2,140 women our age wrote when nobody was asking, counted it, and this is the count.
The Freeform Tank
- Cups sewn into the lining — nothing to fold or fish out of the wash
- No band round the ribs — no wire, no elastic under the bust
- Straps as wide as three fingers — flat, and they stay put
- Pulls on over the head — no hooks; six colors, sizes S to 5XL
Three Of The Members Who Did The Counting
We asked the volunteers what they did when the last sheet was tallied.

“I read about 160 of them at my own kitchen table and by the second evening I had stopped reading and started nodding. I ordered three before we had finished the pile. The cups have been through the wash nine times now and I have nothing to report, which is the point.”

“I was the skeptic. I circled forgot I was wearing it in red every time because I did not believe it. Then mine came, and at nine that night I went to take my bra off and there was no bra. I have had to apologize to the group.”

“I added the column for women who had ordered again because I kept seeing it. Then I became one of them. First order was two. The second was four, and one of those went to my mother, who is 84 and has not asked me to do up a hook since.”
What Members Asked After The Tally Went Up
What size do I order in a bra tank?
Your top size, not your bra size. The chart on the order page runs S to 5XL and shows which bra sizes each one covers. Reviewers who sat between two sizes most often said they took the larger.
Do the bra cups really survive the washing machine?
That was the most repeated thing in the whole pile: 1,312 reviews. The cups are stitched into the lining, not slipped into a pocket, so there is nothing loose to fold. Most reviewers wash warm with the towels and tumble low.
Will a bra tank hold me up at a DD or bigger?
489 of the five-star reviews came from women who gave a cup size of DD or above and said it holds them all day. The cups are shaped and the body is fitted, so the whole tank carries the weight.
Does it show under clothes like a bra does?
There are no hooks, sliders or lace to print through a knit. The neckline is square and straight across, so under a blouse it looks like a camisole, and 612 reviewers said they wear it as the top itself.
What if the bra tank is not right for me?
The company gives 45 days to send it back. Shipping in the US is free.
Compiled by members of Comfortable After 60. Reviewers' names are shortened for privacy. This is a members' tally of what other women wrote. It is not medical advice.