Comfortable After 60Stories & Discussions · 48.2K members
A Member's Test

I Wear A Size 22. I Ordered 6 Built-In-Bra Tanks Sold To Women Over 60 To Prove None Would Fit. One Did.

Diane is 67 and one of our members. She was sure that “fits every body” never means hers, so she bought six bra tanks, put each one through the same five checks and wrote down what happened. Five failed. This is her report, in her own words.

Diane K., group member
By Diane K., 67, Missouri · memberPosted to the group by Pam Reinholt, admin · November 21, 2026
Diane, 67, a dress size 22, wearing a burgundy built-in-bra tank that fits her, beside a bed with five discarded bra tanks
Diane in her bedroom in Missouri, wearing number six. The other five are on the bed, where they stayed.
Pam Reinholt, group admin
Pam Reinholt · Admin

Whenever a bra tank comes up in this group, the same reply arrives within the hour: “Lovely, but not in my size.” When I asked who here wears an 18 or above, 1,460 of you answered in two days. One of you, Diane, went further than answering. She spent her own money to settle it. I asked her to write it up exactly as it happened.

I am a size 22 in a dress and a 44D in a bra. I have been one or the other, near enough, since my forties, and for all of that time I have bought my bras from the same two pages at the back of the same catalog. Beige or white. Four hooks. A band as wide as a belt.

So when the built-in-bra tanks started turning up in this group, with women my age saying they had thrown their bras out, I did what I always do. I read the post, I looked at the photograph of a woman who wears a 10, and I kept scrolling. “Fits every body” is a sentence I have been let down by more times than I can count.

In September I got annoyed enough to prove it. I ordered six bra tanks that are advertised to women over 60, each in the biggest size it comes in or the size its own chart told a 22 to buy. My plan was to photograph six failures and post them here, so the rest of us could stop wondering.

I got five failures. The sixth one I am wearing as I type this.

The five checks every bra tank got
  1. Does it go on? Over my head and down, by myself, without a struggle.
  2. Do the cups cover me? All of each breast inside a cup, nothing spilling over the top or out at the side.
  3. Do the straps lie flat? On the shoulder, not cutting a groove in it.
  4. Does it stay down when I sit? One hour in my kitchen chair. Hem still at my hip, nothing rolled up under the bust.
  5. Does it survive the wash? One warm wash, tumble low, and the cups come out where they went in.

The report cardSix bra tanks, one size 22, five checks each

How each bra tank did on a size 22

Checks passed out of five. Worn and washed by Diane at home.
0/5
1. One-size seamless bra camiSold as fitting sizes 4 to 24
Did not go on
2/5
2. Racerback comfort bra tankBiggest size sold: 3X
Cups too small
1/5
3. Shelf-bra camisoleBiggest size sold: 2X
Band rolled up
1/5
4. Lace bra cami sized by cup lettersChart ended at 42DD
No size for her
3/5
5. Scoop bra tank, removable padsBiggest size sold: 3X
Pads folded
5/5
6. Bra tank sized by T-shirt sizeOrdered in a 3XL
It fit

I will take them in the order they arrived, because the way each one failed turned out to be the useful part. By the fifth I could see they were all failing for the same reason.

1

The “One Size” Seamless Bra Cami

0 of 5 checks · did not go on
Diane holding a small white seamless camisole against her front; it is about half her width
Number one, held up against me. The listing said it stretches to fit sizes 4 to 24. My husband took this and then had to leave the room.

The listing promised it would stretch to fit a size 24. It arrived the size of a dish towel. I got it over my head and as far as the widest part of my bust, and that is where it stopped. A tube of stretchy fabric has no cups in it at all, so the more of you there is, the flatter and tighter it pulls. I cut it off with the kitchen scissors.

2

The Racerback “Comfort” Bra Tank, In A 3X

2 of 5 checks · cups too small

This one went on, and the straps were fine. Then I looked down. The body was a 3X. The cups were the same cups they put in the small. They sat on top of me like two saucers, with most of each breast underneath and outside them. When I sat down, everything the cups were not holding went where gravity sent it.

What I learned from itA lot of makers size up by cutting the body wider and changing nothing else. The label says 3X. The bra inside it is still built for a 36B.
3

The Shelf-Bra Camisole, In A 2X

1 of 5 checks · band rolled up

The biggest size it comes in is a 2X, which told me what the maker thinks of women over a 20. The “bra” is a strip of elastic sewn under the bust with a flat layer of fabric above it. On me that elastic lasted eleven minutes in the kitchen chair before it rolled itself into a cord and climbed. I spent the rest of the hour with a rope under my bust and nothing holding me at all.

Five different built-in-bra tanks and camisoles laid on a bed with opened mailer bags
The five that failed, on my bed, the afternoon I packed them up. Look at the loose pads on the navy one. I will come to those.
In a hurry? See the bra tank that fit a size 22
4

The Lace Bra Cami Sized By Cup Letters

1 of 5 checks · chart ended at 42DD

This one is sold by bra size, band and cup, like a bra. The chart stopped at a 42DD. I am a 44D. There was no row for me, so I ordered the last row and hoped. It went on. The cups gaped at the top and cut in at the side, and the thin straps with their little metal sliders had dug a groove in each shoulder inside twenty minutes.

What I learned from itA bra tank sold by band and cup has the same problem as a bra. There are dozens of combinations, the maker only produces the common ones, and the chart simply ends before it reaches the larger sizes.
5

The Scoop-Neck Bra Tank With Removable Pads, In A 3X

3 of 5 checks · pads folded in the wash

The nearest miss. The body fit me and it stayed down when I sat. But the “bra” was two loose foam pads in a pocket, each about the size of a coaster, and the scoop neck fell open every time I leaned over the sink. After one wash both pads had folded in half and migrated to the same side. A loose pad in a pocket is not a cup, and it is certainly not a cup for a 44D.

By now I had my photographs and my post half written. Five bra tanks, all advertised to women my age, and on a size 22 every one had failed the same way: the maker had made the outside bigger and left the bra part alone.

The sixth parcel had been sitting on the hall table for four days. I very nearly did not open it.

6

The Bra Tank Sized By T-Shirt Size, In A 3XL

5 of 5 checks · it fit
The inside back neck of a burgundy built-in-bra tank with a size tab that reads 3XL
The tab in the back of number six. Its chart did not ask for a band or a cup letter. It asked what size top I wear.

The chart for this one had no cup letters on it anywhere. It asked one question: what size top do you wear? A 22 is a 3XL. That was the whole fitting.

It went over my head and down in one go. I stood in the hall with my arms out waiting for the catch. Then I went through my own checks, a bit put out, because I could feel my post falling apart.

  • It went on. Over the head, no hooks, no help, no scissors.
  • The cups covered me. All of me, each side, in a proper shaped cup.
  • The straps lay flat. They are as wide as three of my fingers. No groove.
  • It stayed down. One hour in the kitchen chair, then three more because I forgot I was testing it. There is no band under the bust, so there was nothing to roll.
  • It survived the wash. In with the towels. The cups came out exactly where they went in.
Diane sitting at her kitchen table in the burgundy built-in-bra tank under an open grey cardigan
Hour four of the one-hour sitting test. I had stopped checking.

Why the sixth one fitThe bra cups are sewn in, and the 3XL gets its own

A large-size built-in-bra tank turned inside out, two large shaped cups stitched into the lining, a woman's hand resting on one cup
My second one, turned inside out on the bed. That is my hand on one cup, for scale. Each cup is stitched to the lining the whole way round.

I turned it inside out to find out what was different, and it took about five seconds. The cups in the 3XL are 3XL cups. They are wide and deep, cut for a full bust, and they are sewn into the lining around the whole edge. Nothing is dropped into a pocket and nothing is borrowed from the small.

The second thing is what is missing. There is no elastic band under the bust. A band is a fixed ring that has to match your ribs to the inch, which is why bras come in dozens of sizes and why so few of them are made for us. Take the band away and the whole fitted body of the tank carries the weight from the shoulders down. The only measurement left is the one you already know: the size on your T-shirts.

The test I did not planTwo sisters, five sizes apart, the same bra tank

Two sisters in their sixties on a porch, one plus-size and one petite, each wearing the same built-in-bra tank in a different color
Me in the burgundy 3XL and my sister Jeanne in the light blue small, on her porch in October.

My sister Jeanne is 64 and a size 6. We have not been able to share, borrow or even recommend a piece of clothing to each other since about 1975. I ordered her a small without telling her what I wear, because I wanted to know whether a tank that fits a 22 would hang off a 6.

It fit her the way it fits me. Same square neckline, same wide straps, same cups sewn in, five sizes apart. She wears a small. I wear a 3XL. It is the same bra tank. She has since ordered three more and told me this is the first thing I have ever been right about.

The chartBra tank sizes by the top you already wear

Which size a woman orders

From the maker's own chart. No band size, no cup letter.
Tank sizeTop / dress sizeBust
S4–834½–37 in
M10–1237–39½ in
L12–1439½–41½ in
XL16–1841½–44 in
2XL18–2044–46½ in
3XL · Diane22–2446½–49 in
4XL24–2649–51 in
5XL28–3051–53½ in

I have copied the chart out because it is the thing I would have wanted to see before I spent money on the first five. It runs from a small to a 5XL. I am the green row.

1 of 6

bra tanks sold to women over 60 passed all five checks on a size 22.

I set out to prove the number was none. I was wrong by one, and I have never been so pleased to be wrong. I have given away the two beige bras from the back of the catalog.

The one that fitWhich bra tank it was

Pam here again. So many of you asked under Diane's post that we will say it once. Number six was the Freeform Tank. It is made by a small company and sold only through its own order page, not in stores, which is why none of us had seen it on a rack in our size or anybody else's.

We are a discussion group, not a shop. Nobody here is telling you what to wear. One of us spent her own money to prove a point, and this is what she found.

Freeform Tanks

The Freeform Tank

Sizes S to 5XL · sized by top size
As low as $20 a tank today
  • Sized by your top size — no band size, no cup letter to guess
  • Shaped cups sewn in for every size — small to 5XL, nothing loose to fold
  • No band under the bust — nothing to roll up when you sit
  • Straps as wide as three fingers — flat on the shoulder; pulls on, no hooks
See If Your Size Is In Stock →Free US shipping · 45-day guarantee
Put it through Diane's five checks yourself. If it does not pass on you, the company takes it back within 45 days.

Three More Members, Sizes 18, 24 And 28

They read Diane's post, ordered, and reported back under it.

Sharon L., 63, Georgia
Sharon L., 63, GeorgiaDress size 18 · wears the 2XL

“I am an 18 and I have always been told to size up in anything with a bra in it, which only ever gets me a looser body and the same small cups. I ordered the 2XL, my actual size. The cups are my size too. I did not know that was something a person could ask for.”

Brenda T., 71, Ohio
Brenda T., 71, OhioDress size 24 · wears the 4XL

“I read Diane's post twice and still assumed she was just lucky. I am a 24. I ordered the 4XL and it went over my head and down like it had been waiting for me. No band, so nothing rolled when I sat through two hours of bingo. I have ordered again.”

Patricia W., 69, Arizona
Patricia W., 69, ArizonaDress size 28 · wears the 5XL

“Nobody ever tests anything on a 28, so I will say it plainly for the women up here with me. The 5XL fits. The straps are wide and flat, the cups hold all of me, and I put it on by myself, which I have not been able to say about a bra in six years.”

What Members Asked Under Diane's Post

What size bra tank do I order if I wear a 22?

A 3XL, which covers a 22 to 24. You order by the size on your tops, and the chart above shows every size from a small to a 5XL with its bust measurement.

Will a bra tank with no band hold a full bust?

Diane is a 44D and wore hers for four hours at the first sitting. Each size has its own shaped cups sewn into a fitted body, so the whole tank carries the weight and there is no band to roll up.

Do the bra cups move in the wash?

They are stitched into the lining around the whole edge, not slipped into a pocket, so there is nothing loose to fold. Diane washes hers warm with the towels and tumbles low.

Is there a bra tank bigger than a 3XL?

Yes. It goes on to a 4XL and a 5XL, which covers a 28 to 30. Patricia, below Diane's post, wears the 5XL.

What if the bra tank is not right for me?

The company gives 45 days to send it back. Shipping in the US is free.

See The Freeform Tank →Check colors and sizes on the order page

Written by a member of Comfortable After 60 and posted by the group admin. Members' names are shortened for privacy. This is one member's account of what she wore and washed. It is not medical advice.